[
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 315,
   "comparisons_with_events": 252,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 36707,
    "higher": 1.0301577213499058,
    "lower": 0.9707251416701633
   },
   "hi": 1.0331557966550544,
   "lo": 0.9725098155088375,
   "log_rr": 0.002371443950550732,
   "p": 0.8778710677406223,
   "placebo_affected": 15452,
   "placebo_at_risk": 231004,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.0690042571557381,
    "hi": 1.0236803971117472,
    "i2": 0.11928942662106753,
    "lo": 0.9654007818818219,
    "p": 0.6929815271597635,
    "rr": 0.9941136030498601,
    "tau2": 0.003259864355215021
   },
   "rd": 1.588147171547869,
   "rd_hi": 21.639885904595566,
   "rd_lo": -18.46359156149983,
   "rr": 1.0023742580478077,
   "se": 0.015432198970393196,
   "se_binomial": 0.009714550606023782,
   "se_clustered": 0.015432198970393196,
   "trials": 307,
   "trials_with_events": 245,
   "vaccine_affected": 21255,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 329998
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 248,
   "comparisons_with_events": 89,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5218,
    "higher": 1.0818159518362234,
    "lower": 0.9243716533322024
   },
   "hi": 1.0485803824624773,
   "lo": 0.9449984868133094,
   "log_rr": -0.004567360038814053,
   "p": 0.8633306311895076,
   "placebo_affected": 2481,
   "placebo_at_risk": 207935,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8023717263675494,
    "hi": 1.0414941689590516,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9389936736806661,
    "p": 0.6732542344509638,
    "rr": 0.988916799244432,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -0.508821512963021,
   "rd_hi": 5.2880743270474895,
   "rd_lo": -6.305717352973532,
   "rr": 0.9954430544883832,
   "se": 0.02653344281151055,
   "se_binomial": 0.02653344281151055,
   "se_clustered": 0.02292155404953068,
   "trials": 241,
   "trials_with_events": 88,
   "vaccine_affected": 2737,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 289882
  },
  "id": "inert",
  "name": "Placebo stated to be inert"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 186,
   "comparisons_with_events": 160,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 18949,
    "higher": 1.0416686052262614,
    "lower": 0.9599982134268024
   },
   "hi": 0.9849874302024009,
   "lo": 0.9054541892460588,
   "log_rr": -0.057222496856099044,
   "p": 0.007716289068407958,
   "placebo_affected": 8925,
   "placebo_at_risk": 264331,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.17513627245612046,
    "hi": 0.9742532401835533,
    "i2": 0.09420408994564093,
    "lo": 0.9064267598676551,
    "p": 0.0007330819447196205,
    "rr": 0.9397282627388316,
    "tau2": 0.0034914923825011684
   },
   "rd": -18.920745496054227,
   "rd_hi": -4.413512595857377,
   "rd_lo": -33.42797839625108,
   "rr": 0.9443839235350598,
   "se": 0.021477995386032157,
   "se_binomial": 0.01407944789103363,
   "se_clustered": 0.021477995386032157,
   "trials": 184,
   "trials_with_events": 158,
   "vaccine_affected": 10024,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 308059
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 118,
   "comparisons_with_events": 47,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1384,
    "higher": 1.1632402734141298,
    "lower": 0.8596676222918099
   },
   "hi": 0.9224283528371382,
   "lo": 0.7419914736850977,
   "log_rr": -0.18958154962802817,
   "p": 0.0006400149535950344,
   "placebo_affected": 710,
   "placebo_at_risk": 140213,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.5897557105771493,
    "hi": 0.9193649612225862,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.7425964276813172,
    "p": 0.00045947189930078535,
    "rr": 0.8262669882908703,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -8.629056847785584,
   "rd_hi": -2.747350691019735,
   "rd_lo": -14.510763004551434,
   "rr": 0.8273052477112335,
   "se": 0.055529579749008046,
   "se_binomial": 0.05403362497922756,
   "se_clustered": 0.055529579749008046,
   "trials": 117,
   "trials_with_events": 47,
   "vaccine_affected": 674,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 167470
  },
  "id": "not_stated",
  "name": "Placebo of unstated composition"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 23,
   "comparisons_with_events": 17,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 3455,
    "higher": 1.1003784342528287,
    "lower": 0.9087782610707135
   },
   "hi": 1.0198751144658929,
   "lo": 0.8747266030425995,
   "log_rr": -0.057081856055950654,
   "p": 0.14498663686408322,
   "placebo_affected": 1760,
   "placebo_at_risk": 16008,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.235807762186767,
    "hi": 1.0120979175857692,
    "i2": 0.18626811346127004,
    "lo": 0.7974338409730338,
    "p": 0.07803202272422222,
    "rr": 0.8983769419688091,
    "tau2": 0.00783255109088966
   },
   "rd": -58.83426513881255,
   "rd_hi": 18.33993471761869,
   "rd_lo": -136.0084649952438,
   "rr": 0.9445167517860299,
   "se": 0.03916502499943341,
   "se_binomial": 0.031679028493620545,
   "se_clustered": 0.03916502499943341,
   "trials": 23,
   "trials_with_events": 17,
   "vaccine_affected": 1695,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 18896
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 13,
   "comparisons_with_events": 3,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 168,
    "higher": 1.541204844865844,
    "lower": 0.6488430161190196
   },
   "hi": 1.5988803391325372,
   "lo": 0.8738505036281409,
   "log_rr": 0.16722881490009023,
   "p": 0.2779050593248076,
   "placebo_affected": 77,
   "placebo_at_risk": 10344,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.23271883594417445,
    "hi": 3.96806430973244,
    "i2": 0.3140933155478943,
    "lo": 0.48032649384409565,
    "p": 0.5493855736133522,
    "rr": 1.3805674258223228,
    "tau2": 0.3799673910936884
   },
   "rd": 13.30628572073709,
   "rd_hi": 37.31082026047721,
   "rd_lo": -10.698248819003023,
   "rr": 1.1820246992309849,
   "se": 0.15412261722028545,
   "se_binomial": 0.15412261722028545,
   "se_clustered": 0.08280350249400759,
   "trials": 13,
   "trials_with_events": 3,
   "vaccine_affected": 91,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 11099
  },
  "id": "adjuvant_placebo",
  "name": "Placebo holding an adjuvant or other active part"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 135,
   "comparisons_with_events": 110,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 11290,
    "higher": 1.0550291236036415,
    "lower": 0.9478411331284583
   },
   "hi": 0.9707996878416449,
   "lo": 0.8784583332596461,
   "log_rr": -0.07961096428562875,
   "p": 0.0017950416954418144,
   "placebo_affected": 4674,
   "placebo_at_risk": 100733,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6535856787022252,
    "hi": 0.9514929586629928,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8848574501739974,
    "p": 3.4094969726955493e-06,
    "rr": 0.9175705058800923,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -37.20966452878278,
   "rd_hi": -10.299073429568665,
   "rd_lo": -64.12025562799691,
   "rr": 0.9234755414792295,
   "se": 0.025498344667730093,
   "se_binomial": 0.018516242389186005,
   "se_clustered": 0.025498344667730093,
   "trials": 132,
   "trials_with_events": 108,
   "vaccine_affected": 6616,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 143714
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 81,
   "comparisons_with_events": 21,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 156,
    "higher": 1.6177474737800681,
    "lower": 0.6181434471125309
   },
   "hi": 1.1573684433416365,
   "lo": 0.6060880896847755,
   "log_rr": -0.17729054815111017,
   "p": 0.28267141133002405,
   "placebo_affected": 61,
   "placebo_at_risk": 27843,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8135266481008409,
    "hi": 1.0727970176635169,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.5634347181203536,
    "p": 0.12546619019962757,
    "rr": 0.7774645234656046,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -3.4525327569781137,
   "rd_hi": 2.9717051095500806,
   "rd_lo": -9.876770623506308,
   "rr": 0.8375364045140812,
   "se": 0.16502312940936067,
   "se_binomial": 0.16502312940936067,
   "se_clustered": 0.13377413075412073,
   "trials": 79,
   "trials_with_events": 21,
   "vaccine_affected": 95,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 59289
  },
  "id": "live",
  "name": "Live attenuated vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 54,
   "comparisons_with_events": 43,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 4087,
    "higher": 1.0924065378288959,
    "lower": 0.9154101201073463
   },
   "hi": 1.2167915615933904,
   "lo": 0.8574361550857156,
   "log_rr": 0.021204484798878754,
   "p": 0.812293609783512,
   "placebo_affected": 1644,
   "placebo_at_risk": 64858,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.010843130980273105,
    "hi": 1.1377892470594002,
    "i2": 0.36198903989966136,
    "lo": 0.8797095686114487,
    "p": 0.9943851157744675,
    "rr": 1.0004619371577161,
    "tau2": 0.030955952497341153
   },
   "rd": 5.6620733679068005,
   "rd_hi": 55.224553549269785,
   "rd_lo": -43.90040681345617,
   "rr": 1.02143089737553,
   "se": 0.08929400857533412,
   "se_binomial": 0.031897309957937936,
   "se_clustered": 0.08929400857533412,
   "trials": 53,
   "trials_with_events": 42,
   "vaccine_affected": 2443,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 84044
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 45,
