{ "primary": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.762, "se_g": 0.211, "ci95_low_g": -1.203, "ci95_high_g": -0.321, "p_two_sided": 0.00176804294708, "p_display": "0.00177", "tau2": 0.737017, "Q": 115.583691, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948377e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 82.7, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.033599, "prediction95_low_g": -2.613, "prediction95_high_g": 1.088, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, "sensitivity": { "REML_normal": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "normal", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.762, "se_g": 0.208, "ci95_low_g": -1.17, "ci95_high_g": -0.355, "p_two_sided": 0.000247362759652, "p_display": "<0.001", "tau2": 0.737017, "Q": 115.583691, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948377e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 82.7, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.033599, "prediction95_low_g": -2.611, "prediction95_high_g": 1.087, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, "REML_unmodified_HK": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "HK", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.762, "se_g": 0.211, "ci95_low_g": -1.203, "ci95_high_g": -0.321, "p_two_sided": 0.00176804294708, "p_display": "0.00177", "tau2": 0.737017, "Q": 115.583691, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948377e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 82.7, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.033599, "prediction95_low_g": -2.613, "prediction95_high_g": 1.088, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, "fixed_normal": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "fixed", "interval_method": "normal", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.566, "se_g": 0.068, "ci95_low_g": -0.699, "ci95_high_g": -0.433, "p_two_sided": 6.92908535271e-17, "p_display": "<0.001", "tau2": 0.0, "Q": 115.583691, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948377e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 82.7, "hk_multiplier_raw": 5.779185, "prediction95_low_g": -0.708, "prediction95_high_g": -0.424, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, "DL_normal": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "DL", "interval_method": "normal", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.761, "se_g": 0.183, "ci95_low_g": -1.119, "ci95_high_g": -0.402, "p_two_sided": 3.15706983874e-05, "p_display": "<0.001", "tau2": 0.533221, "Q": 115.583691, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948377e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 82.7, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.320974, "prediction95_low_g": -2.336, "prediction95_high_g": 0.815, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, "low_randomization_and_allocation": { "status": "estimated", "k": 8, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 304, "n_control": 263, "n_total": 567, "g": -0.551, "se_g": 0.136, "ci95_low_g": -0.874, "ci95_high_g": -0.228, "p_two_sided": 0.00495621769685, "p_display": "0.00496", "tau2": 0.042822, "Q": 8.642195, "Q_p_value": 0.279375551179, "Q_p_display": "0.279", "I2_percent": 19.0, "hk_multiplier_raw": 0.642817, "prediction95_low_g": -1.157, "prediction95_high_g": 0.056, "interval_excludes_zero": true, "studies": [ "Armstrong 2004", "Blumenthal 2012", "Chin 2022", "Daley 2008", "Knubben 2007", "Kruisdijk 2019", "Ma 2019", "Shachar-Malach 2015" ] }, "low_blinded_assessor": { "status": "estimated", "k": 11, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 404, "n_control": 322, "n_total": 726, "g": -0.841, "se_g": 0.249, "ci95_low_g": -1.397, "ci95_high_g": -0.285, "p_two_sided": 0.00710090576587, "p_display": "0.0071", "tau2": 0.54825, "Q": 61.835505, "Q_p_value": 1.6261814161e-09, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.83, "hk_multiplier_raw": 0.989649, "prediction95_low_g": -2.609, "prediction95_high_g": 0.926, "interval_excludes_zero": true, "studies": [ "Abdelbasset 2019", "Blumenthal 2012", "Chin 2022", "Gary 2010", "Knubben 2007", "Kruisdijk 2019", "Ma 2019", "Maharaj 2023", "Mota-Pereira 2011", "Shachar-Malach 2015", "Williams 2008" ] }, "overall_low_risk": { "k": 0, "status": "insufficient studies; no pooled estimate", "studies": [] }, "lexicographic_measure": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.867, "se_g": 0.226, "ci95_low_g": -1.338, "ci95_high_g": -0.395, "p_two_sided": 0.00103253916411, "p_display": "0.00103", "tau2": 0.848702, "Q": 126.688513, "Q_p_value": 1.62489796065e-17, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 84.21, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.041277, "prediction95_low_g": -2.852, "prediction95_high_g": 1.119, "interval_excludes_zero": true, "changed_measures": [ { "studyID": "Buschert 2018", "outcome": "BDI-II" }, { "studyID": "Mota-Pereira 2011", "outcome": "BDI" }, { "studyID": "Shachar-Malach 2015", "outcome": "BDI" } ] }, "usual_care_only": { "status": "estimated", "k": 8, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 307, "n_control": 276, "n_total": 583, "g": -0.706, "se_g": 0.399, "ci95_low_g": -1.65, "ci95_high_g": 0.237, "p_two_sided": 0.11998553063, "p_display": "0.12", "tau2": 1.082521, "Q": 63.677891, "Q_p_value": 2.77128071747e-11, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 89.01, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.021508, "prediction95_low_g": -3.433, "prediction95_high_g": 2.02, "interval_excludes_zero": false, "studies": [ "Abdelbasset 2019", "Brown 1992", "Daley 2008", "Gary 2010", "Kruisdijk 2019", "Ma 2019", "Mota-Pereira 2011", "Nabkasorn 2006" ] }, "published_arm_change": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.903, "se_g": 