{
  "scope": "All seven trial programs named by the target; the core sensitivity uses its six-trial one-year composite panel. This is not a certification of every displayed input or a new comprehensive efficacy review.",
  "sources_checked_at_utc": "2026-11-05",
  "trials": [
    {
      "trial": "DEDICATE",
      "one_year_status": "Confirmed endpoint substitution",
      "primary_doi": "10.1056/NEJMoa2400685",
      "primary_url": "https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2400685",
      "location": "Main Table 2; supplementary Table S10 for 30 days",
      "cohort": "Intention to treat; 701 TAVI, 713 SAVR; one year after randomization",
      "target_one_year_composite_events": [37,68],
      "primary_death_or_any_stroke_events": [37,68],
      "primary_death_or_disabling_stroke_events": [26,57],
      "target_30_day_composite_events": [9,21],
      "primary_30_day_death_or_disabling_stroke_events": [9,21],
      "action": "Replace only the one-year and reused longest-follow-up composite rows in the prespecified endpoint sensitivity. The 30-day row already uses the intended endpoint."
    },
    {
      "trial": "UKTAVI",
      "one_year_status": "Confirmed endpoint substitution",
      "primary_doi": "10.1001/jama.2022.5776",
      "primary_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9115619/",
      "location": "Table 3, separately labeled one-year-after-randomization and 30-day-after-procedure sections",
      "cohort": "Intention to treat; 458 TAVI, 455 surgery",
      "target_one_year_composite_events": [39,40],
      "primary_death_or_any_nonfatal_stroke_events": [39,40],
      "primary_death_or_nonfatal_disabling_stroke_events": [30,35],
      "target_30_day_composite_events": [14,11],
      "primary_30_day_death_or_nonfatal_disabling_stroke_events": [14,11],
      "action": "Replace only the one-year and reused longest-follow-up composite rows. The 30-day row already uses the intended endpoint."
    },
    {
      "trial": "Evolut",
      "one_year_status": "Endpoint label agrees, but displayed event counts differ from original observed event totals",
      "primary_doi": "10.1056/NEJMoa1816885",
      "primary_url": "https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1816885",
      "location": "Main Table 2 and Methods; supplementary Figure S3 (appendix updated September 22, 2021)",
      "supplement_url": "https://www.nejm.org/doi/suppl/10.1056/NEJMoa1816885/suppl_file/nejmoa1816885_appendix.pdf",
      "cohort": "As-treated/attempted-procedure population, 725 TAVR and 678 surgery; adaptive interim report before everyone reached one year",
      "target_one_year_composite_events": [21,31],
      "source_observed_composite_events_age_partition": {"tavr":[10,7],"savr":[14,13]},
      "source_observed_composite_events_sex_partition": {"tavr":[10,7],"savr":[21,6]},
      "source_posterior_median_risks_pct": [2.9,4.6],
      "action": "Preserve the target row in the two-endpoint sensitivity. Separately omit it and substitute the observed totals for arithmetic sensitivity only. Neither operation supplies a corrected time-to-event analysis.",
      "limitation": "The target's counts coincide with rounding posterior risks times baseline N, but its extraction code is unavailable; no conclusion about how or why the counts were obtained is justified."
    },
    {
      "trial": "NOTION2",
      "one_year_status": "Endpoint and displayed risks consistent; exact counts are not printed in the inspected one-year Table 2",
      "primary_doi": "10.1093/eurheartj/ehae331",
      "primary_url": "https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article-pdf/45/37/3804/59616526/ehae331.pdf",
      "location": "Main Table 2 and primary-endpoint follow-up statement",
      "cohort": "Intention to treat, 187 TAVI and 183 surgery; all primary-endpoint follow-up reported available at one year",
      "target_one_year_composite_events": [6,3],
      "source_one_year_death_or_disabling_stroke_risks_pct": [3.2,1.6],
      "action": "Preserve the target counts; do not present a percent-to-count conversion as a directly printed source count.",
      "later_report_doi": "10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.125.076678",
      "later_report_note": "Three-year report explicitly describes the same death/disabling-stroke composite, with rates 5.4% versus 4.9%; this is not a common one-year substitute."
    },
    {
      "trial": "PARTNER3",
      "one_year_status": "Current-database one-year composite count not independently resolved",
      "primary_doi": "10.1056/NEJMoa2509766",
      "primary_url": "https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2509766",
      "investigator_presentation_url": "https://resourcelibrary.edwardsconnect.com/api/v3/download/2438b5",
      "location": "Investigator presentation, Additional Clinical Endpoints slide; journal supplement remained restricted",
      "cohort": "Procedure initiated, 496 TAVR and 454 surgery",
      "target_one_year_composite_events": [5,14],
      "target_seven_year_composite_events": [102,68],
      "presentation_seven_year_death_or_disabling_stroke_events": [102,68],
      "action": "Preserve the target inputs. The public presentation verifies its seven-year composite, but not the current-database one-year count. Do not replace a later database lock with an earlier publication's count."
    },
    {
      "trial": "RHEIA",
      "one_year_status": "Confirmed intended composite counts",
      "primary_doi": "10.1093/eurheartj/ehaf133",
      "primary_url": "https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article-pdf/46/22/2079/62838910/ehaf133.pdf",
      "location": "Table 2",
      "cohort": "As treated, 215 TAVI and 205 surgery; one year",
      "target_one_year_composite_events": [4,6],
      "primary_death_or_disabling_stroke_events": [4,6],
      "primary_death_or_any_stroke_events": [9,9],
      "action": "Preserve the target one-year composite counts. Thirty-day composite counts were not independently re-extracted from the supplement in this audit."
    },
    {
      "trial": "NOTION",
      "one_year_status": "Absent from target one-year composite panel; later composite count unresolved",
      "primary_doi": "10.1093/eurheartj/ehae043",
      "primary_url": "https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC10984572",
      "location": "Main report and supplementary tables",
      "cohort": "Intention to treat, 145 TAVI and 135 surgery; ten-year report",
      "target_ten_year_composite_events": [94,88],
      "action": "No role in the core one-year sensitivity. Preserve the target ten-year row descriptively but do not certify it as death/disabling stroke. The inspected source reports a death/any-stroke/MI primary composite and individual outcomes, without resolving this union count."
    }
  ],
  "interpretation": "Only confirmed endpoint substitutions are changed in the core sensitivity. Unresolved counts are openly retained rather than silently repaired. Observed counts under incomplete survival follow-up are not interchangeable with one-year cumulative risks."
}