   "comparisons_with_events": 15,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 338,
    "higher": 1.359872462848089,
    "lower": 0.7353630780239645
   },
   "hi": 1.13736879991361,
   "lo": 0.6081524968348806,
   "log_rr": -0.18430604342363852,
   "p": 0.24849491329906237,
   "placebo_affected": 161,
   "placebo_at_risk": 62420,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.616849281068837,
    "hi": 1.0178122519713344,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.6568601554984301,
    "p": 0.07155600059389511,
    "rr": 0.8176553761200974,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -4.34635613681256,
   "rd_hi": 2.0229973712077665,
   "rd_lo": -10.715709644832886,
   "rr": 0.8316812343016726,
   "se": 0.1597088354067038,
   "se_binomial": 0.11161541005237881,
   "se_clustered": 0.1597088354067038,
   "trials": 44,
   "trials_with_events": 15,
   "vaccine_affected": 177,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 81109
  },
  "id": "vector",
  "name": "Viral vector vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 36,
   "comparisons_with_events": 33,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 8102,
    "higher": 1.064385046980812,
    "lower": 0.9395096284343303
   },
   "hi": 1.1468794470648478,
   "lo": 0.9408211333722117,
   "log_rr": 0.038021245453097714,
   "p": 0.4517194676148396,
   "placebo_affected": 3870,
   "placebo_at_risk": 103574,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 1.5604600003063139e-09,
    "hi": 1.2540466971033357,
    "i2": 0.6921250414695632,
    "lo": 0.892931490527625,
    "p": 0.5138347544953719,
    "rr": 1.0581955331769863,
    "tau2": 0.07071387979559106
   },
   "rd": 14.082026372518085,
   "rd_hi": 44.892568591934086,
   "rd_lo": -16.728515846897917,
   "rr": 1.0387533014286143,
   "se": 0.050523113868374,
   "se_binomial": 0.0211216993739452,
   "se_clustered": 0.050523113868374,
   "trials": 35,
   "trials_with_events": 32,
   "vaccine_affected": 4232,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 118838
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 36,
   "comparisons_with_events": 14,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 800,
    "higher": 1.2196556035596138,
    "lower": 0.8199035835046057
   },
   "hi": 1.3175916843796736,
   "lo": 0.8405720948160915,
   "log_rr": 0.05106651748345274,
   "p": 0.6560636550426378,
   "placebo_affected": 386,
   "placebo_at_risk": 103697,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.006758493217161429,
    "hi": 1.5256061359079658,
    "i2": 0.5502053773679896,
    "lo": 0.6426832185015753,
    "p": 0.9643547527246621,
    "rr": 0.9901926386269911,
    "tau2": 0.21816024372429693
   },
   "rd": 1.8874852637733255,
   "rd_hi": 8.861548470367623,
   "rd_lo": -5.086577942820972,
   "rr": 1.0523928934819375,
   "se": 0.11466489751376595,
   "se_binomial": 0.07022611014340654,
   "se_clustered": 0.11466489751376595,
   "trials": 35,
   "trials_with_events": 14,
   "vaccine_affected": 414,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 118932
  },
  "id": "mrna",
  "name": "mRNA vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 6,
   "comparisons_with_events": 4,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 135,
    "higher": 1.6290231192614186,
    "lower": 0.6138648298947341
   },
   "hi": 1.3949204764458367,
   "lo": 0.7286160066598112,
   "log_rr": 0.008114490965555105,
   "p": 0.9609372427044444,
   "placebo_affected": 63,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1696,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.30118051058376494,
    "hi": 1.4259667508527212,
    "i2": 0.17925784704527017,
    "lo": 0.7036973777650988,
    "p": 0.9923761885622536,
    "rr": 1.0017230472317575,
    "tau2": 0.028681149288108377
   },
   "rd": 2.89917648586172,
   "rd_hi": 116.48020363884581,
   "rd_lo": -110.68185066712238,
   "rr": 1.008147502678039,
   "se": 0.16567800048921608,
   "se_binomial": 0.1404908935468426,
   "se_clustered": 0.16567800048921608,
   "trials": 6,
   "trials_with_events": 4,
   "vaccine_affected": 72,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 2308
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 6,
   "comparisons_with_events": 3,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 18,
    "higher": 3.805280460949831,
    "lower": 0.2627927192915477
   },
   "hi": 2.5803139965871966,
   "lo": 0.38875606640103516,
   "log_rr": 0.0015539424557107534,
   "p": 0.9974321640814838,
   "placebo_affected": 8,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1696,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.28076288400416494,
    "hi": 2.8827950972745855,
    "i2": 0.21275016917581033,
    "lo": 0.31092148008721077,
    "p": 0.9232576231889397,
    "rr": 0.9467433223597455,
    "tau2": 0.23513158663398198
   },
   "rd": 0.07615763448681251,
   "rd_hi": 44.97735354813242,
   "rd_lo": -44.825038279158804,
   "rr": 1.0015551504499254,
   "se": 0.48284415079870663,
   "se_binomial": 0.43983907979595244,
   "se_clustered": 0.48284415079870663,
   "trials": 6,
   "trials_with_events": 3,
   "vaccine_affected": 10,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 2308
  },
  "id": "dna",
  "name": "DNA vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 55,
   "comparisons_with_events": 40,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 4180,
    "higher": 1.094141074957512,
    "lower": 0.9139589243908354
   },
   "hi": 1.0387658124229882,
   "lo": 0.9485440668738782,
   "log_rr": -0.0073968707626076696,
   "p": 0.7496367261262635,
   "placebo_affected": 1916,
   "placebo_at_risk": 19885,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9435089785849514,
    "hi": 1.0254439150408403,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9401722000140069,
    "p": 0.40908033102762187,
    "rr": 0.9818828145939429,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -6.315305780329686,
   "rd_hi": 32.43457036158468,
   "rd_lo": -45.06518192224406,
   "rr": 0.9926304187587892,
   "se": 0.023179078995059645,
   "se_binomial": 0.023179078995059645,
   "se_clustered": 0.013690648942093294,
   "trials": 54,
   "trials_with_events": 39,
   "vaccine_affected": 2264,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 34483
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 38,
   "comparisons_with_events": 12,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1542,
    "higher": 1.1545781864311193,
    "lower": 0.8661171774698679
   },
   "hi": 1.1195277196311746,
   "lo": 0.9389277232378984,
   "log_rr": 0.02494507134036308,
   "p": 0.5783301150000889,
   "placebo_affected": 747,
   "placebo_at_risk": 12256,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6123460948723565,
    "hi": 1.1101631226112318,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.931319353698632,
    "p": 0.7097785416015511,
    "rr": 1.0168167985681331,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 14.708611035160976,
   "rd_hi": 66.41588338259031,
   "rd_lo": -36.99866131226835,
   "rr": 1.0252588028858933,
   "se": 0.04487931723968105,
   "se_binomial": 0.04487931723968105,
   "se_clustered": 0.021059993718283033,
   "trials": 37,
   "trials_with_events": 12,
   "vaccine_affected": 795,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 15610
  },
  "id": "inactivated",
  "name": "Inactivated vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 165,
   "comparisons_with_events": 140,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 22620,
    "higher": 1.0382218690212708,
    "lower": 0.9631852591803886
   },
   "hi": 1.0062676321634978,
   "lo": 0.9584346911578765,
   "log_rr": -0.018102891540467844,
   "p": 0.1450975468970189,
   "placebo_affected": 9931,
   "placebo_at_risk": 128641,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8804341703516491,
    "hi": 1.0056142666009784,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9583014350640106,
    "p": 0.13243396379351927,
    "rr": 0.9816728552855886,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -14.066994046564474,
   "rd_hi": 4.840353955667711,
   "rd_lo": -32.97434204879666,
   "rr": 0.9820599814954225,
   "se": 0.012424189313955957,
   "se_binomial": 0.012424189313955957,
   "se_clustered": 0.011456919298212432,
   "trials": 163,
   "trials_with_events": 138,
   "vaccine_affected": 12689,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 162465
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 122,
   "comparisons_with_events": 55,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 3269,
    "higher": 1.1035389397210498,
    "lower": 0.9061755448817945
   },
   "hi": 0.9862139766045234,
   "lo": 0.8613438713993951,
   "log_rr": -0.08157170066884765,
   "p": 0.018180723714820515,
   "placebo_affected": 1616,
   "placebo_at_risk": 108975,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.959281468632581,
    "hi": 0.9867007593304846,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8616184855692656,
    "p": 0.01891871282089058,
    "rr": 0.92204100449187,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -11.311184607444112,
   "rd_hi": -1.9438309662720181,
   "rd_lo": -20.678538248616206,
   "rr": 0.9216666233713428,
   "se": 0.03453623003122906,
   "se_binomial": 0.03453623003122906,
   "se_clustered": 0.032592542212670286,
   "trials": 120,
   "trials_with_events": 54,
   "vaccine_affected": 1653,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 133939
  },
  "id": "protein",
  "name": "Protein vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 25,
   "comparisons_with_events": 20,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1934,
    "higher": 1.135900223646341,
    "lower": 0.8803590132150084
   },
   "hi": 1.0837927774497478,