0.24, "ci95_low_g": -1.405, "ci95_high_g": -0.402, "p_two_sided": 0.00123759500387, "p_display": "0.00124", "tau2": 0.714848, "Q": 59.18761, "Q_p_value": 9.50573964272e-06, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 66.21, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.129549, "prediction95_low_g": -2.743, "prediction95_high_g": 0.937, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, "arm_change_r_0": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.907, "se_g": 0.238, "ci95_low_g": -1.404, "ci95_high_g": -0.41, "p_two_sided": 0.00110337652422, "p_display": "0.0011", "tau2": 0.633911, "Q": 51.395451, "Q_p_value": 0.00013940170587, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 61.09, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.137737, "prediction95_low_g": -2.646, "prediction95_high_g": 0.832, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, "arm_change_r_0p5": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.9, "se_g": 0.243, "ci95_low_g": -1.406, "ci95_high_g": -0.393, "p_two_sided": 0.00140804875265, "p_display": "0.00141", "tau2": 0.821963, "Q": 73.19966, "Q_p_value": 5.42421398074e-08, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 72.68, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.118277, "prediction95_low_g": -2.864, "prediction95_high_g": 1.065, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, "arm_change_r_0p8": { "status": "estimated", "k": 21, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 534, "n_control": 460, "n_total": 994, "g": -0.892, "se_g": 0.246, "ci95_low_g": -1.405, "ci95_high_g": -0.38, "p_two_sided": 0.00165845909455, "p_display": "0.00166", "tau2": 0.946124, "Q": 104.665538, "Q_p_value": 1.82538397632e-13, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 80.89, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.103336, "prediction95_low_g": -2.992, "prediction95_high_g": 1.207, "interval_excludes_zero": true } }, "leave_one_out": [ { "omitted": "Abdelbasset 2019", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 488, "n_control": 437, "n_total": 925, "g": -0.628, "se_g": 0.174, "ci95_low_g": -0.992, "ci95_high_g": -0.264, "p_two_sided": 0.00187761955364, "p_display": "0.00188", "tau2": 0.375689, "Q": 63.483409, "Q_p_value": 1.07458652672e-06, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 70.07, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.119191, "prediction95_low_g": -1.967, "prediction95_high_g": 0.711, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Armstrong 2004", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 525, "n_control": 450, "n_total": 975, "g": -0.747, "se_g": 0.221, "ci95_low_g": -1.211, "ci95_high_g": -0.283, "p_two_sided": 0.00319532468812, "p_display": "0.0032", "tau2": 0.778666, "Q": 114.41585, "Q_p_value": 1.21632957983e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.39, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.035926, "prediction95_low_g": -2.658, "prediction95_high_g": 1.164, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Blumenthal 2012", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 498, "n_control": 437, "n_total": 935, "g": -0.766, "se_g": 0.223, "ci95_low_g": -1.234, "ci95_high_g": -0.299, "p_two_sided": 0.0027785363671, "p_display": "0.00278", "tau2": 0.793092, "Q": 115.365608, "Q_p_value": 8.10465847137e-16, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.53, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.026412, "prediction95_low_g": -2.695, "prediction95_high_g": 1.162, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Brown 1992", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 528, "n_control": 457, "n_total": 985, "g": -0.815, "se_g": 0.21, "ci95_low_g": -1.255, "ci95_high_g": -0.374, "p_two_sided": 0.00102615709053, "p_display": "0.00103", "tau2": 0.708995, "Q": 112.303683, "Q_p_value": 2.99420861214e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.08, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.021286, "prediction95_low_g": -2.638, "prediction95_high_g": 1.009, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Buschert 2018", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 519, "n_control": 445, "n_total": 964, "g": -0.813, "se_g": 0.216, "ci95_low_g": -1.265, "ci95_high_g": -0.36, "p_two_sided": 0.00133866438787, "p_display": "0.00134", "tau2": 0.730753, "Q": 111.026418, "Q_p_value": 5.15539951173e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 82.89, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.035773, "prediction95_low_g": -2.665, "prediction95_high_g": 1.04, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Chin 2022", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 497, "n_control": 451, "n_total": 948, "g": -0.76, "se_g": 0.223, "ci95_low_g": -1.227, "ci95_high_g": -0.294, "p_two_sided": 0.00290891420315, "p_display": "0.00291", "tau2": 0.789138, "Q": 115.188308, "Q_p_value": 8.74314590578e-16, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.51, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.030744, "prediction95_low_g": -2.684, "prediction95_high_g": 1.164, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "D'Amato 1990", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 521, "n_control": 440, "n_total": 961, "g": -0.81, "se_g": 0.217, "ci95_low_g": -1.265, "ci95_high_g": -0.356, "p_two_sided": 0.00141085902332, "p_display": "0.00141", "tau2": 0.736673, "Q": 111.419083, "Q_p_value": 4.36279778802e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 82.95, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.035187, "prediction95_low_g": -2.67, "prediction95_high_g": 1.05, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Daley 2008", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 518, "n_control": 445, "n_total": 963, "g": -0.791, "se_g": 0.221, "ci95_low_g": -1.253, "ci95_high_g": -0.329, "p_two_sided": 