{
  "description": "Count-based arithmetic reproduction and audit sensitivities; not an updated clinical survival meta-analysis",
  "reproduction": {
    "mortality": {
      "30_days": {
        "k": 7,
        "n_tavr": 2927,
        "n_savr": 2823,
        "risk_ratio": 0.6406667067345945,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.3532951576577537,
          1.161787305094536
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.11691968018779665,
        "tau2_reml": 0.03777060760851718,
        "hk_scale": 0.7257990960864192,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.3185759335660235,
          1.2884018718039358
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.36609594806649653,
          1.1211646326213842
        ],
        "q": 4.772830253317364,
        "i2_q_pct": 0,
        "q_pvalue": 0.5732620183538801,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6416023533649096,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5085592011412269,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.29717094193228266,
            "weight_pct": 24.33950807847892
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.41563218390804596,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.3582568745125962,
            "weight_pct": 20.585219256004564
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.5586206896551724,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.519029374201788,
            "weight_pct": 14.641366410180556
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 0.48930481283422456,
            "variance_log_rr": 1.4891879255427953,
            "weight_pct": 5.338922029560249
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.3661290322580645,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.6957812277959358,
            "weight_pct": 11.11347849926879
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.9534883720930233,
            "variance_log_rr": 1.9904707884288144,
            "weight_pct": 4.019399548196823
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 1.9868995633187772,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.3706187916886607,
            "weight_pct": 19.9621061783101
          }
        },
        "target_rr_ci": [
          0.64,
          0.35,
          1.16
        ],
        "matches_target_at_2dp": true
      },
      "1_year": {
        "k": 7,
        "n_tavr": 2927,
        "n_savr": 2823,
        "risk_ratio": 0.6102448668001913,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.4419654888195315,
          0.8425970055957137
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.009556379484221963,
        "tau2_reml": 0.0,
        "hk_scale": 0.8019408485466769,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.4256372374016705,
          0.8749206242604977
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.4572743578032672,
          0.8143881044302949
        ],
        "q": 4.811645091280061,
        "i2_q_pct": 0,
        "q_pvalue": 0.5681882443838258,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6102448668001913,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.43590788669248015,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07653602129736203,
            "weight_pct": 28.32439137820603
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.794896551724138,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.10596929281324982,
            "weight_pct": 20.457211369500996
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.6517241379310346,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.2285531837255975,
            "weight_pct": 9.485040577513518
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368982,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.7391879255427953,
            "weight_pct": 2.9327267760296865
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.4160557184750733,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.2866903187050267,
            "weight_pct": 7.561595492827448
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.47674418604651164,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.7404707884288145,
            "weight_pct": 2.9276458378014727
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.6954148471615721,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07657117264104163,
            "weight_pct": 28.31138856812085
          }
        },
        "target_rr_ci": [
          0.61,
          0.44,
          0.84
        ],
        "matches_target_at_2dp": true
      },
      "longest": {
        "k": 7,
        "n_tavr": 2932,
        "n_savr": 2829,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9247437836257357,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.6159332232993379,
          1.3883827548280279
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.654212967750907,
        "tau2_reml": 0.12600736057064515,
        "hk_scale": 0.9532754716406525,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6099020886693967,
          1.4021120459188725
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.6625711717694395,
          1.2906554069817204
        ],
        "q": 18.74334586081148,
        "i2_q_pct": 67.98863957077815,
        "q_pvalue": 0.004619770485673263,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0354808599179528,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.43590788669248015,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07653602129736203,
            "weight_pct": 14.285241380893297
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.15697438951757,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.012906054377247607,
            "weight_pct": 20.82866583599758
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9851643945469126,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.008312958834209839,
            "weight_pct": 21.54090395933311
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.3700534759358287,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.3320450683999382,
            "weight_pct": 6.3167028861509324
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.434005376344086,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.02308619233494286,
            "weight_pct": 19.406480318563027
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.47674418604651164,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.7404707884288145,
            "weight_pct": 3.3392430073718264
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.6954148471615721,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07657117264104163,
            "weight_pct": 14.282762611690238
          }
        },
        "target_rr_ci": [
          0.92,
          0.62,
          1.39
        ],
        "matches_target_at_2dp": true