   "lo": 0.9094053185327506,
   "log_rr": -0.007248834590930769,
   "p": 0.8713279840014745,
   "placebo_affected": 896,
   "placebo_at_risk": 55193,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8123687540774691,
    "hi": 1.0745830830346599,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9021490599545956,
    "p": 0.7279491836489551,
    "rr": 0.9845984553120269,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -1.2181307217120925,
   "rd_hi": 13.551794599079107,
   "rd_lo": -15.988056042503292,
   "rr": 0.992777374843012,
   "se": 0.0447536559956343,
   "se_binomial": 0.0447536559956343,
   "se_clustered": 0.023349240395391147,
   "trials": 24,
   "trials_with_events": 19,
   "vaccine_affected": 1038,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 56866
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 14,
   "comparisons_with_events": 5,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 159,
    "higher": 1.5599293883333631,
    "lower": 0.6410546576524244
   },
   "hi": 1.6192177880143905,
   "lo": 0.8703702182217556,
   "log_rr": 0.1715532830341068,
   "p": 0.2786854678390889,
   "placebo_affected": 72,
   "placebo_at_risk": 10288,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.5344356812476703,
    "hi": 1.5949586040369756,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8597023621613001,
    "p": 0.31676099956295023,
    "rr": 1.1709780866609236,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 12.947484540351535,
   "rd_hi": 36.41294566614308,
   "rd_lo": -10.517976585440014,
   "rr": 1.1871473958622971,
   "se": 0.15836510400057585,
   "se_binomial": 0.15836510400057585,
   "se_clustered": 0.03829464776656882,
   "trials": 14,
   "trials_with_events": 5,
   "vaccine_affected": 87,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 11042
  },
  "id": "polysaccharide",
  "name": "Polysaccharide and conjugate vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 26,
   "comparisons_with_events": 23,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 7668,
    "higher": 1.0662573616064779,
    "lower": 0.9378598788695337
   },
   "hi": 1.1398168615046358,
   "lo": 0.9335244367849107,
   "log_rr": 0.031039731475101178,
   "p": 0.5422483707689858,
   "placebo_affected": 3708,
   "placebo_at_risk": 82443,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 2.456324401584912e-11,
    "hi": 1.3149119531731916,
    "i2": 0.7724058841310802,
    "lo": 0.8623625779136747,
    "p": 0.559238789907091,
    "rr": 1.0648618979322806,
    "tau2": 0.08652055717033681
   },
   "rd": 13.69082682582991,
   "rd_hi": 52.44116947097557,
   "rd_lo": -25.059515819315752,
   "rr": 1.0315264871412948,
   "se": 0.050933522362202305,
   "se_binomial": 0.0216047504751071,
   "se_clustered": 0.050933522362202305,
   "trials": 25,
   "trials_with_events": 22,
   "vaccine_affected": 3960,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 95266
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 26,
   "comparisons_with_events": 10,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 762,
    "higher": 1.2256966962962605,
    "lower": 0.8158625237562785
   },
   "hi": 1.3455291444594981,
   "lo": 0.829939955502937,
   "log_rr": 0.05519271403257519,
   "p": 0.6543284529538093,
   "placebo_affected": 369,
   "placebo_at_risk": 82565,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.0023167478290928157,
    "hi": 1.7974196321299507,
    "i2": 0.6493356512969779,
    "lo": 0.6191668479307002,
    "p": 0.8440396311921422,
    "rr": 1.054942011692899,
    "tau2": 0.2886241675751655
   },
   "rd": 2.434274116920391,
   "rd_hi": 11.06734313700385,
   "rd_lo": -6.198794903163067,
   "rr": 1.0567442444984598,
   "se": 0.12326483425638363,
   "se_binomial": 0.07197774131935142,
   "se_clustered": 0.12326483425638363,
   "trials": 25,
   "trials_with_events": 10,
   "vaccine_affected": 393,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 95360
  },
  "id": "mrna_inert",
  "name": "mRNA vaccines against inert placebo"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 115,
   "comparisons_with_events": 96,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 9453,
    "higher": 1.0596800316837125,
    "lower": 0.9436810830634529
   },
   "hi": 1.0375360803732947,
   "lo": 0.9615793929964442,
   "log_rr": -0.0011646982807743576,
   "p": 0.9521145718197798,
   "placebo_affected": 3646,
   "placebo_at_risk": 95758,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9525683676848197,
    "hi": 1.0312266385591509,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9572186980794116,
    "p": 0.7327574930358469,
    "rr": 0.9935338043501079,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -0.4889760124632601,
   "rd_hi": 15.406268164771951,
   "rd_lo": -16.38422018969847,
   "rr": 0.9988359797170218,
   "se": 0.019394972082256125,
   "se_binomial": 0.019394972082256125,
   "se_clustered": 0.015542396604454608,
   "trials": 112,
   "trials_with_events": 93,
   "vaccine_affected": 5807,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 118854
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 73,
   "comparisons_with_events": 26,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1206,
    "higher": 1.178482642452033,
    "lower": 0.8485487727840696
   },
   "hi": 1.111428411675763,
   "lo": 0.8862780502254394,
   "log_rr": -0.007539252886104333,
   "p": 0.896129036819661,
   "placebo_affected": 533,
   "placebo_at_risk": 40328,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9198559606317434,
    "hi": 1.1073221466647072,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8831419371201529,
    "p": 0.8466253604842613,
    "rr": 0.9888997045310083,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -0.9685076782062693,
   "rd_hi": 13.566390951518676,
   "rd_lo": -15.503406307931211,
   "rr": 0.9924890959930754,
   "se": 0.05774866185533043,
   "se_binomial": 0.05774866185533043,
   "se_clustered": 0.02434428588252692,
   "trials": 70,
   "trials_with_events": 25,
   "vaccine_affected": 673,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 58814
  },
  "id": "aluminium",
  "name": "Aluminium-adjuvanted vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 75,
   "comparisons_with_events": 62,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 7443,
    "higher": 1.0700890409941546,
    "lower": 0.9345016738709528
   },
   "hi": 1.0478378921007012,
   "lo": 0.9632757279369508,
   "log_rr": 0.0046566522515510515,
   "p": 0.8282603032102459,
   "placebo_affected": 2661,
   "placebo_at_risk": 26984,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9866161423176363,
    "hi": 1.0413208299273853,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9589229491364455,
    "p": 0.9724106759368455,
    "rr": 0.9992729563193329,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 4.7228883572904765,
   "rd_hi": 47.202773715923975,
   "rd_lo": -37.756997001343024,
   "rr": 1.004667511305717,
   "se": 0.021465822113373202,
   "se_binomial": 0.021465822113373202,
   "se_clustered": 0.01467895642204936,
   "trials": 73,
   "trials_with_events": 60,
   "vaccine_affected": 4782,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 48417
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 55,
   "comparisons_with_events": 16,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1143,
    "higher": 1.1882539044397726,
    "lower": 0.8415709776030327
   },
   "hi": 1.1379556276686238,
   "lo": 0.901830382953688,
   "log_rr": 0.01295226066596481,
   "p": 0.8271832857516181,
   "placebo_affected": 497,
   "placebo_at_risk": 23589,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9947673519844341,
    "hi": 1.1304736389624879,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8966222331024319,
    "p": 0.9089962368230704,
    "rr": 1.0067809089518822,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 2.517636397341763,
   "rd_hi": 25.101261141561693,
   "rd_lo": -20.06598834687817,
   "rr": 1.0130365045173344,
   "se": 0.059328172749162904,
   "se_binomial": 0.059328172749162904,
   "se_clustered": 0.008444524335401767,
   "trials": 53,
   "trials_with_events": 15,
   "vaccine_affected": 646,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 41666
  },
  "id": "aluminium_inert",
  "name": "Aluminium-adjuvanted vaccines against inert placebo"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 72,
   "comparisons_with_events": 60,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 10367,
    "higher": 1.0567394420374707,
    "lower": 0.9463070651284928
   },
   "hi": 0.9936315746230715,
   "lo": 0.9247604811803702,
   "log_rr": -0.04230465228514141,
   "p": 0.020965422147945424,
   "placebo_affected": 5108,
   "placebo_at_risk": 56270,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6731558214401991,
    "hi": 0.9935839491821687,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9250260051619246,
    "p": 0.020729887074154255,
    "rr": 0.9586923340180572,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -36.92912544049699,
   "rd_hi": -5.520245851768917,
   "rd_lo": -68.33800502922507,
   "rr": 0.9585777031959593,
   "se": 0.018324755954494454,
   "se_binomial": 0.018324755954494454,
   "se_clustered": 0.014452022964405146,
   "trials": 72,
   "trials_with_events": 60,
   "vaccine_affected": 5259,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 65441
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 65,
   "comparisons_with_events": 33,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 2048,
    "higher": 1.132020946874266,
    "lower": 0.8833758798909138
   },
   "hi": 0.9622785641923541,
   "lo": 0.8123581953573709,
   "log_rr": -0.12313260563332978,