0.00199160527089, "p_display": "0.00199", "tau2": 0.771438, "Q": 114.631734, "Q_p_value": 1.10916204976e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.43, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.03152, "prediction95_low_g": -2.693, "prediction95_high_g": 1.112, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Fetsch 1980", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 526, "n_control": 452, "n_total": 978, "g": -0.81, "se_g": 0.216, "ci95_low_g": -1.261, "ci95_high_g": -0.358, "p_two_sided": 0.00133943293085, "p_display": "0.00134", "tau2": 0.731423, "Q": 112.718335, "Q_p_value": 2.50942596694e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.14, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.034154, "prediction95_low_g": -2.663, "prediction95_high_g": 1.043, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Gary 2010", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 516, "n_control": 445, "n_total": 961, "g": -0.794, "se_g": 0.22, "ci95_low_g": -1.255, "ci95_high_g": -0.333, "p_two_sided": 0.001899694928, "p_display": "0.0019", "tau2": 0.767468, "Q": 114.226614, "Q_p_value": 1.31872048349e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.37, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.031695, "prediction95_low_g": -2.692, "prediction95_high_g": 1.104, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Knubben 2007", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 515, "n_control": 442, "n_total": 957, "g": -0.757, "se_g": 0.223, "ci95_low_g": -1.223, "ci95_high_g": -0.29, "p_two_sided": 0.0030274636345, "p_display": "0.00303", "tau2": 0.790015, "Q": 114.784138, "Q_p_value": 1.03922513138e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.45, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.02925, "prediction95_low_g": -2.682, "prediction95_high_g": 1.168, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Kruisdijk 2019", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 522, "n_control": 453, "n_total": 975, "g": -0.766, "se_g": 0.222, "ci95_low_g": -1.231, "ci95_high_g": -0.301, "p_two_sided": 0.00269367331337, "p_display": "0.00269", "tau2": 0.784205, "Q": 115.522751, "Q_p_value": 7.57772525249e-16, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.55, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.035666, "prediction95_low_g": -2.684, "prediction95_high_g": 1.152, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Legrand 2016", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 520, "n_control": 449, "n_total": 969, "g": -0.733, "se_g": 0.22, "ci95_low_g": -1.194, "ci95_high_g": -0.272, "p_two_sided": 0.00351178271623, "p_display": "0.00351", "tau2": 0.766039, "Q": 112.300549, "Q_p_value": 2.99820715442e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.08, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.034556, "prediction95_low_g": -2.629, "prediction95_high_g": 1.163, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Ma 2019", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 365, "n_control": 285, "n_total": 650, "g": -0.793, "se_g": 0.222, "ci95_low_g": -1.257, "ci95_high_g": -0.329, "p_two_sided": 0.00200960026111, "p_display": "0.00201", "tau2": 0.77609, "Q": 102.234817, "Q_p_value": 2.10509712463e-13, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 81.42, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.026508, "prediction95_low_g": -2.702, "prediction95_high_g": 1.115, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Maharaj 2023", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 509, "n_control": 436, "n_total": 945, "g": -0.768, "se_g": 0.223, "ci95_low_g": -1.235, "ci95_high_g": -0.301, "p_two_sided": 0.00271900148843, "p_display": "0.00272", "tau2": 0.79202, "Q": 115.479945, "Q_p_value": 7.71778241498e-16, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.55, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.027161, "prediction95_low_g": -2.696, "prediction95_high_g": 1.159, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Mota-Pereira 2011", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 515, "n_control": 450, "n_total": 965, "g": -0.759, "se_g": 0.223, "ci95_low_g": -1.225, "ci95_high_g": -0.293, "p_two_sided": 0.00292646528676, "p_display": "0.00293", "tau2": 0.787953, "Q": 115.169091, "Q_p_value": 8.81528954836e-16, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.5, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.031852, "prediction95_low_g": -2.682, "prediction95_high_g": 1.163, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Nabkasorn 2006", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 513, "n_control": 432, "n_total": 945, "g": -0.764, "se_g": 0.223, "ci95_low_g": -1.231, "ci95_high_g": -0.297, "p_two_sided": 0.00283354923946, "p_display": "0.00283", "tau2": 0.792519, "Q": 115.270232, "Q_p_value": 8.4421206882e-16, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.52, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.027263, "prediction95_low_g": -2.692, "prediction95_high_g": 1.164, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Norouzi 2020", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 514, "n_control": 440, "n_total": 954, "g": -0.644, "se_g": 0.178, "ci95_low_g": -1.016, "ci95_high_g": -0.272, "p_two_sided": 0.00181528055888, "p_display": "0.00182", "tau2": 0.458971, "Q": 82.507, "Q_p_value": 6.84928837137e-10, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 76.97, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.01506, "prediction95_low_g": -2.115, "prediction95_high_g": 0.828, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Shachar-Malach 2015", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 528, "n_control": 454, "n_total": 982, "g": -0.764, "se_g": 0.222, "ci95_low_g": -1.228, "ci95_high_g": -0.3, "p_two_sided": 