      }
    },
    "labelled_death_disabling_stroke": {
      "30_days": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2782,
        "n_savr": 2688,
        "risk_ratio": 0.5782847083677889,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.28205460341241245,
          1.1856328522426167
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.10716054582974308,
        "tau2_reml": 0.2069513160946678,
        "hk_scale": 0.8232081303682837,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.262106876831114,
          1.275865814644362
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.31630964910581316,
          1.0572336470840618
        ],
        "q": 7.712947048077225,
        "i2_q_pct": 35.17393586610374,
        "q_pvalue": 0.1727813953661066,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.5868573589990119,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.43590788669248015,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.1559011006624414,
            "weight_pct": 26.115887103778068
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.3117241379310345,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.21936798562370732,
            "weight_pct": 22.227970240065844
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 0.6524064171122994,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.8225212588761286,
            "weight_pct": 9.204920054942221
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.30510752688172044,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.6624478944626024,
            "weight_pct": 10.899725507327759
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 1.9069767441860466,
            "variance_log_rr": 1.4904707884288144,
            "weight_pct": 5.582708464858807
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 1.264390631202858,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.15795645402632302,
            "weight_pct": 25.968788629027298
          }
        },
        "target_rr_ci": [
          0.58,
          0.28,
          1.19
        ],
        "matches_target_at_2dp": true
      },
      "1_year": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2782,
        "n_savr": 2688,
        "risk_ratio": 0.6856587533300034,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.43751109467175164,
          1.0745508668089296
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.08327278448310589,
        "tau2_reml": 0.05091059584287687,
        "hk_scale": 1.1125182876045063,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.43751109467175164,
          1.0745508668089296
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.49552030158273946,
          0.9487561347464889
        ],
        "q": 8.157507258087513,
        "i2_q_pct": 38.706766150371465,
        "q_pvalue": 0.1477660665483896,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6868642785587104,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 30.571311327514
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 21.46229126810915
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 5.083786229674363
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 8.631151816300122
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 5.99444844282827
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 28.257010915574106
          }
        },
        "target_rr_ci": [
          0.69,
          0.44,
          1.07
        ],
        "matches_target_at_2dp": true
      },
      "longest": {
        "k": 7,
        "n_tavr": 2932,
        "n_savr": 2829,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9859212724273494,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.7372663009233701,
          1.3184391504227937
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.9088734563972675,
        "tau2_reml": 0.06509363198032209,
        "hk_scale": 0.8889686341210874,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.7243925774560214,
          1.3418701208099795
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.7702193965563765,
          1.2620310002198378
        ],
        "q": 16.285206506306388,
        "i2_q_pct": 63.15674598491262,
        "q_pvalue": 0.01230231839673574,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0392457917337916,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 15.259034045555332
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 20.764134335125195
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 21.80060589081052
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 5.979446027578678
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 18.585318129605028
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 3.3604334438039887
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 14.25102812752126
          }
        },
        "target_rr_ci": [
          0.99,
          0.74,
          1.32
        ],
        "matches_target_at_2dp": true
      }
    }
  },
  "sensitivities": {
    "1_year_two_endpoint_substitutions": {
      "k": 6,
      "n_tavr": 2782,
      "n_savr": 2688,
      "risk_ratio": 0.6283203746882464,
      "ci_hk": [
        0.3976210135375201,
        0.992871301584582
      ],
      "p_hk": 0.04762517262633599,
      "tau2_reml": 0.04432992725221692,
      "hk_scale": 1.128313140941891,
      "ci_modified_hk": [
        0.3976210135375201,
        0.992871301584582
      ],
      "ci_wald": [
        0.45242472842338444,
        0.8726014924607136
      ],
      "q": 7.571187389630547,
      "i2_q_pct": 33.96016050470537,
      "q_pvalue": 0.18150564612558578,
      "fixed_effect_rr": 0.623892015368384,
      "trial_estimates": {
        "DEDICATE": {
          "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
          "weight_pct": 28.797428663396378
        },
        "Evolut": {
          "rr": 0.633503893214683,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
          "weight_pct": 23.138565505994112
        },
        "NOTION2": {
          "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
          "weight_pct": 5.263047453719069
        },
        "PARTNER3": {
          "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
          "weight_pct": 9.013071329367818
        },
        "RHEIA": {
          "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
          "weight_pct": 6.2195628886073635
        },
        "UKTAVI": {
          "rr": 0.851528384279476,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
          "weight_pct": 27.568324158915242
        }
      }
    },
    "1_year_add_observed_evolut_counts_arithmetic_only": {
      "k": 6,
      "n_tavr": 2782,
      "n_savr": 2688,
      "risk_ratio": 0.6188860079520078,
      "ci_hk": [
        0.38786281189400257,
        0.987513829873039
      ],
