{ "software": { "R": "4.6.1", "metafor": "5.2.1", "jsonlite": "2.0.0" }, "studies": { "Abdelbasset 2019": { "studyID": "Abdelbasset 2019", "outcome": "PHQ-9", "yi": -3.2301721205462, "vi": 0.140826173393869 }, "Armstrong 2004": { "studyID": "Armstrong 2004", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -1.09321485264004, "vi": 0.242561603585658 }, "Blumenthal 2012": { "studyID": "Blumenthal 2012", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.690216173947796, "vi": 0.0752933129420814 }, "Brown 1992": { "studyID": "Brown 1992", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": 0.748065938264781, "vi": 0.531089035999554 }, "Buschert 2018": { "studyID": "Buschert 2018", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": 0.201923753219822, "vi": 0.134012886701906 }, "Chin 2022": { "studyID": "Chin 2022", "outcome": "HADS", "yi": -0.80176545753731, "vi": 0.145125397365312 }, "D'Amato 1990": { "studyID": "D'Amato 1990", "outcome": "GDS", "yi": 0.148677361172364, "vi": 0.127258000524974 }, "Daley 2008": { "studyID": "Daley 2008", "outcome": "EPDS", "yi": -0.220604282893418, "vi": 0.129951606176843 }, "Fetsch 1980": { "studyID": "Fetsch 1980", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": 0.276575401757989, "vi": 0.2523904360268 }, "Gary 2010": { "studyID": "Gary 2010", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.165809663401383, "vi": 0.122638780471878 }, "Knubben 2007": { "studyID": "Knubben 2007", "outcome": "CES-D", "yi": -0.867643203134269, "vi": 0.118360171367047 }, "Kruisdijk 2019": { "studyID": "Kruisdijk 2019", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.685453137569743, "vi": 0.238554844711639 }, "Legrand 2016": { "studyID": "Legrand 2016", "outcome": "BDI-II", "yi": -1.36634153562155, "vi": 0.199675446176956 }, "Ma 2019": { "studyID": "Ma 2019", "outcome": "SCL-20", "yi": -0.257531798069758, "vi": 0.0117278446447753 }, "Maharaj 2023": { "studyID": "Maharaj 2023", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": -0.657994242095856, "vi": 0.0860845893465779 }, "Mota-Pereira 2011": { "studyID": "Mota-Pereira 2011", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.823383322785113, "vi": 0.164320546123931 }, "Nabkasorn 2006": { "studyID": "Nabkasorn 2006", "outcome": "CES-D", "yi": -0.728461097828791, "vi": 0.0887481860991489 }, "Norouzi 2020": { "studyID": "Norouzi 2020", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": -3.36612089705714, "vi": 0.241634623670059 }, "Shachar-Malach 2015": { "studyID": "Shachar-Malach 2015", "outcome": "HAM-D", "yi": -0.722554874555138, "vi": 0.355086897780975 }, "Taheri 2018": { "studyID": "Taheri 2018", "outcome": "BDI", "yi": -1.16617824357956, "vi": 0.292499115493697 }, "Williams 2008": { "studyID": "Williams 2008", "outcome": "CSDD", "yi": -0.481605484637589, "vi": 0.146155894518081 } }, "primary": { "k": 21, "g": -0.762222791308198, "se_g": 0.211439922286671, "ci95_low_g": -1.20327874049093, "ci95_high_g": -0.321166842125468, "tau2": 0.737017109426753, "Q": 115.58369121424, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948376968e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00176804294711615 }, "sensitivity": { "REML_normal": { "k": 21, "g": -0.762222791308198, "se_g": 0.207974896023631, "ci95_low_g": -1.16984609720298, "ci95_high_g": -0.35459948541342, "tau2": 0.737017109426753, "Q": 115.58369121424, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948376968e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.000247362759872728 }, "REML_unmodified_HK": { "k": 21, "g": -0.762222791308198, "se_g": 0.211439922286671, "ci95_low_g": -1.20327874049093, "ci95_high_g": -0.321166842125468, "tau2": 0.737017109426753, "Q": 115.58369121424, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948376968e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00176804294711615 }, "fixed_normal": { "k": 21, "g": -0.566048559905649, "se_g": 