   "p": 0.004372935858858826,
   "placebo_affected": 1076,
   "placebo_at_risk": 54735,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8186963459562142,
    "hi": 0.9649492063355692,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8143752110252787,
    "p": 0.005363345472940937,
    "rr": 0.8864709321451011,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -22.286414733265772,
   "rd_hi": -6.996708720309887,
   "rd_lo": -37.576120746221655,
   "rr": 0.8841464119920313,
   "se": 0.04320554008531007,
   "se_binomial": 0.04320554008531007,
   "se_clustered": 0.03566402708214809,
   "trials": 65,
   "trials_with_events": 33,
   "vaccine_affected": 972,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 61149
  },
  "id": "other_adjuvant",
  "name": "Vaccines with a non-aluminium adjuvant"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 52,
   "comparisons_with_events": 41,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5490,
    "higher": 1.0790266590307758,
    "lower": 0.9267611616734655
   },
   "hi": 1.01929230773659,
   "lo": 0.9238894887365857,
   "log_rr": -0.03002712243882807,
   "p": 0.23101592117571157,
   "placebo_affected": 2644,
   "placebo_at_risk": 23685,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6528308757536052,
    "hi": 1.0169717616930727,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9221284647983256,
    "p": 0.19840281931234227,
    "rr": 0.968389699115641,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -32.26462461297297,
   "rd_hi": 20.719812083315922,
   "rd_lo": -85.24906130926188,
   "rr": 0.9704192130558281,
   "se": 0.025069691580466773,
   "se_binomial": 0.025069691580466773,
   "se_clustered": 0.021628500983342767,
   "trials": 52,
   "trials_with_events": 41,
   "vaccine_affected": 2846,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 29364
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 46,
   "comparisons_with_events": 22,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1231,
    "higher": 1.174113890218773,
    "lower": 0.8517061320292102
   },
   "hi": 1.0287886162410396,
   "lo": 0.8282882327192765,
   "log_rr": -0.0800060343338778,
   "p": 0.14797071659008323,
   "placebo_affected": 630,
   "placebo_at_risk": 23289,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9821549316029777,
    "hi": 1.0209674100025836,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.822498659866154,
    "p": 0.11327050030823076,
    "rr": 0.9163756470433635,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -19.9452023430966,
   "rd_hi": 6.99738567831659,
   "rd_lo": -46.88779036450978,
   "rr": 0.9231107760112004,
   "se": 0.055301038023836666,
   "se_binomial": 0.055301038023836666,
   "se_clustered": 0.014995237232367507,
   "trials": 46,
   "trials_with_events": 22,
   "vaccine_affected": 601,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 28494
  },
  "id": "other_adjuvant_inert",
  "name": "Vaccines with a non-aluminium adjuvant against inert placebo"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 331,
   "comparisons_with_events": 268,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 34805,
    "higher": 1.0307789555803581,
    "lower": 0.9701401009268482
   },
   "hi": 1.0226666373019557,
   "lo": 0.9467451103658017,
   "log_rr": -0.016155905371223113,
   "p": 0.4116542901283494,
   "placebo_affected": 15208,
   "placebo_at_risk": 339322,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.00048307970861761855,
    "hi": 1.0067900427850076,
    "i2": 0.23694905133242533,
    "lo": 0.9368263343658279,
    "p": 0.11145996297652405,
    "rr": 0.9711783694349322,
    "tau2": 0.008714848994409429
   },
   "rd": -7.242784804161302,
   "rd_hi": 9.942019510865364,
   "rd_lo": -24.427589119187967,
   "rr": 0.9839739012798374,
   "se": 0.019678663227620154,
   "se_binomial": 0.010152654822623803,
   "se_clustered": 0.019678663227620154,
   "trials": 325,
   "trials_with_events": 263,
   "vaccine_affected": 19597,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 445922
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 243,
   "comparisons_with_events": 81,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 3348,
    "higher": 1.1027176171415425,
    "lower": 0.9068504796288587
   },
   "hi": 1.0634277147839934,
   "lo": 0.9262667562503359,
   "log_rr": -0.007547813971048981,
   "p": 0.8303463474940462,
   "placebo_affected": 1586,
   "placebo_at_risk": 252908,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.42186952972906766,
    "hi": 1.0586768704436114,
    "i2": 0.02250021516788608,
    "lo": 0.9076849347159797,
    "p": 0.6118580552817865,
    "rr": 0.9802780452677328,
    "tau2": 0.002586405572010878
   },
   "rd": -0.4498329462596283,
   "rd_hi": 3.62279778023544,
   "rd_lo": -4.522463672754696,
   "rr": 0.9924805992459887,
   "se": 0.03522778895209546,
   "se_binomial": 0.032802174643057715,
   "se_clustered": 0.03522778895209546,
   "trials": 238,
   "trials_with_events": 81,
   "vaccine_affected": 1762,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 334121
  },
  "id": "no_adjuvant",
  "name": "Vaccines with no adjuvant"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 41,
   "comparisons_with_events": 40,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5392,
    "higher": 1.0793639632196077,
    "lower": 0.92647154627724
   },
   "hi": 0.9647604754285473,
   "lo": 0.8663507808798258,
   "log_rr": -0.08967040706257752,
   "p": 0.0010867549335189094,
   "placebo_affected": 2622,
   "placebo_at_risk": 50419,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.3836807242114817,
    "hi": 0.9710254955124588,
    "i2": 0.048328818321599507,
    "lo": 0.8640019490077926,
    "p": 0.0032094340164716927,
    "rr": 0.9159519204952965,
    "tau2": 0.0015761298903456417
   },
   "rd": -45.8070415477644,
   "rd_hi": -7.4748801154588245,
   "rd_lo": -84.13920298006995,
   "rr": 0.9142324601814977,
   "se": 0.027446925871387955,
   "se_binomial": 0.025966385138821067,
   "se_clustered": 0.027446925871387955,
   "trials": 40,
   "trials_with_events": 39,
   "vaccine_affected": 2770,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 54775
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 20,
   "comparisons_with_events": 3,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 19,
    "higher": 3.6343690858204996,
    "lower": 0.27515092066502067
   },
   "hi": 1.5982142852478458,
   "lo": 0.30246396031524486,
   "log_rr": -0.36345310690441784,
   "p": 0.39208289397783413,
   "placebo_affected": 11,
   "placebo_at_risk": 3500,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.3795291970991571,
    "hi": 1.5751235580675267,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.28657005755267695,
    "p": 0.36026128247137734,
    "rr": 0.67185061486017,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -9.426019323722663,
   "rd_hi": 13.495190039008822,
   "rd_lo": -32.347228686454145,
   "rr": 0.6952713298766617,
   "se": 0.42467108638639667,
   "se_binomial": 0.42467108638639667,
   "se_clustered": 0.2583217278874144,
   "trials": 20,
   "trials_with_events": 3,
   "vaccine_affected": 8,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 4173
  },
  "id": "infants",
  "name": "Trials of infants (to 2 years)"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 84,
   "comparisons_with_events": 74,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 11024,
    "higher": 1.055932376121049,
    "lower": 0.9470303426754317
   },
   "hi": 0.963961178146852,
   "lo": 0.8794087990224548,
   "log_rr": -0.08260483669433334,
   "p": 0.00041991094543092605,
   "placebo_affected": 4546,
   "placebo_at_risk": 87279,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.07965112582280572,
    "hi": 0.9719007551056714,
    "i2": 0.19420939889045818,
    "lo": 0.8646607423111025,
    "p": 0.003550581933676055,
    "rr": 0.9167139294034922,
    "tau2": 0.006914578815351667
   },
   "rd": -42.39660109615377,
   "rd_hi": -14.40150557039391,
   "rd_lo": -70.39169662191364,
   "rr": 0.9207149080895746,
   "se": 0.02341909335065426,
   "se_binomial": 0.01858388744296534,
   "se_clustered": 0.02341909335065426,
   "trials": 83,
   "trials_with_events": 73,
   "vaccine_affected": 6478,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 129890
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 45,
   "comparisons_with_events": 10,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 138,
    "higher": 1.6665771609538638,
    "lower": 0.6000322237871368
   },
   "hi": 1.250515176289034,
   "lo": 0.6275912870216558,
   "log_rr": -0.12115526689649987,
   "p": 0.490906939324371,
   "placebo_affected": 52,
   "placebo_at_risk": 31130,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6373049651782222,
    "hi": 1.201247323092754,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.6014499971108477,
    "p": 0.3570755037737414,
    "rr": 0.8499942346884186,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -1.8300534845451029,
   "rd_hi": 3.4437731700672787,
   "rd_lo": -7.103880139157485,
   "rr": 0.8858963985293922,
   "se": 0.17587612544676853,
   "se_binomial": 0.17587612544676853,
   "se_clustered": 0.1366537649665476,
   "trials": 45,
   "trials_with_events": 10,
   "vaccine_affected": 86,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 65804
  },
  "id": "children",
  "name": "Trials of children (under 18 years)"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 38,
   "comparisons_with_events": 32,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5024,
    "higher": 1.0889893693210453,
    "lower": 0.9182826097039609
   },
   "hi": 1.0251763173634687,
   "lo": 0.8819910643781967,
   "log_rr": -0.050354369690010954,