0.00269703789371, "p_display": "0.0027", "tau2": 0.779528, "Q": 115.513805, "Q_p_value": 7.60678268712e-16, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.55, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.040838, "prediction95_low_g": -2.677, "prediction95_high_g": 1.148, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Taheri 2018", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 526, "n_control": 452, "n_total": 978, "g": -0.745, "se_g": 0.221, "ci95_low_g": -1.207, "ci95_high_g": -0.282, "p_two_sided": 0.00321847065441, "p_display": "0.00322", "tau2": 0.774527, "Q": 114.332724, "Q_p_value": 1.26029332861e-15, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.38, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.037842, "prediction95_low_g": -2.651, "prediction95_high_g": 1.162, "interval_excludes_zero": true }, { "omitted": "Williams 2008", "status": "estimated", "k": 20, "model": "REML", "interval_method": "modified_HK", "n_exercise": 517, "n_control": 448, "n_total": 965, "g": -0.777, "se_g": 0.222, "ci95_low_g": -1.242, "ci95_high_g": -0.312, "p_two_sided": 0.00241494925874, "p_display": "0.00241", "tau2": 0.784415, "Q": 115.533319, "Q_p_value": 7.54353952304e-16, "Q_p_display": "<0.001", "I2_percent": 83.55, "hk_multiplier_raw": 1.031075, "prediction95_low_g": -2.695, "prediction95_high_g": 1.142, "interval_excludes_zero": true } ], "leave_one_out_summary": { "minimum_pooled_g": -0.815, "maximum_pooled_g": -0.628, "intervals_excluding_zero": 21, "comparisons": 21, "largest_absolute_point_shift_study": "Abdelbasset 2019", "maximum_absolute_point_shift_g": 0.134 }, "interval_level_percent": 95, "selected_studies": [ { "studyID": "Abdelbasset 2019", "outcome": "PHQ-9", "yi": -3.23017212055, "vi": 0.140826173394, "n_exercise": 46, "n_control": 23, "mean_exercise": 3.385, "mean_control": 8.54, "sd_exercise": 1.21173291887, "sd_control": 2.14, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Abdelbasset 201915.958.54", "Abdelbasset 201916.123.65", "Abdelbasset 201916.343.12" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 2, 3, 4 ] }, { "studyID": "Armstrong 2004", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -1.09321485264, "vi": 0.242561603586, "n_exercise": 9, "n_control": 10, "mean_exercise": 6.33, "mean_control": 13.33, "sd_exercise": 3.67, "sd_control": 7.66, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "High risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Armstrong 200417.1713.33", "Armstrong 200417.256.33" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 19, 20 ] }, { "studyID": "Blumenthal 2012", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.690216173948, "vi": 0.0752933129421, "n_exercise": 36, "n_control": 23, "mean_exercise": 5.9, "mean_control": 10.0, "sd_exercise": 5.9, "sd_control": 5.8, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Blumenthal 201214.510", "Blumenthal 201213.45.9" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 50, 52 ] }, { "studyID": "Brown 1992", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": 0.748065938265, "vi": 0.531089036, "n_exercise": 6, "n_control": 3, "mean_exercise": 18.8333333333, "mean_control": 4.33, "sd_exercise": 20.204724365, "sd_control": 4.16, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Unclear risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Brown 199215.334.33", "Brown 199212.524.5", "Brown 199228.516" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 76, 77, 78 ] }, { "studyID": "Buschert 2018", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": 0.20192375322, "vi": 0.134012886702, "n_exercise": 15, "n_control": 15, "mean_exercise": 7.2, "mean_control": 6.44, "sd_exercise": 3.88, "sd_control": 3.43, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Unclear risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Buschert 20189.676.44", "Buschert 2018117.2" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 82, 84 ] }, { "studyID": "Chin 2022", "outcome": "HADS", "yi": -0.801765457537, "vi": 0.145125397365, "n_exercise": 37, "n_control": 9, "mean_exercise": 4.40512677626, "mean_control": 7.42268041237, "sd_exercise": 3.22468859162, "sd_control": 5.33505154639, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "", "", "", "", "" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 142, 144, 146, 148, 150 ] }, { "studyID": "D'Amato 1990", "outcome": "GDS", "yi": 0.148677361172, "vi": 0.127258000525, "n_exercise": 13, "n_control": 20, "mean_exercise": 14.17, "mean_control": 12.86, "sd_exercise": 8.73, "sd_control": 8.51, "risk": { "overall": "Unclear risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Unclear risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "D'Amato 199014.0612.86", "D'Amato 199014.0614.17" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 177, 179 ] }, { "studyID": "Daley 2008", "outcome": "EPDS", "yi": -0.220604282893, "vi": 0.129951606177, "n_exercise": 16, "n_control": 15, "mean_exercise": 13.1, "mean_control": 14.3, "sd_exercise": 5.2, "sd_control": 5.4, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Unclear risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Daley 200819.214.3", "Daley 200817.713.1" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 189, 190 ] }, { "studyID": "Fetsch 1980", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": 0.276575401758, "vi": 0.252390436027, "n_exercise": 8, "n_control": 8, "mean_exercise": 13.63, "mean_control": 11.63, "sd_exercise": 7.95, "sd_control": 5.5, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "High risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "High risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Fetsch 19801911.63", "Fetsch 198021.1313.63" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 231, 232 ] }, { "studyID": "Gary 