{
  "all_seven": {
    "common": {
      "k": 7,
      "n": 6583,
      "hr": 0.526304,
      "lower": 0.457986,
      "upper": 0.604813,
      "p": 0.0,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 1.08666829,
      "Q": 6.52000973,
      "i2_percent": 7.9756,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": -0.6418760045,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0709401861,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 23.591781,
        "Moon2020": 3.368547,
        "Ludwig2023": 15.275502,
        "Hariri2024": 11.572411,
        "Adrichem2025": 12.861917,
        "Angellotti2025": 12.532155,
        "Lim2026": 20.797686
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 7,
      "n": 6583,
      "hr": 0.521468,
      "lower": 0.427631,
      "upper": 0.635895,
      "p": 0.00019917,
      "tau2": 0.0093416362,
      "q": 0.82288598,
      "Q": 6.52000973,
      "i2_percent": 7.9756,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6511080663,
      "se_log_effect": 0.081076312,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 21.430289,
        "Moon2020": 4.140999,
        "Ludwig2023": 15.544799,
        "Hariri2024": 12.442781,
        "Adrichem2025": 13.562047,
        "Angellotti2025": 13.279957,
        "Lim2026": 19.599127
      }
    }
  },
  "exclude_mixed_or_unresolved_gradient": {
    "common": {
      "k": 5,
      "n": 5150,
      "hr": 0.518066,
      "lower": 0.435343,
      "upper": 0.616508,
      "p": 0.0,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 1.35626648,
      "Q": 5.42506592,
      "i2_percent": 26.2682,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": -0.6576520602,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0887612173,
      "weights": {
        "Moon2020": 5.273567,
        "Ludwig2023": 23.914283,
        "Hariri2024": 18.116976,
        "Adrichem2025": 20.135739,
        "Lim2026": 32.559436
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 5,
      "n": 5150,
      "hr": 0.510245,
      "lower": 0.372348,
      "upper": 0.699212,
      "p": 0.00405423,
      "tau2": 0.0217410335,
      "q": 0.77671475,
      "Q": 5.42506592,
      "i2_percent": 26.2682,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6728642815,
      "se_log_effect": 0.1134771792,
      "weights": {
        "Moon2020": 7.524374,
        "Ludwig2023": 23.547286,
        "Hariri2024": 19.741579,
        "Adrichem2025": 21.155645,
        "Lim2026": 28.031116
      }
    }
  },
  "exclude_mixed_and_pseudo": {
    "common": {
      "k": 4,
      "n": 4501,
      "hr": 0.56643,
      "lower": 0.464011,
      "upper": 0.691454,
      "p": 2e-08,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.73612018,
      "Q": 2.20836054,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": -0.5684025171,
      "se_log_effect": 0.1017587304,
      "weights": {
        "Moon2020": 6.931087,
        "Hariri2024": 23.81127,
        "Adrichem2025": 26.464545,
        "Lim2026": 42.793099
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 4,
      "n": 4501,
      "hr": 0.56643,
      "lower": 0.409735,
      "upper": 0.783048,
      "p": 0.01133046,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.73612018,
      "Q": 2.20836054,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.5684025171,
      "se_log_effect": 0.1017587304,
      "weights": {
        "Moon2020": 6.931087,
        "Hariri2024": 23.81127,
        "Adrichem2025": 26.464545,
        "Lim2026": 42.793099
      }
    }
  },
  "explicit_moderate": {
    "common": {
      "k": 2,
      "n": 1756,
      "hr": 0.51,
      "lower": 0.384956,
      "upper": 0.675661,
      "p": 2.71e-06,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.0,
      "Q": 0.0,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": -0.6733445533,
      "se_log_effect": 0.14351329,
      "weights": {
        "Hariri2024": 47.361281,
        "Adrichem2025": 52.638719
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 2,
      "n": 1756,
      "hr": 0.51,
      "lower": 0.082344,
      "upper": 3.158713,
      "p": 0.13368562,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.0,
      "Q": 0.0,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6733445533,
      "se_log_effect": 0.14351329,
      "weights": {
        "Hariri2024": 47.361281,
        "Adrichem2025": 52.638719
      }
    }
  },
  "liberal_moderate_with_moon": {
    "common": {
      "k": 3,
      "n": 2011,
      "hr": 0.499565,
      "lower": 0.383771,
      "upper": 0.650297,
      "p": 2.5e-07,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.08563013,
      "Q": 0.17126027,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": -0.6940172379,
      "se_log_effect": 0.1345387744,
      "weights": {
        "Moon2020": 12.115822,
        "Hariri2024": 41.623072,
        "Adrichem2025": 46.261105