   "p": 0.18949571451831548,
   "placebo_affected": 1715,
   "placebo_at_risk": 24250,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.05336761995055926,
    "hi": 1.106017807194594,
    "i2": 0.30595474595073474,
    "lo": 0.8607115504833114,
    "p": 0.7003987132193463,
    "rr": 0.9756855547217101,
    "tau2": 0.017297703832143674
   },
   "rd": -34.2658183507744,
   "rd_hi": 28.619764162627465,
   "rd_lo": -97.15140086417627,
   "rr": 0.9508923973440558,
   "se": 0.03837773776821131,
   "se_binomial": 0.027778155703793956,
   "se_clustered": 0.03837773776821131,
   "trials": 38,
   "trials_with_events": 32,
   "vaccine_affected": 3309,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 53268
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 25,
   "comparisons_with_events": 5,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 86,
    "higher": 1.9245837565472173,
    "lower": 0.519592871236761
   },
   "hi": 1.1636018383938806,
   "lo": 0.4931301003185554,
   "log_rr": -0.2777310085136968,
   "p": 0.20475451727112226,
   "placebo_affected": 34,
   "placebo_at_risk": 20927,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.36871473290953943,
    "hi": 1.2461459780135047,
    "i2": 0.06667125136023591,
    "lo": 0.42836941537535067,
    "p": 0.24925870287137297,
    "rr": 0.7306235857635515,
    "tau2": 0.041727247841003165
   },
   "rd": -3.8636457083816738,
   "rd_hi": 2.387621943924426,
   "rd_lo": -10.114913360687773,
   "rr": 0.7575005553120274,
   "se": 0.2190097553171752,
   "se_binomial": 0.2190097553171752,
   "se_clustered": 0.10678842251305494,
   "trials": 25,
   "trials_with_events": 5,
   "vaccine_affected": 52,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 47142
  },
  "id": "children_inert",
  "name": "Trials of children against inert placebo"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 294,
   "comparisons_with_events": 228,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 17826,
    "higher": 1.0434345747960512,
    "lower": 0.9583734564243849
   },
   "hi": 1.0168601511184474,
   "lo": 0.9171159678758113,
   "log_rr": -0.03490087693955922,
   "p": 0.18512402557191276,
   "placebo_affected": 7492,
   "placebo_at_risk": 183002,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.4449358141924613,
    "hi": 0.9895926420232083,
    "i2": 0.009994975039352141,
    "lo": 0.935540540356479,
    "p": 0.007143469514265171,
    "rr": 0.9621871102083981,
    "tau2": 0.000431268541675438
   },
   "rd": -14.286015772334382,
   "rd_hi": 4.769657445249374,
   "rd_lo": -33.34168898991813,
   "rr": 0.9657011347654815,
   "se": 0.02633745995291288,
   "se_binomial": 0.0136741322689259,
   "se_clustered": 0.02633745995291288,
   "trials": 289,
   "trials_with_events": 224,
   "vaccine_affected": 10334,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 252933
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 230,
   "comparisons_with_events": 75,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 2563,
    "higher": 1.1181242575240615,
    "lower": 0.8943549818106691
   },
   "hi": 1.0293146779671232,
   "lo": 0.8164989755556349,
   "log_rr": -0.08691820082827638,
   "p": 0.14129591538991335,
   "placebo_affected": 1282,
   "placebo_at_risk": 160695,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.46169081431232106,
    "hi": 0.9887354450400915,
    "i2": 0.006770634099130751,
    "lo": 0.8441573889086829,
    "p": 0.025034904825479393,
    "rr": 0.9135908994766246,
    "tau2": 0.0010065122727762558
   },
   "rd": -6.334763241609936,
   "rd_hi": -1.1166398840734222,
   "rd_lo": -11.55288659914645,
   "rr": 0.9167520821271878,
   "se": 0.059088544698706856,
   "se_binomial": 0.03655661194568479,
   "se_clustered": 0.059088544698706856,
   "trials": 226,
   "trials_with_events": 74,
   "vaccine_affected": 1281,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 209495
  },
  "id": "adults",
  "name": "Trials of adults (from 18 years)"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 64,
   "comparisons_with_events": 61,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 23395,
    "higher": 1.037356881649278,
    "lower": 0.9639883994504526
   },
   "hi": 1.0253611007345254,
   "lo": 0.9749996523507863,
   "log_rr": -0.00013666029924504924,
   "p": 0.9915132645532987,
   "placebo_affected": 10933,
   "placebo_at_risk": 166497,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6953590099664387,
    "hi": 1.0211630740379303,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.97292552858437,
    "p": 0.7921689184526084,
    "rr": 0.9967525387874331,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -0.09101025814310401,
   "rd_hi": 16.685827228018763,
   "rd_lo": -16.86784774430497,
   "rr": 0.9998633490383483,
   "se": 0.01284794223179835,
   "se_binomial": 0.012375213055876497,
   "se_clustered": 0.01284794223179835,
   "trials": 61,
   "trials_with_events": 58,
   "vaccine_affected": 12462,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 183404
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 49,
   "comparisons_with_events": 32,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 3750,
    "higher": 1.0960650013167776,
    "lower": 0.9123546494036683
   },
   "hi": 1.0356996207857088,
   "lo": 0.9122099313881467,
   "log_rr": -0.02840398350086967,
   "p": 0.3805052749944585,
   "placebo_affected": 1803,
   "placebo_at_risk": 105170,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.987227374418558,
    "hi": 1.0313777026102913,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9084042527400342,
    "p": 0.31438370762955736,
    "rr": 0.9679400246050552,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -4.749845180923824,
   "rd_hi": 5.8679890489475754,
   "rd_lo": -15.367679410795226,
   "rr": 0.9719956172821259,
   "se": 0.032388933659246916,
   "se_binomial": 0.032388933659246916,
   "se_clustered": 0.024363971889941095,
   "trials": 46,
   "trials_with_events": 32,
   "vaccine_affected": 1947,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 121063
  },
  "id": "older_adults",
  "name": "Trials of adults aged 50 and over"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 59,
   "comparisons_with_events": 49,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 3411,
    "higher": 1.10124350888659,
    "lower": 0.9080643762532122
   },
   "hi": 1.3328115369134652,
   "lo": 0.9970078294876284,
   "log_rr": 0.14214699626808497,
   "p": 0.054921299835724455,
   "placebo_affected": 1406,
   "placebo_at_risk": 58557,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.07564027216065027,
    "hi": 1.2211724587546267,
    "i2": 0.23426666272232555,
    "lo": 0.9835256434707016,
    "p": 0.09709774836096206,
    "rr": 1.0959262877973788,
    "tau2": 0.02102229395712984
   },
   "rd": 36.796161383369565,
   "rd_hi": 61.86131222153615,
   "rd_lo": 11.731010545202974,
   "rr": 1.152746085456014,
   "se": 0.07405424399246617,
   "se_binomial": 0.03362468136034913,
   "se_clustered": 0.07405424399246617,
   "trials": 58,
   "trials_with_events": 48,
   "vaccine_affected": 2005,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 71830
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 42,
   "comparisons_with_events": 19,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 151,
    "higher": 1.5805081626892277,
    "lower": 0.6327078996533017
   },
   "hi": 2.9928094267641767,
   "lo": 0.7672026258924447,
   "log_rr": 0.41560411056922414,
   "p": 0.23137483206552756,
   "placebo_affected": 54,
   "placebo_at_risk": 51153,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.14088704383125028,
    "hi": 1.606327184978175,
    "i2": 0.2637478898720394,
    "lo": 0.5640045872034551,
    "p": 0.853301807483688,
    "rr": 0.9518276634335144,
    "tau2": 0.27789224826260456
   },
   "rd": 5.59564230812102,
   "rd_hi": 15.463616265973265,
   "rd_lo": -4.272331649731225,
   "rr": 1.5152858644523608,
   "se": 0.3472555839249569,
   "se_binomial": 0.16784599959611157,
   "se_clustered": 0.3472555839249569,
   "trials": 41,
   "trials_with_events": 19,
   "vaccine_affected": 97,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 60990
  },
  "id": "mixed_ages",
  "name": "Trials spanning children and adults"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 16,
   "comparisons_with_events": 16,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5271,
    "higher": 1.082263178544396,
    "lower": 0.9239896725905091
   },
   "hi": 1.0816145894383307,
   "lo": 0.983111519644851,
   "log_rr": 0.03071109898353358,
   "p": 0.20740170820849524,
   "placebo_affected": 1923,
   "placebo_at_risk": 8220,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.925666217421323,
    "hi": 1.0776693479790591,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9809541233620666,
    "p": 0.24673251166750154,
    "rr": 1.0281751750168684,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 75.876578399598,
   "rd_hi": 193.50092822840725,
   "rd_lo": -41.74777142921125,
   "rr": 1.031187549717683,
   "se": 0.024359537209821033,
   "se_binomial": 0.024359537209821033,
   "se_clustered": 0.008723865110883432,
   "trials": 15,
   "trials_with_events": 15,
   "vaccine_affected": 3348,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 12766
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 13,
   "comparisons_with_events": 5,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 9,
    "higher": 6.760994653703591,
    "lower": 0.1479072312906226
   },
   "hi": 2.0453116778941633,
   "lo": 0.1551518290214423,
   "log_rr": -0.5739004559087827,
   "p": 0.383029326264691,
   "placebo_affected": 5,
   "placebo_at_risk": 8085,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.7040495582071934,