2010", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.165809663401, "vi": 0.122638780472, "n_exercise": 18, "n_control": 15, "mean_exercise": 8.4, "mean_control": 9.3, "sd_exercise": 5.6, "sd_control": 4.9, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Gary 201015.28.2", "Gary 201015.48.3" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 268, 270 ] }, { "studyID": "Knubben 2007", "outcome": "CES-D", "yi": -0.867643203134, "vi": 0.118360171367, "n_exercise": 19, "n_control": 18, "mean_exercise": 22.4, "mean_control": 31.8, "sd_exercise": 10.0, "sd_control": 11.2, "risk": { "overall": "Unclear risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Knubben 200739.231.8", "Knubben 200737.622.4" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 368, 369 ] }, { "studyID": "Kruisdijk 2019", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.68545313757, "vi": 0.238554844712, "n_exercise": 12, "n_control": 7, "mean_exercise": 17.1, "mean_control": 22.3, "sd_exercise": 6.6, "sd_control": 8.3, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Kruisdijk 201925.122.3", "Kruisdijk 201919.117.1" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 396, 397 ] }, { "studyID": "Legrand 2016", "outcome": "BDI-II", "yi": -1.36634153562, "vi": 0.199675446177, "n_exercise": 14, "n_control": 11, "mean_exercise": 18.92, "mean_control": 28.43, "sd_exercise": 6.11, "sd_control": 7.46, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "High risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Legrand 201637.828.43", "Legrand 201636.118.92" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 427, 428 ] }, { "studyID": "Ma 2019", "outcome": "SCL-20", "yi": -0.25753179807, "vi": 0.0117278446448, "n_exercise": 169, "n_control": 175, "mean_exercise": 1.1, "mean_control": 1.4, "sd_exercise": 1.0, "sd_control": 1.3, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Ma 20191.51.4", "Ma 20191.51.1" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 442, 443 ] }, { "studyID": "Maharaj 2023", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": -0.657994242096, "vi": 0.0860845893466, "n_exercise": 25, "n_control": 24, "mean_exercise": 20.9, "mean_control": 23.5, "sd_exercise": 3.22, "sd_control": 4.48, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "", "" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 446, 447 ] }, { "studyID": "Mota-Pereira 2011", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.823383322785, "vi": 0.164320546124, "n_exercise": 19, "n_control": 10, "mean_exercise": 12.48, "mean_control": 13.6, "sd_exercise": 1.47, "sd_control": 0.96, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Mota-Pereira 201117.8322.13", "Mota-Pereira 201124.6818.21" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 508, 510 ] }, { "studyID": "Nabkasorn 2006", "outcome": "CES-D", "yi": -0.728461097829, "vi": 0.0887481860991, "n_exercise": 21, "n_control": 28, "mean_exercise": 14.4, "mean_control": 17.5, "sd_exercise": 4.124318, "sd_control": 4.233202, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "High risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Nabkasorn 200618.817.5", "Nabkasorn 200620.114.4" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 516, 517 ] }, { "studyID": "Norouzi 2020", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": -3.36612089706, "vi": 0.24163462367, "n_exercise": 20, "n_control": 20, "mean_exercise": 21.33, "mean_control": 30.14, "sd_exercise": 2.01, "sd_control": 3.02, "risk": { "overall": "Unclear risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Unclear risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Norouzi 202030.9830.14", "Norouzi 202030.2121.33" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 529, 530 ] }, { "studyID": "Shachar-Malach 2015", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.722554874555, "vi": 0.355086897781, "n_exercise": 6, "n_control": 6, "mean_exercise": 17.1, "mean_control": 22.31, "sd_exercise": 4.24, "sd_control": 8.4, "risk": { "overall": "High risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Low risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Shachar-Malach 201535.3337.52", "Shachar-Malach 201528.3329.06" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 639, 643 ] }, { "studyID": "Taheri 2018", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": -1.16617824358, "vi": 0.292499115494, "n_exercise": 8, "n_control": 8, "mean_exercise": 15.03, "mean_control": 16.67, "sd_exercise": 1.329361, "sd_control": 1.329361, "risk": { "overall": "Unclear risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Unclear risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Taheri 201816.7716.67", "Taheri 201816.9415.03" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 718, 719 ] }, { "studyID": "Williams 2008", "outcome": "CSDD", "yi": -0.481605484638, "vi": 0.146155894518, "n_exercise": 17, "n_control": 12, "mean_exercise": 8.37, "mean_control": 11.75, "sd_exercise": 5.78, "sd_control": 8.1, "risk": { "overall": "Unclear risk", "random_sequence_generation_selection_bias": "Unclear risk", "allocation_concealment_selection_bias": "Low risk", "blinded_outcome_assessor": "Low risk" }, "source_row_ids": [ "Williams 200814.5811.75", "Williams 200811.058.37" ], "source_csv_lines": [ 780, 781 ] } ], "flow": [ { "studyID": "Abdelbasset 2019", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "PHQ-9", "source_row_ids": [ "Abdelbasset 201915.958.54", "Abdelbasset 201916.123.65", "Abdelbasset 201916.343.12" ] }, { "studyID": "Abdelbasset 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Abdollahi 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Abedi 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Abt 2006", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Aguinaga 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Armstrong 