{
  "harness": "sj-harness 0.8.3",
  "job": "job:1407c09671a519bfbd9eee490fbc9e6a",
  "kind": "methods_review",
  "bundle": "sha256:d6dc513c7d14672cb80c6d16dd01595e959e40803ec7a91af1ad6808a74c480e",
  "claims": [
    {
      "local_id": "C1",
      "claim_id": "claim:c6ccdbf3785bff3693ad3cc1443030b5e4d2e3964553317e261dd9acecc9b037",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Count and exact CI reproduce; verdict sensitivity unknown (no positive control) and 15 of 38 inconclusive; among judged claims 10/23 = 43.5% (23.2-65.5%). See report points 1-2."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C2",
      "claim_id": "claim:356a8fac7b2b3d2b54e8d52bc9ab0f1f038007447ce8234246afb68adace97d8",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Arithmetic correct; controls and overlapping outcome data mean the margin partly measures re-detection in the same data (independent well-powered 0/5)."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C3",
      "claim_id": "claim:f5168307e452efa7437510d7e5623aace607d2743cfbdd718f6fa608b4bc6bb2",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Correct; same overlap caveat as C2; independent-data margin 2.8 pp (CI 0-7.0)."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C4",
      "claim_id": "claim:25ff854661f1309a4ba34654c9f6ada430e2c6d3c3e2a3e0ace4ce04cd8cbc01",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Counts reproduce; 26 failures rest on power at the uncapped claimed OR (22 with inferred units); capping at 1.2 gives 69 failures and 31.0% of judged."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C5",
      "claim_id": "claim:06e272f383f2d5738c021fa1f5cc3f3af09e3c5e6d7604eec79c8b1592521e6e",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Counts right; the no-better-neighbour part relies on a dose-response test that failed calibration (C11), so zero findings bound little."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C6",
      "claim_id": "claim:c2be17d4600cb18c958ae422d6ce91927f01d1824dfbead127d44f302b62dd67",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Counts reproduce; independent stratum n=5 (exact CI 0-52.2%) does not separate strata; no intervals given."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C7",
      "claim_id": "claim:b8c012ac1097ca3d885e0d4dda542952ff9c9bb5720e82b184fab584ae9c7870",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Correct; deduplication check shows duplicates do not drive C1."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C8",
      "claim_id": "claim:4bb89f6b183d983160a31ebfb841a0ebe61d5d0d168ca3d309c814a3f927ea8f",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Band counts reproduce; upper bands overlap heavily, no trend test or band intervals; 4/13 at |z|>=8 supports the sensitivity concern."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C9",
      "claim_id": "claim:f5b77e449c4161770172828e8567abf4d26f90690644cc9514ce40482eae4497",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Correct and useful sensitivity analysis; C1 share ranges 18.7-33.3% with assumed effect."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C10",
      "claim_id": "claim:e170fd20b835294da77d00bd8a95e39f5927147e24ed8420b3a203f1e05f25ca",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Correct; same selection and overlap caveat as C2/C3."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C11",
      "claim_id": "claim:ff16906aaa1fe7884a174f7614067a77f1ac08dc22318a3753ef3fbd1f1650c6",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Gate reported as registered (8 of 76 loci testable, under 30 required); claim correctly limits the test to description."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C12",
      "claim_id": "claim:d9f7c2c9969e8160715939fa433e529ca38f4b0b40cf50a42863722f58747906",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Correct and labelled as uncalibrated description; given no inferential weight."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C13",
      "claim_id": "claim:18201c762a40bc3a5371d7138cdb74bf26de181de24e4c0ae1742c6db24f051d",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Counts reproduce; eligibility coded by model readers with no human-validated sample; window date field unstated."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C14",
      "claim_id": "claim:2097b30eea1f0c719c9b0adeac193b454eb6a1efb1744ed2f12bffb4a14791df",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Correct mechanical mapping to UKB-PPP and Open Targets; depends on C13 coding."
    }
  ]
}
