{
  "harness": "sj-harness 0.8.4",
  "job": "job:6c57ae81203e0b02f946c4ff3862de24",
  "kind": "domain_review",
  "bundle": "sha256:400fcac8029a5c222748333a2e3e9a10e081b147daca45105e5f1fd2798be631",
  "claims": [
    {
      "local_id": "C1",
      "claim_id": "claim:318e0256b6c365dd1f5b0e3cea5935ef22457eebd7ebf8ac33d07b43efc4ca69",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Counts and MH RR 0.98 (0.96-1.01) match results/T.json; inside 0.95-1.05; non-robust random-effects reading is reported honestly. Report in evidence/report.md."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C2",
      "claim_id": "claim:9b1869998d285a5e97b91a25aef1c78ba87639c5b51c0d697419405311a3e1b4",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Deaths 3,411 vs 3,191, RR 0.96 (0.91-1.01); leave-one-out low end 0.89 disclosed as not robust; matches T.json."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C3",
      "claim_id": "claim:62e632c4a0f71bd5317d3e1b2ed8bbb93336594d63c0200ddb4471a6541f9762",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "P4 RR 0.99 (0.97-1.02); random-effects and every leave-one-out interval inside 0.95-1.05; consistent with T.json."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C4",
      "claim_id": "claim:7d157966e5b6c5a6e55d843c5a05284dddd8efa1b49fe1252c95fe43de90b3be",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "61 trials, RR 0.96 (0.90-1.03), p 0.28; 'inconclusive' reading agrees with interval touching margin; excludes most of the observational 10-25% range."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C5",
      "claim_id": "claim:cb7b46b7ac158e471fbd10b6ce137f96b9605b949385f218c49f2878edb31646",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Inert-placebo RR 1.00 (0.97-1.03), death 1.00 (0.94-1.05); other strata consistent with T.json; no prior pool by placebo composition found."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C6",
      "claim_id": "claim:962b061bbf9ae2d1704f51a93fca4320ae4e8622179dc693e166221676875ed7",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Aluminium/inert and mRNA/inert estimates match T.json, but the Discussion's 'within about 5%' fits the serious-event ratio (0.96-1.05) and not death (0.90-1.14); mRNA intervals wide; mixed-age risk difference above zero is traced to follow-up asymmetry in C12."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C7",
      "claim_id": "claim:ff446b8696adfcfaa25ca02c586f97c4603c0f944098a79ef062ff449dab1833",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Subgroup ratios (children 0.92, infants 0.91, older adults 1.00, pregnant 1.03, offspring 0.96) match T.json; wide intervals for pregnancy disclosed."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C8",
      "claim_id": "claim:9920e4e5e6abec93ff04754e47ac468fa8708f772a58e8602fd7f287c61918cb",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Counts match T.json and no outcome has q<0.05 (min q 0.62), but powers are low (GBS detectable only beyond 0.39/2.56) and two outcomes count broader term sets than named; authors disclose and add narrow-term estimates (added after registration). Counts are reports, not people."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C9",
      "claim_id": "claim:4f06e1814c38d7d562f7908a0c8299cffdc54c7b957baf0fcbd54073403c49f9",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "27 organ systems tested; none replicated across halves and none q<0.05 (min q 0.19, infections RR 0.94); matches T.json."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C10",
      "claim_id": "claim:c49309b286491d1297ab1c4ac536a4c256da787f2adfeff2c276d6abafced672",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "known",
      "reason": "Positive controls in expected direction (COVID-19 0.29, dengue 0.55, rotavirus 0.72, injection-site pain 3.38) and negative controls near 1; consistent with Cochrane/COVID pooled SAE findings (Grana 2022)."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C11",
      "claim_id": "claim:381ea60e67394b45a29ff278d1ad1d9020aa9e1beabf52719c6daffd2517c6aa",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match T.json (non-target infections ratio 0.92, 0.86-0.99, p 0.021; children p 0.22); p-values uncorrected over eight between-trial contrasts and the paper says so; the Summary foregrounds the non-target-infection contrast although the all-serious-event contrast is stronger, and target-disease tagging may not remove all target illness."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C12",
      "claim_id": "claim:291534fd421ac139a6a09a427a1c8db2a1a9c5999ffd3eec078c6016f5f4fc66",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Unplanned analysis, coded by same-family models after an excess was seen; 6 trials, one trial supplies 740/955 serious events and 84/91 deaths (registry 61 vs 23 deaths vs published blinded 16 vs 15). Disclosed in Limitations; the flagging was not built to find placebo-longer trials, so estimates excluding flagged trials lean toward vaccine."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C13",
      "claim_id": "claim:fc2bae4bd111b4b27dd50109fb7e345b9d565b02069e0b46c56de18f79c943f4",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Published-count swap gives SAE RR 0.98 (0.95-1.00), p 0.045 vs registry p 0.16, and death 0.94 (0.90-1.00 at margin); only 15 comparisons, usable-count rule set after reviewers of a first version, one count computed from a percentage; all disclosed."
    }
  ]
}