      "p_hk": 0.04599256020366217,
      "tau2_reml": 0.047996656592089564,
      "hk_scale": 1.1130074757177644,
      "ci_modified_hk": [
        0.38786281189400257,
        0.987513829873039
      ],
      "ci_wald": [
        0.44151768231229627,
        0.8675074774646359
      ],
      "q": 7.59195429483218,
      "i2_q_pct": 34.14080478061513,
      "q_pvalue": 0.18020403064278073,
      "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6146820136076022,
      "trial_estimates": {
        "DEDICATE": {
          "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
          "weight_pct": 29.34331130205916
        },
        "Evolut": {
          "rr": 0.5888122605363985,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.09300632985028684,
          "weight_pct": 21.05452381206982
        },
        "NOTION2": {
          "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
          "weight_pct": 5.526500265189165
        },
        "PARTNER3": {
          "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
          "weight_pct": 9.418432525225128
        },
        "RHEIA": {
          "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
          "weight_pct": 6.522804288644238
        },
        "UKTAVI": {
          "rr": 0.851528384279476,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
          "weight_pct": 28.134427806812496
        }
      }
    },
    "1_year_two_substitutions_omit_evolut": {
      "k": 5,
      "n_tavr": 2057,
      "n_savr": 2010,
      "risk_ratio": 0.6328100700564507,
      "ci_hk": [
        0.321496629914534,
        1.2455763062626957
      ],
      "p_hk": 0.13388430026361953,
      "tau2_reml": 0.10548179236470143,
      "hk_scale": 1.1156019166135405,
      "ci_modified_hk": [
        0.321496629914534,
        1.2455763062626957
      ],
      "ci_wald": [
        0.40245144374191866,
        0.9950233524858394
      ],
      "q": 7.567265822822508,
      "i2_q_pct": 47.1407494641434,
      "q_pvalue": 0.10877947293125813,
      "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6211110480030142,
      "trial_estimates": {
        "DEDICATE": {
          "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
          "weight_pct": 33.60954759642082
        },
        "NOTION2": {
          "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
          "weight_pct": 8.967041522607804
        },
        "PARTNER3": {
          "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
          "weight_pct": 14.307883979823053
        },
        "RHEIA": {
          "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
          "weight_pct": 10.402317273754312
        },
        "UKTAVI": {
          "rr": 0.851528384279476,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
          "weight_pct": 32.713209627394
        }
      }
    },
    "1_year_original_leave_one_out": {
      "DEDICATE": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2081,
        "n_savr": 1975,
        "risk_ratio": 0.7513156189757085,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.4065151690672555,
          1.3885709618463535
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.2657882491046236,
        "tau2_reml": 0.058580658111946335,
        "hk_scale": 1.1723147744964801,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.4065151690672555,
          1.3885709618463535
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.5033945820708015,
          1.121337375135793
        ],
        "q": 6.238763665609089,
        "i2_q_pct": 35.88473270674085,
        "q_pvalue": 0.18201271689775822,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.7819012277819917,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 30.78454074550408
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 7.620905308200536
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 12.81342781175689
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 8.963560549728117
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 39.817565584810374
          }
        }
      },
      "Evolut": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2057,
        "n_savr": 2010,
        "risk_ratio": 0.7003834814330593,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.3638097850919108,
          1.3483337754105926
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.20565998093195365,
        "tau2_reml": 0.10393450629590875,
        "hk_scale": 1.112867041822449,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.3638097850919108,
          1.3483337754105926
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.45183761948075807,
          1.085648914377707
        ],
        "q": 8.052756553501132,
        "i2_q_pct": 50.32756828764552,
        "q_pvalue": 0.08966465919275403,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6999668489783296,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 35.01161271187335
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 8.431650850691387
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 13.474546645581926
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 9.78531720535355
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 33.296872586499774
          }
        }
      },
      "NOTION2": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2595,
        "n_savr": 2505,
        "risk_ratio": 0.6492077897331822,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.42014047907733354,
          1.0031662628076958
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.051044355435060876,
        "tau2_reml": 0.047307240968833736,
        "hk_scale": 0.8772377766872875,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.40794689393637246,
          1.0331510314574928
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.4676726447313425,
          0.9012089096901533
        ],
        "q": 5.847118976529643,
        "i2_q_pct": 31.59024100491174,
        "q_pvalue": 0.21086013897348269,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6651078054855492,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 32.48229276088703
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 22.523375811252144
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 8.9036000624596
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 6.162100609737831
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 29.928630755663406
          }
        }
      },
      "PARTNER3": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2286,
        "n_savr": 2234,
        "risk_ratio": 0.7336115896392343,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.4643783798367063,
          1.1589384601459087
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.1331504677016367,
        "tau2_reml": 0.044741295167931516,