    "hi": 2.0419212759663075,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.16831224508672815,
    "p": 0.4016202691995948,
    "rr": 0.586242572872566,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -2.7259447636890335,
   "rd_hi": 3.795596067960702,
   "rd_lo": -9.24748559533877,
   "rr": 0.5633239278995652,
   "se": 0.657895065173933,
   "se_binomial": 0.657895065173933,
   "se_clustered": 0.5196000020460692,
   "trials": 13,
   "trials_with_events": 5,
   "vaccine_affected": 4,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 12435
  },
  "id": "pregnant",
  "name": "Pregnant women"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 15,
   "comparisons_with_events": 14,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 7405,
    "higher": 1.06880240497462,
    "lower": 0.9356266372021741
   },
   "hi": 0.9912794114122718,
   "lo": 0.9305902174960751,
   "log_rr": -0.04034754355287123,
   "p": 0.012300026313848382,
   "placebo_affected": 2804,
   "placebo_at_risk": 8376,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8940972434732212,
    "hi": 0.967085713541997,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9263682986259308,
    "p": 5.446495070849017e-07,
    "rr": 0.9465080808315078,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -140.27869598156013,
   "rd_hi": 69.98252269435822,
   "rd_lo": -350.5399146574785,
   "rr": 0.9604555809955645,
   "se": 0.016116983839209932,
   "se_binomial": 0.015954062348541177,
   "se_clustered": 0.016116983839209932,
   "trials": 15,
   "trials_with_events": 14,
   "vaccine_affected": 4601,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 12718
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 13,
   "comparisons_with_events": 8,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 73,
    "higher": 1.9533529793150068,
    "lower": 0.5119402435655411
   },
   "hi": 1.9636714538113802,
   "lo": 0.47280307859621473,
   "log_rr": -0.03713019488475781,
   "p": 0.9185834866243613,
   "placebo_affected": 28,
   "placebo_at_risk": 8263,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.5163691201792875,
    "hi": 1.5232613680449223,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.5258453863572498,
    "p": 0.6826142575354939,
    "rr": 0.8949860125178801,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -1.193675831162064,
   "rd_hi": 21.00598870809973,
   "rd_lo": -23.393340370423854,
   "rr": 0.9635506778128098,
   "se": 0.3632444813340328,
   "se_binomial": 0.2590755559392978,
   "se_clustered": 0.3632444813340328,
   "trials": 13,
   "trials_with_events": 8,
   "vaccine_affected": 45,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 12435
  },
  "id": "offspring",
  "name": "Infants born to women vaccinated in pregnancy"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 55,
   "comparisons_with_events": 53,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 8877,
    "higher": 1.0623350988057052,
    "lower": 0.9413225649083953
   },
   "hi": 1.0131554466450716,
   "lo": 0.9461660460150728,
   "log_rr": -0.02113376786897966,
   "p": 0.22588345255774034,
   "placebo_affected": 3900,
   "placebo_at_risk": 17686,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9065627527992226,
    "hi": 1.0093556119807459,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9451051175770168,
    "p": 0.16003107108760173,
    "rr": 0.9767021830312884,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -45.07647840914183,
   "rd_hi": 27.843357215367362,
   "rd_lo": -117.99631403365103,
   "rr": 0.9790879852959091,
   "se": 0.017451051720869467,
   "se_binomial": 0.017451051720869467,
   "se_clustered": 0.011523206510631767,
   "trials": 54,
   "trials_with_events": 52,
   "vaccine_affected": 4977,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 25503
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 45,
   "comparisons_with_events": 32,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 2137,
    "higher": 1.1325857491870732,
    "lower": 0.8829353545351968
   },
   "hi": 1.0762542925592522,
   "lo": 0.9215463629039881,
   "log_rr": -0.004107712757831777,
   "p": 0.9173622027144419,
   "placebo_affected": 990,
   "placebo_at_risk": 12793,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.804250585213636,
    "hi": 1.077783741262205,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9232235728812295,
    "p": 0.9497513606638636,
    "rr": 0.9975145895681885,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -2.8795442162409945,
   "rd_hi": 51.39304892102532,
   "rd_lo": -57.1521373535073,
   "rr": 0.9959007123542907,
   "se": 0.03958974652102485,
   "se_binomial": 0.03958974652102485,
   "se_clustered": 0.018829674575561898,
   "trials": 44,
   "trials_with_events": 32,
   "vaccine_affected": 1147,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 20372
  },
  "id": "patients",
  "name": "People enrolled for a medical condition"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 446,
   "comparisons_with_events": 359,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 46779,
    "higher": 1.0264510467363896,
    "lower": 0.9742305813604156
   },
   "hi": 1.0125586692540813,
   "lo": 0.9531159341104724,
   "log_rr": -0.01776913386121416,
   "p": 0.24960201896017153,
   "placebo_affected": 20477,
   "placebo_at_risk": 477649,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.004738001374977685,
    "hi": 0.9967818813979747,
    "i2": 0.16982905583034855,
    "lo": 0.9415674430392788,
    "p": 0.029132602496298773,
    "rr": 0.9687813826327242,
    "tau2": 0.006047670025752823
   },
   "rd": -7.653617440721939,
   "rd_hi": 5.438673430529581,
   "rd_lo": -20.745908311973455,
   "rr": 0.9823878062597075,
   "se": 0.015433751397133058,
   "se_binomial": 0.008933837728527814,
   "se_clustered": 0.015433751397133058,
   "trials": 437,
   "trials_with_events": 351,
   "vaccine_affected": 26302,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 612554
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 321,
   "comparisons_with_events": 104,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 4465,
    "higher": 1.0882705542781825,
    "lower": 0.9188891457816482
   },
   "hi": 1.0043711673850926,
   "lo": 0.8804754762216892,
   "log_rr": -0.06146578097824468,
   "p": 0.06723509614926611,
   "placebo_affected": 2201,
   "placebo_at_risk": 335355,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.49267101079735837,
    "hi": 0.9886506881573499,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.879707026252863,
    "p": 0.01911946314419721,
    "rr": 0.9325893827841645,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -3.7182428741652536,
   "rd_hi": 0.5363381040559005,
   "rd_lo": -7.972823852386408,
   "rr": 0.940385124247892,
   "se": 0.03358603656003261,
   "se_binomial": 0.02966831368158305,
   "se_clustered": 0.03358603656003261,
   "trials": 314,
   "trials_with_events": 103,
   "vaccine_affected": 2264,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 436980
  },
  "id": "general",
  "name": "Healthy people and the general population"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 475,
   "comparisons_with_events": 390,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 55251,
    "higher": 1.0243034374932303,
    "lower": 0.9762732051815545
   },
   "hi": 1.0077594727784898,
   "lo": 0.9571191164291409,
   "log_rr": -0.01804895189838003,
   "p": 0.16997616175844632,
   "placebo_affected": 24246,
   "placebo_at_risk": 485875,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.011250113696572603,
    "hi": 0.9951803577796705,
    "i2": 0.14586739926589035,
    "lo": 0.9483008208406568,
    "p": 0.01865018886339995,
    "rr": 0.9714578478590618,
    "tau2": 0.004280496306555004
   },
   "rd": -9.069978922462678,
   "rd_hi": 4.018028426547608,
   "rd_lo": -22.157986271472964,
   "rr": 0.9821129548880032,
   "se": 0.013152524637380456,
   "se_binomial": 0.008028854986130695,
   "se_clustered": 0.013152524637380456,
   "trials": 466,
   "trials_with_events": 382,
   "vaccine_affected": 31005,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 619032
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 352,
   "comparisons_with_events": 133,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 6599,
    "higher": 1.0720660234722525,
    "lower": 0.9327783719524643
   },
   "hi": 1.0065684677326423,
   "lo": 0.9113464849203534,
   "log_rr": -0.04314256498552812,
   "p": 0.0888072434630477,
   "placebo_affected": 3190,
   "placebo_at_risk": 343898,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.5823810618347404,
    "hi": 1.0012489248121035,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9121117702267111,
    "p": 0.05645705155039638,
    "rr": 0.9556416322282945,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -3.750589234782433,
   "rd_hi": 0.5151787943334369,
   "rd_lo": -8.016357263898302,
   "rr": 0.9577748351777727,
   "se": 0.025352279090872926,
   "se_binomial": 0.023816837776505284,
   "se_clustered": 0.025352279090872926,
   "trials": 344,
   "trials_with_events": 132,
   "vaccine_affected": 3409,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 448778
  },
  "id": "masked",
  "name": "Double-blind or more"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 172,
   "comparisons_with_events": 162,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 49514,
    "higher": 1.0256469710731577,
    "lower": 0.974994348156342
   },
   "hi": 1.0080634286922439,
   "lo": 0.9529879896686546,
   "log_rr": -0.020060942552073413,
   "p": 0.16162127072913468,
   "placebo_affected": 22058,
   "placebo_at_risk": 453138,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 7.218625781022173e-10,