2003", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Armstrong 2004", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "HAM-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Armstrong 200417.1713.33", "Armstrong 200417.256.33" ] }, { "studyID": "Balchin 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Beffert 1994", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "BelvederiMurri 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Bhandari 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Bieber 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Blumenthal 1999", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Blumenthal 2007", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Blumenthal 2012", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "HAM-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Blumenthal 201214.510", "Blumenthal 201213.45.9" ] }, { "studyID": "Bombardier 2013", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Bonnet 2006", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Bosscher 1993", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Brenes 2007", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Bressington 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Briggs 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Brown 1992", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "BDI", "source_row_ids": [ "Brown 199215.334.33", "Brown 199212.524.5", "Brown 199228.516" ] }, { "studyID": "Brush 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Buschert 2018", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "HAM-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Buschert 20189.676.44", "Buschert 2018117.2" ] }, { "studyID": "Butler 2008", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Buttner 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Callaghan 2011", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Carneiro 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Carter 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Cecchini-Estrada 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Chalder 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Chan 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Chang 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Cheng 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Cheng 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Cheung 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Chin 2022", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "HADS", "source_row_ids": [ "", "", "", "", "" ] }, { "studyID": "Chou 2004", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Chu 2009", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Chu 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Chu 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Ciccolo 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Cody 2023", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Cohen-Kahn 1995", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Cooney 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Craft 2007", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "D'Amato 1990", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "GDS", "source_row_ids": [ "D'Amato 199014.0612.86", "D'Amato 199014.0614.17" ] }, { "studyID": "Da Costa 2009", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Daley 2008", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "EPDS", "source_row_ids": [ "Daley 200819.214.3", "Daley 200817.713.1" ] }, { "studyID": "Daley 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "DanHauer 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Danielsson 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Davis 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Deus 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Dopp 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Doyne 1987", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Dunn 2002", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Epstein 1986", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Euteneuer 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Fetsch 1980", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "BDI", "source_row_ids": [ "Fetsch 19801911.63", "Fetsch 198021.1313.63" ] }, { "studyID": "Field 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Field 2013", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Foley 2008", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Forsyth 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Fremont 1987", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Gao 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "García-Toro 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Gary 2010", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "HAM-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Gary 201015.28.2", "Gary 201015.48.3" ] }, { "studyID": "Gautam 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Goracci 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Greer 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Gujral 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Guo 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Hallgren 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Hanssen 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Haussleiter 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Heh 2008", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Heinzel 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Heissel 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Hemat-Far 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Hess-Homeier 1981", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Ho 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Hoffman 