        "hk_scale": 0.9559927281739538,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.45957084497634537,
          1.1710620252263944
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.5273306208809379,
          1.0205854603207605
        ],
        "q": 5.97528492974614,
        "i2_q_pct": 33.05758558747189,
        "q_pvalue": 0.20100162838610341,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.7169554214765474,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 33.92274168508125
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 23.30301829215327
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 5.314323672866186
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 6.2792788897552025
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 31.1806374601441
          }
        }
      },
      "RHEIA": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2567,
        "n_savr": 2483,
        "risk_ratio": 0.6890261164702656,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.3883832089814714,
          1.2223931884777883
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.1455740985575898,
        "tau2_reml": 0.0650745413512183,
        "hk_scale": 1.2982518804947678,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.3883832089814714,
          1.2223931884777883
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.4830387292348617,
          0.9828549150295172
        ],
        "q": 8.142216650331433,
        "i2_q_pct": 50.87332882701938,
        "q_pvalue": 0.08650535781679579,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6888447616014836,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 31.583732048361252
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 23.111086497043896
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 5.925037123847457
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 9.883179228405119
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 29.496965102342283
          }
        }
      },
      "UKTAVI": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2324,
        "n_savr": 2233,
        "risk_ratio": 0.5862863394761588,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.38277098320956937,
          0.8980086969344764
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.025422247696853754,
        "tau2_reml": 0.0,
        "hk_scale": 1.1067548681466872,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.38277098320956937,
          0.8980086969344764
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.4404099396329511,
          0.7804811856490534
        ],
        "q": 4.427019472586749,
        "i2_q_pct": 9.645755462133474,
        "q_pvalue": 0.3512890041488006,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.5862863394761588,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 54.77142126826508
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 27.664758220653567
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 4.3558295655333605
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 7.974330415146737
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 5.233660530401272
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "1_year_two_substitutions_leave_one_out": {
      "DEDICATE": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2081,
        "n_savr": 1975,
        "risk_ratio": 0.7207162101174978,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.4347774476139185,
          1.1947074494705245
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.14638223754969001,
        "tau2_reml": 0.0,
        "hk_scale": 1.2794176746529993,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.4347774476139185,
          1.1947074494705245
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.5257465898840854,
          0.9879890150892877
        ],
        "q": 5.117670698611997,
        "i2_q_pct": 21.83944150441585,
        "q_pvalue": 0.2754354423082108,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.7207162101174978,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 33.62632548182875
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 5.294481214899885
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 9.692744389834608
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 6.361478782969678
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 45.024970130467075
          }
        }
      },
      "Evolut": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2057,
        "n_savr": 2010,
        "risk_ratio": 0.6328100700564507,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.321496629914534,
          1.2455763062626957
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.13388430026361953,
        "tau2_reml": 0.10548179236470143,
        "hk_scale": 1.1156019166135405,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.321496629914534,
          1.2455763062626957
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.40245144374191866,
          0.9950233524858394
        ],
        "q": 7.567265822822508,
        "i2_q_pct": 47.1407494641434,
        "q_pvalue": 0.10877947293125813,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6211110480030142,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 33.60954759642082
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 8.967041522607804
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 14.307883979823053
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 10.402317273754312
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 32.713209627394
          }
        }
      },
      "NOTION2": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2595,
        "n_savr": 2505,
        "risk_ratio": 0.5914370049481905,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.3894040257863194,
          0.8982899704638212
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.025145406542138024,
        "tau2_reml": 0.035048074263273804,
        "hk_scale": 0.8300078571238537,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.373833710623352,
          0.9357040868219532
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.42782572173053623,
          0.8176173452291964
        ],
        "q": 4.8004765546276795,
        "i2_q_pct": 16.674939363176698,
        "q_pvalue": 0.3083891663168029,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.5981064069766042,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 30.943826854496344
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 24.359577620288192
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 9.032026094570252
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 6.173881367375189
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 29.490688063270028
          }
        }
      },
      "PARTNER3": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2286,