    "hi": 0.9994471691588385,
    "i2": 0.45293893476900043,
    "lo": 0.9357279878817992,
    "p": 0.04627586333763541,
    "rr": 0.9670629186310269,
    "tau2": 0.009523846691912564
   },
   "rd": -9.835257117052556,
   "rd_hi": 4.066562981248857,
   "rd_lo": -23.737077215353967,
   "rr": 0.9801389393182544,
   "se": 0.014332934437296727,
   "se_binomial": 0.00843165724534361,
   "se_clustered": 0.014332934437296727,
   "trials": 170,
   "trials_with_events": 160,
   "vaccine_affected": 27456,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 560587
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 112,
   "comparisons_with_events": 68,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 6220,
    "higher": 1.0741386918229605,
    "lower": 0.9309784738345688
   },
   "hi": 1.0126197140807647,
   "lo": 0.915818789641505,
   "log_rr": -0.037698006321223644,
   "p": 0.141369047876086,
   "placebo_affected": 3020,
   "placebo_at_risk": 315029,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.14150113333243663,
    "hi": 1.018025822237514,
    "i2": 0.15690984127570246,
    "lo": 0.8855690154494616,
    "p": 0.14496274543105278,
    "rr": 0.949490455508113,
    "tau2": 0.008415633692254227
   },
   "rd": -3.409420237847204,
   "rd_hi": 1.133233752899568,
   "rd_lo": -7.952074228593976,
   "rr": 0.9630037180180421,
   "se": 0.02563248889244439,
   "se_binomial": 0.024427365695432014,
   "se_clustered": 0.02563248889244439,
   "trials": 111,
   "trials_with_events": 68,
   "vaccine_affected": 3200,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 396747
  },
  "id": "late_phase",
  "name": "Phase 3 and 4"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 373,
   "comparisons_with_events": 321,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 53694,
    "higher": 1.0246587539255156,
    "lower": 0.9759346671942762
   },
   "hi": 1.0063078728082155,
   "lo": 0.9546343180422959,
   "log_rr": -0.020069431714728372,
   "p": 0.13559987299707665,
   "placebo_affected": 23664,
   "placebo_at_risk": 475997,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.0004127320122011978,
    "hi": 0.9934504748947237,
    "i2": 0.22225099176737093,
    "lo": 0.9414138088016538,
    "p": 0.014739110207254205,
    "rr": 0.9670822071708556,
    "tau2": 0.006049473758956998
   },
   "rd": -10.015346174452686,
   "rd_hi": 3.2753388231779184,
   "rd_lo": -23.30603117208329,
   "rr": 0.9801306187946912,
   "se": 0.01344794759562652,
   "se_binomial": 0.008128786928484474,
   "se_clustered": 0.01344794759562652,
   "trials": 365,
   "trials_with_events": 313,
   "vaccine_affected": 30030,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 606924
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 255,
   "comparisons_with_events": 104,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 6464,
    "higher": 1.0728315827038888,
    "lower": 0.9321127529445682
   },
   "hi": 1.0123407616485074,
   "lo": 0.9173934181679928,
   "log_rr": -0.03697681805079502,
   "p": 0.14108159565268863,
   "placebo_affected": 3122,
   "placebo_at_risk": 331648,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.5963799263993513,
    "hi": 1.0071235834236292,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9166943469253123,
    "p": 0.09607164443684832,
    "rr": 0.9608457189266152,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -3.265763461551841,
   "rd_hi": 1.0889520446451788,
   "rd_lo": -7.62047896774886,
   "rr": 0.9636984754992163,
   "se": 0.025123958008833668,
   "se_binomial": 0.02405290097862324,
   "se_clustered": 0.025123958008833668,
   "trials": 249,
   "trials_with_events": 103,
   "vaccine_affected": 3342,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 431946
  },
  "id": "industry",
  "name": "Industry lead sponsor"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 128,
   "comparisons_with_events": 91,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1962,
    "higher": 1.138943969805346,
    "lower": 0.8780063168260221
   },
   "hi": 1.1387209586743245,
   "lo": 0.942263006163477,
   "log_rr": 0.03521741141514009,
   "p": 0.4660202639194442,
   "placebo_affected": 713,
   "placebo_at_risk": 19338,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.995857697413711,
    "hi": 1.099567608797846,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9190585980674996,
    "p": 0.9085320818078174,
    "rr": 1.0052696479165086,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 13.287787410216337,
   "rd_hi": 49.370588527421035,
   "rd_lo": -22.79501370698836,
   "rr": 1.0358448888235272,
   "se": 0.04831122155355748,
   "se_binomial": 0.046184885322863765,
   "se_clustered": 0.04831122155355748,
   "trials": 126,
   "trials_with_events": 90,
   "vaccine_affected": 1249,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 31133
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 111,
   "comparisons_with_events": 32,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 138,
    "higher": 1.6292614684191602,
    "lower": 0.6137750259142137
   },
   "hi": 1.0636496379144327,
   "lo": 0.4769758594302039,
   "log_rr": -0.3392916747587621,
   "p": 0.09724438107126705,
   "placebo_affected": 69,
   "placebo_at_risk": 16500,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6763360935975811,
    "hi": 1.0076513335931072,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.506673331020369,
    "p": 0.05530084289697315,
    "rr": 0.7145278564889803,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -11.734820698523807,
   "rd_hi": 1.6336423552457537,
   "rd_lo": -25.103283752293365,
   "rr": 0.7122746662467098,
   "se": 0.20459443325322232,
   "se_binomial": 0.1711586391331993,
   "se_clustered": 0.20459443325322232,
   "trials": 109,
   "trials_with_events": 32,
   "vaccine_affected": 69,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 25406
  },
  "id": "not_industry",
  "name": "Other lead sponsor"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 117,
   "comparisons_with_events": 117,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 51336,
    "higher": 1.025172490224733,
    "lower": 0.9754456050423136
   },
   "hi": 1.0110347062656178,
   "lo": 0.9577992633233051,
   "log_rr": -0.01607139605424884,
   "p": 0.24415133887727625,
   "placebo_affected": 22880,
   "placebo_at_risk": 464786,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 2.76295908546043e-11,
    "hi": 1.013732868113751,
    "i2": 0.5271871660635556,
    "lo": 0.9516224198441645,
    "p": 0.265132248796498,
    "rr": 0.9821868076033057,
    "tau2": 0.008918171556139404
   },
   "rd": -7.97685515488038,
   "rd_hi": 5.580216944692306,
   "rd_lo": -21.53392725445307,
   "rr": 0.9840570597559386,
   "se": 0.013799061693904243,
   "se_binomial": 0.008291593654296847,
   "se_clustered": 0.013799061693904243,
   "trials": 116,
   "trials_with_events": 116,
   "vaccine_affected": 28456,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 570896
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 85,
   "comparisons_with_events": 71,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 6309,
    "higher": 1.0735727183478128,
    "lower": 0.9314692734917497
   },
   "hi": 1.0117767321841948,
   "lo": 0.9152030998412283,
   "log_rr": -0.038450672572194894,
   "p": 0.13297502817813836,
   "placebo_affected": 3061,
   "placebo_at_risk": 327580,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.1369421535481709,
    "hi": 1.0191341570147827,
    "i2": 0.15681272174118085,
    "lo": 0.8869486672400653,
    "p": 0.15411127948594325,
    "rr": 0.9507469075958591,
    "tau2": 0.008676676944896421
   },
   "rd": -3.3941881518628074,
   "rd_hi": 1.0252205286555662,
   "rd_lo": -7.813596832381181,
   "rr": 0.9622791703254329,
   "se": 0.025591591848557253,
   "se_binomial": 0.024304416036538785,
   "se_clustered": 0.025591591848557253,
   "trials": 84,
   "trials_with_events": 71,
   "vaccine_affected": 3248,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 410430
  },
  "id": "large",
  "name": "Comparisons of 1,000 participants or more"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 44,
   "comparisons_with_events": 40,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5497,
    "higher": 1.0787716890573877,
    "lower": 0.9269802036367705
   },
   "hi": 1.2099836904753611,
   "lo": 0.8390795692866809,
   "log_rr": 0.007578570901995364,
   "p": 0.9353184095760226,
   "placebo_affected": 2408,
   "placebo_at_risk": 147362,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 8.867117461248711e-15,
    "hi": 1.196260573827463,
    "i2": 0.7383709247184702,
    "lo": 0.8519641793106736,
    "p": 0.912680663286499,
    "rr": 1.0095400725194765,
    "tau2": 0.09786345672450297
   },
   "rd": 1.2743819904463092,
   "rd_hi": 32.10238815083352,
   "rd_lo": -29.553624169940903,
   "rr": 1.0076073609536478,
   "se": 0.09338350585512287,
   "se_binomial": 0.027402141929411667,
   "se_clustered": 0.09338350585512287,
   "trials": 43,
   "trials_with_events": 39,
   "vaccine_affected": 3089,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 173326
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 44,
   "comparisons_with_events": 14,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 507,
    "higher": 1.2835953204264468,
    "lower": 0.779061737049471
   },
   "hi": 1.3192020842348533,
   "lo": 0.5375881977866324,
   "log_rr": -0.17181768567536865,
   "p": 0.4530897968309213,
   "placebo_affected": 257,
   "placebo_at_risk": 147406,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 8.937105352702444e-05,
    "hi": 1.1431474148173117,
    "i2": 0.6842471654854669,
    "lo": 0.5117421310416931,