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 3,
      "n": 2011,
      "hr": 0.499565,
      "lower": 0.280021,
      "upper": 0.891238,
      "p": 0.03558594,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.08563013,
      "Q": 0.17126027,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6940172379,
      "se_log_effect": 0.1345387744,
      "weights": {
        "Moon2020": 12.115822,
        "Hariri2024": 41.623072,
        "Adrichem2025": 46.261105
      }
    }
  },
  "all_available_alternative_adjustments": {
    "common": {
      "k": 7,
      "n": 6583,
      "hr": 0.580945,
      "lower": 0.507747,
      "upper": 0.664694,
      "p": 0.0,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 1.43801252,
      "Q": 8.62807512,
      "i2_percent": 30.4596,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": -0.5430999766,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0687113746,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 24.107698,
        "Moon2020": 14.666712,
        "Ludwig2023": 8.337152,
        "Hariri2024": 10.856666,
        "Adrichem2025": 10.763356,
        "Angellotti2025": 11.757051,
        "Lim2026": 19.511365
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 7,
      "n": 6583,
      "hr": 0.570183,
      "lower": 0.463647,
      "upper": 0.701198,
      "p": 0.00056028,
      "tau2": 0.0139135977,
      "q": 1.03733048,
      "Q": 8.62807512,
      "i2_percent": 30.4596,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.5617987351,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0845284649,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 20.562461,
        "Moon2020": 14.940032,
        "Ludwig2023": 9.764204,
        "Hariri2024": 11.999728,
        "Adrichem2025": 11.921429,
        "Angellotti2025": 12.738827,
        "Lim2026": 18.073319
      }
    }
  },
  "samad_moon_alternatives": {
    "common": {
      "k": 7,
      "n": 6583,
      "hr": 0.569534,
      "lower": 0.500099,
      "upper": 0.648609,
      "p": 0.0,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 1.68291336,
      "Q": 10.09748019,
      "i2_percent": 40.5792,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": -0.5629375249,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0663339088,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 22.468271,
        "Moon2020": 13.669312,
        "Ludwig2023": 13.356173,
        "Hariri2024": 10.118366,
        "Adrichem2025": 11.245849,
        "Angellotti2025": 10.957521,
        "Lim2026": 18.184508
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 7,
      "n": 6583,
      "hr": 0.559769,
      "lower": 0.451427,
      "upper": 0.694113,
      "p": 0.00058159,
      "tau2": 0.0222727225,
      "q": 0.96212258,
      "Q": 10.09748019,
      "i2_percent": 40.5792,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.5802314593,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0879112786,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 18.46392,
        "Moon2020": 14.190175,
        "Ludwig2023": 13.996225,
        "Hariri2024": 11.752448,
        "Adrichem2025": 12.586972,
        "Angellotti2025": 12.379392,
        "Lim2026": 16.630867
      }
    }
  },
  "samad_ava_definition": {
    "common": {
      "k": 7,
      "n": 5896,
      "hr": 0.513783,
      "lower": 0.442379,
      "upper": 0.596713,
      "p": 0.0,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.98078502,
      "Q": 5.88471015,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": -0.665953761,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0763460695,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 11.502949,
        "Moon2020": 3.901497,
        "Ludwig2023": 17.692297,
        "Hariri2024": 13.403326,
        "Adrichem2025": 14.89685,
        "Angellotti2025": 14.514915,
        "Lim2026": 24.088166
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 7,
      "n": 5896,
      "hr": 0.510735,
      "lower": 0.414205,
      "upper": 0.62976,
      "p": 0.00022626,
      "tau2": 0.0092601614,
      "q": 0.74585829,
      "Q": 5.88471015,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6719043884,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0856135018,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 12.230039,
        "Moon2020": 4.619816,
        "Ludwig2023": 17.366778,
        "Hariri2024": 13.895824,
        "Adrichem2025": 15.147901,
        "Angellotti2025": 14.832306,
        "Lim2026": 21.907336
      }
    }
  },
  "leave_one_out": {
    "Samad2016": {
      "k": 6,
      "n": 5493,
      "hr": 0.502759,
      "lower": 0.392206,
      "upper": 0.644474,
      "p": 0.00084862,
      "tau2": 0.0145237378,
      "q": 0.75787052,
      "Q": 5.71925929,
      "i2_percent": 12.5761,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6876445599,