        "n_savr": 2234,
        "risk_ratio": 0.6706466971741055,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.40815903277830423,
          1.1019405582402777
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.08924312661428896,
        "tau2_reml": 0.04528208525083468,
        "hk_scale": 1.0281901350198852,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.40815903277830423,
          1.1019405582402777
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.4746268547727965,
          0.9476223014094715
        ],
        "q": 5.898882910208025,
        "i2_q_pct": 32.190550975711105,
        "q_pvalue": 0.20682809494114626,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6526508165238943,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 31.599754679334612
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 25.438560017224344
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 5.821209838840371
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 6.876940114070681
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 30.263535350529988
          }
        }
      },
      "RHEIA": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2567,
        "n_savr": 2483,
        "risk_ratio": 0.6291253221561056,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.35033253421312693,
          1.1297799442664298
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.09288436767245165,
        "tau2_reml": 0.05970894775100027,
        "hk_scale": 1.3153418902640104,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.35033253421312693,
          1.1297799442664298
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.4387710688328496,
          0.902061915866207
        ],
        "q": 7.570291561744489,
        "i2_q_pct": 47.161876562145984,
        "q_pvalue": 0.10864937874871211,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.6233712585296899,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 29.94483981883252
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 24.72234904511431
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 6.158409758481456
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 10.339975581595269
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 28.834425795976443
          }
        }
      },
      "UKTAVI": {
        "k": 5,
        "n_tavr": 2324,
        "n_savr": 2233,
        "risk_ratio": 0.5450604625140614,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.3311431911882159,
          0.8971674964235679
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.027759673683329402,
        "tau2_reml": 0.0,
        "hk_scale": 1.2896825783745705,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.3311431911882159,
          0.8971674964235679
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.3998623088268293,
          0.742983025001002
        ],
        "q": 5.158730313498282,
        "i2_q_pct": 22.4615407877857,
        "q_pvalue": 0.2713950684361987,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.5450604625140614,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 46.9766697018265
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 0.633503893214683,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.07702287553666176,
            "weight_pct": 32.43253831727373
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.9572192513368984,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.48918792554279533,
            "weight_pct": 5.106518848308844
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 0.32690092165898615,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.26720979922450716,
            "weight_pct": 9.348636799246094
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 6.135636333344841
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "longest_two_endpoint_substitutions": {
      "k": 7,
      "n_tavr": 2932,
      "n_savr": 2829,
      "risk_ratio": 0.943805685757226,
      "ci_hk": [
        0.6683499823549273,
        1.3327885030071336
      ],
      "p_hk": 0.6959974792769849,
      "tau2_reml": 0.09703380164097276,
      "hk_scale": 0.9105218845514478,
      "ci_modified_hk": [
        0.6573733720587238,
        1.3550429791185614
      ],
      "ci_wald": [
        0.706431295396538,
        1.2609423991722453
      ],
      "q": 18.890781374558976,
      "i2_q_pct": 68.23847631797561,
      "q_pvalue": 0.004352118091227786,
      "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0362062026199799,
      "trial_estimates": {
        "DEDICATE": {
          "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
          "weight_pct": 14.544025264808907
        },
        "Evolut": {
          "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
          "weight_pct": 20.160149188526475
        },
        "NOTION": {
          "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
          "weight_pct": 20.859572553535205
        },
        "NOTION2": {
          "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
          "weight_pct": 7.347523765655437
        },
        "PARTNER3": {
          "rr": 1.372983870967742,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
          "weight_pct": 18.620611111428953
        },
        "RHEIA": {
          "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
          "weight_pct": 4.33317065677824
        },
        "UKTAVI": {
          "rr": 0.851528384279476,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
          "weight_pct": 14.134947459266785
        }
      }
    },
    "longest_original_leave_one_out": {
      "DEDICATE": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2231,
        "n_savr": 2116,
        "risk_ratio": 1.1058774257184647,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.9394053403404795,
          1.3018500408678166
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.17366704559041454,
        "tau2_reml": 0.006782868526072645,
        "hk_scale": 0.7544380933969563,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.9165008612464407,
          1.3343848679536063
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.9583188952500964,
          1.2761564931833431
        ],
        "q": 5.194769001107302,
        "i2_q_pct": 3.7493293939689214,
        "q_pvalue": 0.3925758810492733,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0975943690912888,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 29.474789571884784
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 36.87053093968196
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 2.578286077903137
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 19.720704749137987
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 1.289901371451758
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 10.065787289940356