2010", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Huang 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Hughes 2013", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Imboden 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Irandoust 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Jelalian 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Jeong 2005", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Jin 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Jing 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Joyce 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Kanner 1991", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Kerling 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Khoshnab 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Kim 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Klein 1984", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Knubben 2007", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "CES-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Knubben 200739.231.8", "Knubben 200737.622.4" ] }, { "studyID": "Kouidi 2010", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Krogh 2009", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Krogh 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Kruisdijk 2019", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "HAM-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Kruisdijk 201925.122.3", "Kruisdijk 201919.117.1" ] }, { "studyID": "Kuvačić 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "LaRocque 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Lanza 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Lavretsky 2011", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Lavretsky 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Lee 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Legrand 2007", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Legrand 2009", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Legrand 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Legrand 2016", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "BDI-II", "source_row_ids": [ "Legrand 201637.828.43", "Legrand 201636.118.92" ] }, { "studyID": "Levin 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Liao 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Lok 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Lu 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Luttenberger 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Ma 2019", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "SCL-20", "source_row_ids": [ "Ma 20191.51.4", "Ma 20191.51.1" ] }, { "studyID": "Maddux 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Maharaj 2023", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "BDI", "source_row_ids": [ "", "" ] }, { "studyID": "Makizako 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Margolis 1982", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Martinsen 1985", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Martinsen 1989", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Martiny 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "McCann 1984", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "McMurdo 2001", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Meleppurakkal 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Meyer 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Minghetti 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Mitchell 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Mitchell 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Moncrieft 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Moraes 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Mosquera-Valderrama 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Mota-Pereira 2011", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "HAM-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Mota-Pereira 201117.8322.13", "Mota-Pereira 201124.6818.21" ] }, { "studyID": "Motl 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Mutrie 1986", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Nabkasorn 2006", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "CES-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Nabkasorn 200618.817.5", "Nabkasorn 200620.114.4" ] }, { "studyID": "Nasstasia 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Naumann 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Newcombe 2023", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Norouzi 2020", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "BDI", "source_row_ids": [ "Norouzi 202030.9830.14", "Norouzi 202030.2121.33" ] }, { "studyID": "Norouzi 2023", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Nyström 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Olson 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Oretzky 2007", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Ouyang 2001", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Ozkan 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Pagoto 2013", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Passmore 2006", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Patten 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Patten 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Pentecost 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Phillips 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Pilu 2007", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Prakhinkit 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Prathikanti 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Puterman 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Rashidi 2013", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Ravindran 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Roh 