0.0678045824859991, "ci95_low_g": -0.698943099564982, "ci95_high_g": -0.433154020246315, "tau2": 0, "Q": 115.58369121424, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948376968e-15, "p_two_sided": 6.92908535269643e-17 }, "DL_normal": { "k": 21, "g": -0.760688465053643, "se_g": 0.182777388002948, "ci95_low_g": -1.11892556272772, "ci95_high_g": -0.402451367379562, "tau2": 0.533220778878223, "Q": 115.58369121424, "Q_p_value": 1.86341948376968e-15, "p_two_sided": 3.15706983873849e-05 }, "low_randomization_and_allocation": { "k": 8, "g": -0.550892089610718, "se_g": 0.136485324527471, "ci95_low_g": -0.873628597974886, "ci95_high_g": -0.228155581246549, "tau2": 0.0428221857539418, "Q": 8.64219545785488, "Q_p_value": 0.279375551178714, "p_two_sided": 0.00495621769721175 }, "low_blinded_assessor": { "k": 11, "g": -0.841051144543565, "se_g": 0.249443157562491, "ci95_low_g": -1.39684513527068, "ci95_high_g": -0.285257153816446, "tau2": 0.54825036023325, "Q": 61.8355047378894, "Q_p_value": 1.62618141610165e-09, "p_two_sided": 0.00710090576376734 }, "lexicographic_measure": { "k": 21, "g": -0.866506305261425, "se_g": 0.225899671896235, "ci95_low_g": -1.33772476358632, "ci95_high_g": -0.395287846936526, "tau2": 0.848701591392287, "Q": 126.688513465077, "Q_p_value": 1.6248979606466e-17, "p_two_sided": 0.0010325391641099 }, "usual_care_only": { "k": 8, "g": -0.706244121808845, "se_g": 0.398942625046242, "ci95_low_g": -1.64959352798728, "ci95_high_g": 0.237105284369585, "tau2": 1.08252134481867, "Q": 63.6778905685798, "Q_p_value": 2.77128071747656e-11, "p_two_sided": 0.119985530631332 } }, "leave_one_out": [ { "omitted": "Abdelbasset 2019", "k": 20, "g": -0.627974370624837, "se_g": 0.174091218246756, "ci95_low_g": -0.992351478076545, "ci95_high_g": -0.263597263173129, "tau2": 0.375688734966459, "Q": 63.4834089551126, "Q_p_value": 1.07458652671835e-06, "p_two_sided": 0.0018776195537986 }, { "omitted": "Armstrong 2004", "k": 20, "g": -0.747040673188782, "se_g": 0.221492600284322, "ci95_low_g": -1.21063001345731, "ci95_high_g": -0.283451332920251, "tau2": 0.778666228276544, "Q": 114.415850136799, "Q_p_value": 1.21632957983266e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00319532468816091 }, { "omitted": "Blumenthal 2012", "k": 20, "g": -0.766465021202381, "se_g": 0.223163714705529, "ci95_low_g": -1.23355204415217, "ci95_high_g": -0.299377998252595, "tau2": 0.793091540968389, "Q": 115.365607747644, "Q_p_value": 8.10465847137866e-16, "p_two_sided": 0.00277853636712498 }, { "omitted": "Brown 1992", "k": 20, "g": -0.814908347475217, "se_g": 0.210456457239451, "ci95_low_g": -1.25539877488294, "ci95_high_g": -0.374417920067493, "tau2": 0.708994746687166, "Q": 112.303682572819, "Q_p_value": 2.99420861214472e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00102615709052454 }, { "omitted": "Buschert 2018", "k": 20, "g": -0.812584999092889, "se_g": 0.216364304129351, "ci95_low_g": -1.26544069215094, "ci95_high_g": -0.359729306034841, "tau2": 0.730753446915834, "Q": 111.026417826008, "Q_p_value": 5.15539951173136e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00133866438788687 }, { "omitted": "Chin 2022", "k": 20, "g": -0.760390756718709, "se_g": 0.222708597637891, "ci95_low_g": -1.22652520869836, "ci95_high_g": -0.294256304739061, "tau2": 0.789137991279257, "Q": 115.188307510282, "Q_p_value": 8.7431459057915e-16, "p_two_sided": 0.00290891420318762 }, { "omitted": "D'Amato 1990", "k": 20, "g": -0.810210596647238, "se_g": 0.217063021396526, "ci95_low_g": -1.26452872175271, "ci95_high_g": -0.355892471541764, "tau2": 0.736672608925166, "Q": 111.419082563973, "Q_p_value": 4.36279778802297e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00141085902334022 }, { "omitted": "Daley 2008", "k": 20, "g": -0.790764887549804, "se_g": 0.220806966925682, "ci95_low_g": -1.2529191807062, "ci95_high_g": -0.328610594393411, "tau2": 0.771438174102408, "Q": 