          }
        }
      },
      "Evolut": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2202,
        "n_savr": 2145,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9375815993144482,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.6546815670617387,
          1.3427279758590487
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.6639563607671016,
        "tau2_reml": 0.08304699220365072,
        "hk_scale": 0.8237784163809072,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6311820066230546,
          1.3927191303759987
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.6933891516609011,
          1.2677718612519315
        ],
        "q": 14.50178822992804,
        "i2_q_pct": 65.5214934825675,
        "q_pvalue": 0.012717363849942575,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.9928283068228896,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 19.431456008045703
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 26.11365149185802
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 8.363210384411586
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 22.93136989663484
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 4.8342669049987705
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 18.32604531405108
          }
        }
      },
      "NOTION": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2787,
        "n_savr": 2694,
        "risk_ratio": 0.97360699332467,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.666247923920886,
          1.4227595215189954
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.8632889596126347,
        "tau2_reml": 0.09544258782214067,
        "hk_scale": 0.8248801930040226,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6411935387434352,
          1.478353289879294
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.7080725007333454,
          1.3387196600192213
        ],
        "q": 15.863894098941712,
        "i2_q_pct": 68.48188743056755,
        "q_pvalue": 0.007243598899441339,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0705960779010426,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 19.65127825923536
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 24.725848656244864
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 8.926978957543334
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 22.811688332818314
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 5.25305231628565
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 18.631153477872466
          }
        }
      },
      "NOTION2": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2745,
        "n_savr": 2646,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9762265403228679,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.6907287013936693,
          1.3797287648650918
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.8651261719188276,
        "tau2_reml": 0.07468212264188454,
        "hk_scale": 0.9679221928078412,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6868125127959014,
          1.3875959454366587
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.7466440602303646,
          1.276402383401695
        ],
        "q": 16.274826392584814,
        "i2_q_pct": 69.27770607569667,
        "q_pvalue": 0.006101701330670282,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.038506048131467,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 16.473750103524424
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 21.75454874064791
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 22.71406567091066
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 19.70227231902904
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 3.88358430550496
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 15.471778860383004
          }
        }
      },
      "PARTNER3": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2436,
        "n_savr": 2375,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9173892862928515,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.6732852749163889,
          1.2499948149161897
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.5057715171659883,
        "tau2_reml": 0.05582128100161739,
        "hk_scale": 0.8263136787040815,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6527573998117072,
          1.2893045760150312
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.7077188506696779,
          1.189177173687746
        ],
        "q": 11.772764824742485,
        "i2_q_pct": 57.529093000383035,
        "q_pvalue": 0.038037638630465255,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.9882764191918183,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 18.503892118851596
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 26.101440895672585
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 27.594523877190795
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 6.843594625074677
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 3.7860472059698687
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 17.170501277240483
          }
        }
      },
      "RHEIA": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2717,
        "n_savr": 2624,
        "risk_ratio": 1.0006578140035793,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.7217163908198793,
          1.38740933899106
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.9960726738019278,
        "tau2_reml": 0.06714621168259742,
        "hk_scale": 0.9619717387689395,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.7171146837406535,
          1.3963123101918673
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.7761756938644174,
          1.2900636655356696
        ],
        "q": 15.68709039471001,
        "i2_q_pct": 68.12665781739807,
        "q_pvalue": 0.007796616894904109,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0431775546158792,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 15.840777231279167
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 21.40628177915444
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 22.445503056165986
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 6.281343316860196
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 19.212813189654586
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.9686135371179039,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.04625981732968633,
            "weight_pct": 14.813281426885617
          }
        }
      },
      "UKTAVI": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2474,
        "n_savr": 2374,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9817066420563363,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.681055073502915,
          1.4150807600633821