      "se_log_effect": 0.096602413,
      "weights": {
        "Moon2020": 5.693009,
        "Ludwig2023": 19.659321,
        "Hariri2024": 16.086685,
        "Adrichem2025": 17.393962,
        "Angellotti2025": 17.066456,
        "Lim2026": 24.100567
      }
    },
    "Moon2020": {
      "k": 6,
      "n": 6328,
      "hr": 0.525468,
      "lower": 0.423438,
      "upper": 0.652083,
      "p": 0.00060316,
      "tau2": 0.0104662288,
      "q": 0.91143731,
      "Q": 6.23710085,
      "i2_percent": 19.8345,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6434656001,
      "se_log_effect": 0.083981685,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 22.180502,
        "Ludwig2023": 16.246783,
        "Hariri2024": 13.072259,
        "Adrichem2025": 14.221484,
        "Angellotti2025": 13.932249,
        "Lim2026": 20.346724
      }
    },
    "Ludwig2023": {
      "k": 6,
      "n": 5934,
      "hr": 0.555528,
      "lower": 0.455686,
      "upper": 0.677247,
      "p": 0.00061607,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.66027806,
      "Q": 3.30139029,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.5878353761,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0770704372,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 27.845288,
        "Moon2020": 3.975883,
        "Hariri2024": 13.658872,
        "Adrichem2025": 15.180872,
        "Angellotti2025": 14.791655,
        "Lim2026": 24.547429
      }
    },
    "Hariri2024": {
      "k": 6,
      "n": 5162,
      "hr": 0.520717,
      "lower": 0.409789,
      "upper": 0.661673,
      "p": 0.00091555,
      "tau2": 0.0155736202,
      "q": 0.84968364,
      "Q": 6.4942581,
      "i2_percent": 23.0089,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6525490091,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0931948044,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 23.533976,
        "Moon2020": 5.264737,
        "Ludwig2023": 17.900914,
        "Adrichem2025": 15.877768,
        "Angellotti2025": 15.584442,
        "Lim2026": 21.838163
      }
    },
    "Adrichem2025": {
      "k": 6,
      "n": 6248,
      "hr": 0.520673,
      "lower": 0.408642,
      "upper": 0.66342,
      "p": 0.00096377,
      "tau2": 0.0160805387,
      "q": 0.84019244,
      "Q": 6.49096506,
      "i2_percent": 22.9699,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.652632159,
      "se_log_effect": 0.094252924,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 23.745255,
        "Moon2020": 5.368469,
        "Ludwig2023": 18.12039,
        "Hariri2024": 14.913481,
        "Angellotti2025": 15.796652,
        "Lim2026": 22.055752
      }
    },
    "Angellotti2025": {
      "k": 6,
      "n": 6240,
      "hr": 0.530374,
      "lower": 0.420366,
      "upper": 0.66917,
      "p": 0.00090901,
      "tau2": 0.0124765714,
      "q": 0.84696817,
      "Q": 6.00380334,
      "i2_percent": 16.7195,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.6341732573,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0904295635,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 24.18794,
        "Moon2020": 5.051784,
        "Ludwig2023": 18.003585,
        "Hariri2024": 14.612159,
        "Adrichem2025": 15.846717,
        "Lim2026": 22.297816
      }
    },
    "Lim2026": {
      "k": 6,
      "n": 4093,
      "hr": 0.493961,
      "lower": 0.402398,
      "upper": 0.606358,
      "p": 0.00030724,
      "tau2": 3.35343e-05,
      "q": 0.69503483,
      "Q": 3.47939486,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": -0.7052987022,
      "se_log_effect": 0.0797540974,
      "weights": {
        "Samad2016": 29.771443,
        "Moon2020": 4.256636,
        "Ludwig2023": 19.28746,
        "Hariri2024": 14.615391,
        "Adrichem2025": 16.24258,
        "Angellotti2025": 15.82649
      }
    }
  },
  "trial_secondary_input_replication": {
    "common": {
      "k": 2,
      "n": 922,
      "hr": 1.047526,
      "lower": 0.737337,
      "upper": 1.48821,
      "p": 0.79550679,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.17562264,
      "Q": 0.17562264,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "inverse-variance common effect, normal CI",
      "log_effect": 0.0464316573,
      "se_log_effect": 0.1791576452,
      "weights": {
        "TAVR_UNLOAD": 55.938678,
        "PROGRESS": 44.061322
      }
    },
    "reml": {
      "k": 2,
      "n": 922,
      "hr": 1.047526,
      "lower": 0.10753,
      "upper": 10.204669,
      "p": 0.8385614,
      "tau2": 0.0,
      "q": 0.17562264,
      "Q": 0.17562264,
      "i2_percent": 0,
      "method": "REML with modified Hartung-Knapp (q floored at 1)",
      "log_effect": 0.0464316573,
      "se_log_effect": 0.1791576452,
      "weights": {
        "TAVR_UNLOAD": 55.938678,
        "PROGRESS": 44.061322
      }
    }
  }
}