114.631734270664, "Q_p_value": 1.10916204976581e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00199160527091906 }, { "omitted": "Fetsch 1980", "k": 20, "g": -0.809657520623311, "se_g": 0.21559925697385, "ci95_low_g": -1.26091195158214, "ci95_high_g": -0.358403089664483, "tau2": 0.731422596342942, "Q": 112.71833499558, "Q_p_value": 2.50942596694614e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00133943293087141 }, { "omitted": "Gary 2010", "k": 20, "g": -0.793898652984539, "se_g": 0.220403720107735, "ci95_low_g": -1.25520894085111, "ci95_high_g": -0.332588365117972, "tau2": 0.767467869533487, "Q": 114.22661408614, "Q_p_value": 1.31872048349608e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00189969492802625 }, { "omitted": "Knubben 2007", "k": 20, "g": -0.756832605218571, "se_g": 0.222818767931283, "ci95_low_g": -1.22319764627237, "ci95_high_g": -0.290467564164774, "tau2": 0.790014630574335, "Q": 114.784138101841, "Q_p_value": 1.03922513138428e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00302746363453105 }, { "omitted": "Kruisdijk 2019", "k": 20, "g": -0.765985859769964, "se_g": 0.222138514008889, "ci95_low_g": -1.23092711300109, "ci95_high_g": -0.301044606538842, "tau2": 0.784204833085617, "Q": 115.522750828578, "Q_p_value": 7.57772525249703e-16, "p_two_sided": 0.00269367331340028 }, { "omitted": "Legrand 2016", "k": 20, "g": -0.733056905630732, "se_g": 0.220075902793084, "ci95_low_g": -1.19368106397228, "ci95_high_g": -0.272432747289183, "tau2": 0.766039333091238, "Q": 112.300548589343, "Q_p_value": 2.99820715442632e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00351178271626638 }, { "omitted": "Ma 2019", "k": 20, "g": -0.793054106487192, "se_g": 0.221691039440569, "ci95_low_g": -1.25705878468308, "ci95_high_g": -0.329049428291299, "tau2": 0.776090109352111, "Q": 102.234816525788, "Q_p_value": 2.10509712462596e-13, "p_two_sided": 0.00200960026112913 }, { "omitted": "Maharaj 2023", "k": 20, "g": -0.768186813743716, "se_g": 0.223044009086554, "ci95_low_g": -1.23502328995354, "ci95_high_g": -0.301350337533894, "tau2": 0.792020421179479, "Q": 115.479944663256, "Q_p_value": 7.71778241498837e-16, "p_two_sided": 0.00271900148845336 }, { "omitted": "Mota-Pereira 2011", "k": 20, "g": -0.759339675173405, "se_g": 0.222574039510294, "ci95_low_g": -1.22519249375528, "ci95_high_g": -0.293486856591534, "tau2": 0.787953071400975, "Q": 115.169091281467, "Q_p_value": 8.81528954836688e-16, "p_two_sided": 0.00292646528680215 }, { "omitted": "Nabkasorn 2006", "k": 20, "g": -0.764295729715817, "se_g": 0.22309454176358, "ci95_low_g": -1.23123797203419, "ci95_high_g": -0.297353487397445, "tau2": 0.792518866607934, "Q": 115.270231852234, "Q_p_value": 8.44212068821219e-16, "p_two_sided": 0.00283354923948261 }, { "omitted": "Norouzi 2020", "k": 20, "g": -0.643779265797467, "se_g": 0.177741729616358, "ci95_low_g": -1.01579698135664, "ci95_high_g": -0.271761550238292, "tau2": 0.458971370426763, "Q": 82.5069997014125, "Q_p_value": 6.849288371371e-10, "p_two_sided": 0.00181528055893794 }, { "omitted": "Shachar-Malach 2015", "k": 20, "g": -0.764041776895289, "se_g": 0.221610132626568, "ci95_low_g": -1.22787711518331, "ci95_high_g": -0.300206438607266, "tau2": 0.779528213654625, "Q": 115.513805437429, "Q_p_value": 7.60678268712819e-16, "p_two_sided": 0.0026970378937588 }, { "omitted": "Taheri 2018", "k": 20, "g": -0.744563646538178, "se_g": 0.220967467028377, "ci95_low_g": -1.20705387027025, "ci95_high_g": -0.282073422806111, "tau2": 0.774526522062523, "Q": 114.332723628215, "Q_p_value": 1.2602933286158e-15, "p_two_sided": 0.00321847065445927 }, { "omitted": "Williams 2008", "k": 20, "g": -0.776848961347918, "se_g": 0.222184852600849, "ci95_low_g": -1.24188720236666, "ci95_high_g": -0.311810720329176, "tau2": 0.784415066722667, "Q": 115.533318849952, "Q_p_value": 7.54353952304686e-16, "p_two_sided": 0.00241494925876973 } ] }