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.9017874483312481,
        "tau2_reml": 0.08687072876948203,
        "hk_scale": 0.8810860574967398,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6649749108002163,
          1.4492996884615907
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.7294433336744861,
          1.321210142812272
        ],
        "q": 16.170413715176174,
        "i2_q_pct": 69.07933162336208,
        "q_pvalue": 0.006374007821227585,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0445195280696142,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.5534320718301586,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.03890385131225088,
            "weight_pct": 18.258098579293854
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 23.384452178553293
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 24.282924348453783
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 7.996679868146518
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 21.429329561830418
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 4.648515463722134
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "longest_two_substitutions_leave_one_out": {
      "DEDICATE": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2231,
        "n_savr": 2116,
        "risk_ratio": 1.0965021701829814,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.9130997322958347,
          1.316742264498277
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.2522653723976157,
        "tau2_reml": 0.008951479593911908,
        "hk_scale": 0.8405383662562269,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.8980596395827114,
          1.338794169365691
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.9416748777862183,
          1.2767856906648214
        ],
        "q": 5.967110335741933,
        "i2_q_pct": 16.20734796789517,
        "q_pvalue": 0.3094323947143018,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0911894781201759,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 29.738480997905445
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 36.22846510694619
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 2.8825935505662215
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 20.62696264917336
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 1.4496520774792667
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 9.073845617929504
          }
        }
      },
      "Evolut": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2202,
        "n_savr": 2145,
        "risk_ratio": 0.888146195961197,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.5821390531203781,
          1.3550090157535466
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.5027347758788145,
        "tau2_reml": 0.12017727055230455,
        "hk_scale": 0.8466512808029186,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.5611816783690272,
          1.4056119360362225
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.6258418248954529,
          1.2603882227464023
        ],
        "q": 16.994476135999935,
        "i2_q_pct": 70.57867532963643,
        "q_pvalue": 0.00451028505975013,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.9865222490218386,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 18.39937428487773
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 24.943044672922642
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 9.952679475068248
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 22.70688769947829
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 6.048755723744725
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 17.949258143908377
          }
        }
      },
      "NOTION": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2787,
        "n_savr": 2694,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9199835039048219,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.5893702585388172,
          1.4360576143684889
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.650535901170058,
        "tau2_reml": 0.13743759986565607,
        "hk_scale": 0.847274180618172,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.5671265847539,
          1.4923822480024784
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.63619070343685,
          1.3303709766343768
        ],
        "q": 18.51460654433011,
        "i2_q_pct": 72.99429513650026,
        "q_pvalue": 0.0023660268464365903,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0671722502422858,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 18.580872236007767
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 23.80718791206052
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 10.486790240888213
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 22.45485317595241
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 6.503737605271898
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 18.166558829819184
          }
        }
      },
      "NOTION2": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2745,
        "n_savr": 2646,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9276983040781519,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.6141497792622084,
          1.4013261462429667
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.6596628151875169,
        "tau2_reml": 0.11346695659384708,
        "hk_scale": 0.9658076539535477,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6097207549127691,
          1.4115054087548748
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.6736416004713934,
          1.277569768237652
        ],
        "q": 18.87900707249332,
        "i2_q_pct": 73.51555629594,
        "q_pvalue": 0.0020244629494428797,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0353923388712212,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 15.99700239723926
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 21.360791420751347
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 22.001359456223533
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 19.92997389866071
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 5.120573617753775
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 15.59029920937138
          }
        }
      },
      "PARTNER3": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2436,
        "n_savr": 2375,
        "risk_ratio": 0.8687552959860356,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.5968421429884626,
          1.2645483787802394
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.37959826685557835,
        "tau2_reml": 0.08819567142264677,
        "hk_scale": 0.8509129663487874,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.5782995252684642,
          1.3050949055395005
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.6369962588346555,
          1.1848354740489777
