{
  "harness": "sj-harness 0.8.4",
  "job": "job:790ed769d8787c949ed362ed410267bd",
  "kind": "methods_review",
  "bundle": "sha256:4244ead10c648da9ce5d02dd62317feb2b4b799b219a5c208c1815a243504025",
  "claims": [
    {
      "local_id": "C1",
      "claim_id": "claim:42fb9c86246ef08b69ed710aee5de007143b44e5203cb64b8aec87bad0c7e5ab",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Numbers match R1 (10 of 37, 27.0%, CI 13.8-44.1). The well-powered rule and joint verdict were registered; the name-matching correction drops one claim and leaves the hold-up count at 10. Fourteen of the 37 are still inconclusive; most re-tests use overlapping outcome data; the pipeline is one Olink cis instrument. The claim states the count, not a survey-wide causal rate."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C2",
      "claim_id": "claim:a4261ffb9e4555ac8a1d7fea878498f0efc1625cc9db344741b0c97e0415fe37",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Numbers match R2 (32.4% vs 0.9%, difference 31.5 pp, CI 16.2-47.7, excludes 0). Control draws are registered and sound. An exploratory split, disclosed after results, attributes most of the margin to overlapping outcome data, so the contrast overstates signal that would appear in new data."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C3",
      "claim_id": "claim:6f897b16acba1bd87e9e158001d6e6649472b36687967d2955007ba23319b6a2",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Numbers match R3 (10.9% vs 0.2%, difference 10.7 pp, CI 7.5-14.2, excludes 0). Same control design and the same overlap caveat as C2, now on all 339 primary claims."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C4",
      "claim_id": "claim:e975439db495f6c647548d77263dead9646a8c8df9da3a8fb3c7412e2f548e97",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Numbers match R4 (31 hold up, 79 fail, 229 inconclusive of 339; 31 of 110 judged either way hold up). The claim is a partition and correctly reports the large inconclusive share."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C5",
      "claim_id": "claim:fc6d6ed72f020a2e6cf0ae463d96552303f19f0680081b784342b068556346a6",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R5 (16 reproduce, 12 colocalise, 13 fail, 14 inconclusive, 0 better-supported neighbours, CI 0-9.5%). The components add up to the joint hold-up rule in C1."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C6",
      "claim_id": "claim:5931f4f22a3dcd7d4804edbf5396645a226e71f957b31973135aee399e1b8433",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R6 (0 of 5 independent, 4 of 18 overlapping, 6 of 14 unknown). The claim states counts only, which is appropriate, but n=5 is too small to support an independence contrast."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C7",
      "claim_id": "claim:b088154f956bed0488ed4a1c23abfa3cc15c5aedca551fc990eddc109de0c5dc",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R7 (10 of 36, 27.8%). Deduplicating one protein-study-direction pair leaves the share essentially that of C1."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C8",
      "claim_id": "claim:4cf2e80f70aa6e81742d941d49d6c743a8db83d3ff29603548c7e974901b3242",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R8. Hold-up rises into the well-powered range, then the three bands at or above expected |z| of 4 have only 22, 24, and 13 claims; the paper correctly says there is no clear further rise and that intervals are wide."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C9",
      "claim_id": "claim:0d172bd78db8f9befb40fefd9d41f19fc6b1784bdb3a067bb4cc120729b51f9d",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R9 (14 of 73 at OR 1.2; 10 of 32 at the similar-power median). Registered sensitivities of the well-powered rule; the correction's shift of one power band is disclosed, and both intervals stay in C1's order of success."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C10",
      "claim_id": "claim:d2f4e53025a2cfc73351bc7f32bded6160c9aa62e79744a769a0554e232370eb",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R10 (40 of 223, 17.9% vs 0.3% of controls, difference 17.6 pp, CI excludes 0). Same control idea as C2/C3, and the same overlap caveat."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C11",
      "claim_id": "claim:680e0c8875eb4c3b70c4637875e373bb690a92a5b1e0e2a5c693ba4d50afdb98",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R11 (8 of 76 judged loci could take the test, below the registered gate of 30; sensitivity 37.5%, CI 0-71.4%; one decoy passed). The claim states the calibration failure and does not use the test in the main verdicts."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C12",
      "claim_id": "claim:52b603fe51e123f7762c45bfafe184dd0ce1542cb9dbe70bf22362b84077b4bb",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R12 (8 pass, 21 fail, 8 cannot run among the 37). The claim notes that calibration failed; the counts are description only and should not be read as a further verdict."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C13",
      "claim_id": "claim:5ef312139069a88f80b3893c4fbd3c3d125a5ffe0466f750c2c887204524a4a8",
      "verdict": "minor_issues",
      "significance": "moderate",
      "reason": "Numbers match R13 (989 eligible of 2,432; 847 fail E2). Two-reader coding under a locked codebook, with audits, is described, but an exploratory re-reading still questioned four directions, and the frame is one PubMed query."
    },
    {
      "local_id": "C14",
      "claim_id": "claim:06ffe3ab42b34bb9eb5d3ca88b15370cdd4fa4941877c2d7548e1e71ce177cab",
      "verdict": "sound",
      "significance": "minor",
      "reason": "Numbers match R14 (638 of 989 testable, 64.5%; 209 not measured in UKB-PPP; 136 with no cis signal). The claim states the limits of that one proteomic resource."
    }
  ]
}