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Roshan 2011", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Roy 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sadeghi 2006", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Salchow 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Salehi 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sarubin 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Schneider 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Schuch 2011", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Schuch 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Schuver 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Setaro 1986", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sexton 1989", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Shachar-Malach 2015", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "HAM-D", "source_row_ids": [ "Shachar-Malach 201535.3337.52", "Shachar-Malach 201528.3329.06" ] }, { "studyID": "Shahidi 2011", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sims 2005", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sims 2009", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Singh 1996", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Singh 1997", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Singh 2001", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Singh 2005", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Siqueira 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sjösten 2008", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Streeter 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Strom 2013", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sujatha 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sun 2022a", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Sun 2022b", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Szuhany 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Szuhany 2020", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Taheri 2018", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "BDI", "source_row_ids": [ "Taheri 201816.7716.67", "Taheri 201816.9415.03" ] }, { "studyID": "Tolahunase 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Tsang 2006", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Uebelacker 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Uebelacker 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Veale 1992", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Verrusio 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Vickers 2009", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Vieira 2007", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Vollbehr 2022", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Wadden 2014", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Walter 2023", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Weinstock 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Whiddon 2013", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Williams 2008", "included": true, "reason": "Eligible", "outcome": "CSDD", "source_row_ids": [ "Williams 200814.5811.75", "Williams 200811.058.37" ] }, { "studyID": "Woolery 2004", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Wunram 2018", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Yagli 2015", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Yang 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Yeung 2012", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Yeung 2017", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Zeibig 2021", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Zhao 2023", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "Zou 2005", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "de Groot 2019", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" }, { "studyID": "de Manincor 2016", "included": false, "reason": "No immediate target and eligible control arms" } ], "source_rows": 827, "source_studies": 218, "source_overall_risk": { "low_risk": 0, "unclear_risk": 5, "high_risk": 16 }, "checks": { "one_contrast_per_study": true, "unique_eligible_source_keys": true, "noneligible_source_duplicate_keys": [ { "studyID": "Carter 2015", "arm_number": "Carter_2015_44_29.4_20.4", "outcome": "CDI", "time": "0", "csv_lines": [ 97, 98 ] }, { "studyID": "Carter 2015", "arm_number": "Carter_2015_42_28.7_24.6", "outcome": "CDI", "time": "0", "csv_lines": [ 100, 101 ] }, { "studyID": "Guo 2020", "arm_number": "Guo_2020_150_24.3_23.8", "outcome": "CES-D", "time": "0", "csv_lines": [ 279, 280, 281 ] }, { "studyID": "Guo 2020", "arm_number": "Guo_2020_150_23.9_17.7", "outcome": "CES-D", "time": "0", "csv_lines": [ 282, 283, 284 ] }, { "studyID": "Rashidi 2013", "arm_number": "613", "outcome": "BDI", "time": "0", "csv_lines": [ 584, 585, 586 ] }, { "studyID": "Rashidi 2013", "arm_number": "612", "outcome": "BDI", "time": "0", "csv_lines": [ 587, 588, 589 ] } ], "combined_variance_identity": true, "REML_score_matches_likelihood": true, "max_source_arm_g_discrepancy": 0.0503414706, "max_source_arm_g_discrepancy_display": 0.05034, "source_arm_g_discrepancies": [ { "studyID": "D'Amato 1990", "arm_number": "D'Amato_1990_NA_5.1_5.9", "source_csv_line": 177, "stored_g": -0.151024411912, "documented_formula_g": -0.201365882549, "stored_mean_diff": -1.2, "post_minus_baseline_mean": -1.6, "absolute_difference": 0.0503414706372 } ], "source_arm_g_discrepancy_count": 1, "max_source_arm_se_discrepancy": 0.0, "independent_metafor_reference": { "status": "matched within declared display precision", "software": { "R": "4.6.1", "metafor": "5.2.1", "jsonlite": "2.0.0" }, "fits_compared": 30, "max_study_g_difference": 3.24185123191e-14, "max_study_variance_difference": 1.33226762955e-15 } }, "source_sha256": "affdfdb925809b3b864e1710e705341d03f79d20f3bfb628316fb5c66956cc37" }