        ],
        "q": 14.252950424250939,
        "i2_q_pct": 64.91954401600485,
        "q_pvalue": 0.014080017561715211,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 0.9827390270192861,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 17.729542257922006
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 25.183693110259775
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 26.137926151956854
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 8.688065954754098
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 5.060152283747763
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 17.200620241359516
          }
        }
      },
      "RHEIA": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2717,
        "n_savr": 2624,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9598514908962368,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.6469897743324516,
          1.424002234851886
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.8001014767753466,
        "tau2_reml": 0.10172411340865486,
        "hk_scale": 0.9942556067947613,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6462540241269403,
          1.425623439359442
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.7099257706871307,
          1.2977622768701524
        ],
        "q": 18.299609173844257,
        "i2_q_pct": 72.67701210173094,
        "q_pvalue": 0.0025934268146448306,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0402438967458891,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 15.288543005688645
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 20.94723779399402
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 21.642817061677782
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 7.8411282171743775
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 19.409084353805465
          },
          "UKTAVI": {
            "rr": 0.851528384279476,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05752355359342259,
            "weight_pct": 14.871189567659702
          }
        }
      },
      "UKTAVI": {
        "k": 6,
        "n_tavr": 2474,
        "n_savr": 2374,
        "risk_ratio": 0.9522786122458039,
        "ci_hk": [
          0.619698200069893,
          1.4633486998001872
        ],
        "p_hk": 0.7816030966569992,
        "tau2_reml": 0.12347104203196416,
        "hk_scale": 0.9115122191787195,
        "ci_modified_hk": [
          0.6072022616715487,
          1.493463731252247
        ],
        "ci_wald": [
          0.6757034200856569,
          1.3420600346019227
        ],
        "q": 18.181335604468725,
        "i2_q_pct": 72.49927008238565,
        "q_pvalue": 0.0027275196025860716,
        "fixed_effect_rr": 1.0483158182924754,
        "trial_estimates": {
          "DEDICATE": {
            "rr": 0.4639487449007684,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.05317634004294394,
            "weight_pct": 17.347889828438152
          },
          "Evolut": {
            "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
            "weight_pct": 22.732953691108378
          },
          "NOTION": {
            "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
            "weight_pct": 23.362676565083653
          },
          "NOTION2": {
            "rr": 1.0873440285204992,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.20029903665390647,
            "weight_pct": 9.464924415361857
          },
          "PARTNER3": {
            "rr": 1.372983870967742,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
            "weight_pct": 21.31618752285044
          },
          "RHEIA": {
            "rr": 0.6356589147286821,
            "variance_log_rr": 0.40713745509548116,
            "weight_pct": 5.775367977157521
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "mortality_at_least_5_years_descriptive": {
      "k": 3,
      "n_tavr": 1371,
      "n_savr": 1273,
      "risk_ratio": 1.1466100650954858,
      "ci_hk": [
        0.7290603385776402,
        1.8033001821813757
      ],
      "p_hk": 0.32325079389682776,
      "tau2_reml": 0.018431907654995746,
      "hk_scale": 1.0342855110547027,
      "ci_modified_hk": [
        0.7290603385776402,
        1.8033001821813757
      ],
      "ci_wald": [
        0.9361233169733849,
        1.404424628187798
      ],
      "q": 4.686608757122499,
      "i2_q_pct": 57.325219499910474,
      "q_pvalue": 0.09600986056586847,
      "fixed_effect_rr": 1.1097852205598704,
      "trial_estimates": {
        "Evolut": {
          "rr": 1.15697438951757,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.012906054377247607,
          "weight_pct": 34.170045249935896
        },
        "NOTION": {
          "rr": 0.9851643945469126,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.008312958834209839,
          "weight_pct": 40.03832216230051
        },
        "PARTNER3": {
          "rr": 1.434005376344086,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.02308619233494286,
          "weight_pct": 25.791632587763605
        }
      }
    },
    "labelled_death_disabling_stroke_at_least_5_years_descriptive": {
      "k": 3,
      "n_tavr": 1371,
      "n_savr": 1273,
      "risk_ratio": 1.1409387811641545,
      "ci_hk": [
        0.7719544434861182,
        1.686292906723524
      ],
      "p_hk": 0.2836076939384541,
      "tau2_reml": 0.012403492345950697,
      "hk_scale": 1.0096871761616986,
      "ci_modified_hk": [
        0.7719544434861182,
        1.686292906723524
      ],
      "ci_wald": [
        0.9557511816739824,
        1.3620085722356818
      ],
      "q": 4.061134455877915,
      "i2_q_pct": 50.75267707265185,
      "q_pvalue": 0.1312610450959659,
      "fixed_effect_rr": 1.1145125601852037,
      "trial_estimates": {
        "Evolut": {
          "rr": 1.1730773379354977,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.011331472606339928,
          "weight_pct": 34.4030467671722
        },
        "NOTION": {
          "rr": 0.9945141065830719,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.007697975104431451,
          "weight_pct": 40.621666616450135
        },
        "PARTNER3": {
          "rr": 1.372983870967742,
          "variance_log_rr": 0.020291031717504394,
          "weight_pct": 24.975286616377666
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "endpoint_audit": {
    "confirmed_substituted_trial_rows": 2,
    "unique_extra_any_stroke_events_tavr": 20,
    "unique_extra_any_stroke_events_savr": 16,
    "published_displayed_weight_1_year_pct": 58.900000000000006,
    "calculated_weight_1_year_pct": 58.82832224308811,
    "longest_includes_1_year_trials": [
      "DEDICATE",
      "RHEIA",
      "UKTAVI"
    ],
    "longest_horizon_min_years": 1,
    "longest_horizon_max_years": 10
  }
}