    "p": 0.19105592405993366,
    "rr": 0.7648507659363449,
    "tau2": 0.29212882120492134
   },
   "rd": -2.7442633415417186,
   "rd_hi": 4.5421900674931575,
   "rd_lo": -10.030716750576595,
   "rr": 0.842132692026728,
   "se": 0.2290066337242418,
   "se_binomial": 0.08965986169581916,
   "se_clustered": 0.2290066337242418,
   "trials": 43,
   "trials_with_events": 14,
   "vaccine_affected": 250,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 173352
  },
  "id": "covid",
  "name": "COVID-19 vaccines"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 457,
   "comparisons_with_events": 372,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 50159,
    "higher": 1.0256030505161893,
    "lower": 0.9750361014397304
   },
   "hi": 0.9989413558402497,
   "lo": 0.9595820753414123,
   "log_rr": -0.021158316206369834,
   "p": 0.03908866121914318,
   "placebo_affected": 21969,
   "placebo_at_risk": 347973,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9721020225209857,
    "hi": 0.9923012633042563,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.960947298126065,
    "p": 0.0036898120863671042,
    "rr": 0.9764984474638484,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -13.284320418420808,
   "rd_hi": -0.5815615327579914,
   "rd_lo": -25.98707930408363,
   "rr": 0.9790639506087184,
   "se": 0.010254836970012159,
   "se_binomial": 0.00835994011291284,
   "se_clustered": 0.010254836970012159,
   "trials": 448,
   "trials_with_events": 364,
   "vaccine_affected": 28190,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 464731
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 322,
   "comparisons_with_events": 122,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 6095,
    "higher": 1.0755731722417972,
    "lower": 0.9297368378161743
   },
   "hi": 1.0162213193058809,
   "lo": 0.9224495015127859,
   "log_rr": -0.032315743038471664,
   "p": 0.19072295344737245,
   "placebo_affected": 2934,
   "placebo_at_risk": 200742,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9947092627689519,
    "hi": 1.012771102241325,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9197209901584184,
    "p": 0.1487935890115318,
    "rr": 0.965125298060943,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -4.343556769687811,
   "rd_hi": 2.163289824669482,
   "rd_lo": -10.850403364045103,
   "rr": 0.9682008311400975,
   "se": 0.024697852835496144,
   "se_binomial": 0.024697852835496144,
   "se_clustered": 0.019070990985576037,
   "trials": 315,
   "trials_with_events": 121,
   "vaccine_affected": 3161,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 284000
  },
  "id": "not_covid",
  "name": "All vaccines but COVID-19"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 7,
   "comparisons_with_events": 5,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 160,
    "higher": 1.557372136704733,
    "lower": 0.642107288573889
   },
   "hi": 1.7761578743372086,
   "lo": 0.972272547232153,
   "log_rr": 0.27316670919405445,
   "p": 0.07556168382452809,
   "placebo_affected": 69,
   "placebo_at_risk": 3077,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.7051527914612061,
    "hi": 1.7516140915064684,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.960823558970988,
    "p": 0.08930301434606992,
    "rr": 1.2973018482007104,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 69.93489837356992,
   "rd_hi": 146.67576982873175,
   "rd_lo": -6.8059730815918895,
   "rr": 1.314119302334565,
   "se": 0.15372008089589626,
   "se_binomial": 0.15372008089589626,
   "se_clustered": 0.08235470823994756,
   "trials": 7,
   "trials_with_events": 5,
   "vaccine_affected": 91,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 3147
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 6,
   "comparisons_with_events": 1,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 4,
    "higher": 16.47412741266744,
    "lower": 0.06070124231472622
   },
   "hi": 3.1980229113039917,
   "lo": 0.03474368827013987,
   "log_rr": -1.0986122886681098,
   "p": 0.3409556010274877,
   "placebo_affected": 3,
   "placebo_at_risk": 2877,
   "random_effects": {
    "hi": null,
    "i2": null,
    "lo": null,
    "p": null,
    "rr": null,
    "tau2": null
   },
   "rd": -6.8920931201589335,
   "rd_hi": 6.830533675455794,
   "rd_lo": -20.614719915773662,
   "rr": 0.3333333333333333,
   "se": 1.1536666323026183,
   "se_binomial": 1.1536666323026183,
   "se_clustered": null,
   "trials": 6,
   "trials_with_events": 1,
   "vaccine_affected": 1,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 2945
  },
  "id": "off_target",
  "name": "Vaccines given against a disease other than their own"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 10,
   "comparisons_with_events": 8,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 4107,
    "higher": 1.0927343845600583,
    "lower": 0.9151354749421619
   },
   "hi": 1.0473421129360447,
   "lo": 0.9340850891703708,
   "log_rr": -0.010966054530540312,
   "p": 0.7072064175427744,
   "placebo_affected": 1597,
   "placebo_at_risk": 12380,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.28600768617176997,
    "hi": 1.0800060312260806,
    "i2": 0.182000773760379,
    "lo": 0.8976637231671255,
    "p": 0.7425454991408145,
    "rr": 0.9846228897569639,
    "tau2": 0.002819728004370839
   },
   "rd": -15.033998914941561,
   "rd_hi": 63.40746908178881,
   "rd_lo": -93.47546691167194,
   "rr": 0.9890938534607067,
   "se": 0.029195275258529153,
   "se_binomial": 0.029195275258529153,
   "se_clustered": 0.01165142446583689,
   "trials": 10,
   "trials_with_events": 8,
   "vaccine_affected": 2510,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 17356
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 5,
   "comparisons_with_events": 4,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1122,
    "higher": 1.1843955623762317,
    "lower": 0.8443125183563824
   },
   "hi": 1.1388026055943188,
   "lo": 0.9011725299758898,
   "log_rr": 0.012959405970564431,
   "p": 0.8281612458462582,
   "placebo_affected": 491,
   "placebo_at_risk": 12268,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.7064539318045244,
    "hi": 1.1366668071705823,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8995240225604336,
    "p": 0.8524115293518847,
    "rr": 1.011167196212875,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 5.1415607582084,
   "rd_hi": 51.555156983714696,
   "rd_lo": -41.27203546729789,
   "rr": 1.0130437429975903,
   "se": 0.05970413664029268,
   "se_binomial": 0.05970413664029268,
   "se_clustered": 0.007654498615103397,
   "trials": 5,
   "trials_with_events": 4,
   "vaccine_affected": 631,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 16650
  },
  "id": "target_c_difficile",
  "name": "Vaccines against c difficile"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 7,
   "comparisons_with_events": 5,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 116,
    "higher": 1.8349856285965795,
    "lower": 0.5449633961246949
   },
   "hi": 2.5327567684650933,
   "lo": 0.6795653829433144,
   "log_rr": 0.27150325672238695,
   "p": 0.4185393721782831,
   "placebo_affected": 28,
   "placebo_at_risk": 2189,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.12948174750470717,
    "hi": 2.4256990752217513,
    "i2": 0.43851293782380674,
    "lo": 0.5977228660899467,
    "p": 0.6032021703198572,
    "rr": 1.204116191865751,
    "tau2": 0.26929755968675895
   },
   "rd": 34.25261832430101,
   "rd_hi": 100.9340316035702,
   "rd_lo": -32.428794954968176,
   "rr": 1.3119351444580836,
   "se": 0.3356210035508708,
   "se_binomial": 0.23774672759248303,
   "se_clustered": 0.3356210035508708,
   "trials": 7,
   "trials_with_events": 5,
   "vaccine_affected": 88,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 6843
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 7,
   "comparisons_with_events": 3,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 6,
    "higher": 14.427283761904198,
    "lower": 0.06931311648839532
   },
   "hi": 5.462667689168545,
   "lo": 0.15438539243085456,
   "log_rr": -0.08518299813955392,
   "p": 0.9254021599158881,
   "placebo_affected": 2,
   "placebo_at_risk": 2189,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9469334096749039,
    "hi": 3.4458639951776315,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.14712841777348254,
    "p": 0.6729035589000117,
    "rr": 0.7120284527131596,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -0.6519530820534951,
   "rd_hi": 13.110929739415164,
   "rd_lo": -14.414835903522157,
   "rr": 0.9183442137410326,
   "se": 0.9097719429214204,
   "se_binomial": 0.9097719429214204,
   "se_clustered": 0.2544987590721242,
   "trials": 7,
   "trials_with_events": 3,
   "vaccine_affected": 4,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 6843
  },
  "id": "target_chikungunya",
  "name": "Vaccines against chikungunya"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 12,
   "comparisons_with_events": 10,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 246,
    "higher": 1.4656906376271182,
    "lower": 0.6822722164746521
   },
   "hi": 1.4476177632971046,
   "lo": 0.9291771552824506,
   "log_rr": 0.14823170987152795,
   "p": 0.19001568859928708,
   "placebo_affected": 92,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1144,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9951335160686899,
    "hi": 1.4268458793018273,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9373939021458697,
    "p": 0.17486741380402349,
    "rr": 1.1565105388882084,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 110.36893633730206,
   "rd_hi": 293.8412906169729,
   "rd_lo": -73.1034179423688,
   "rr": 1.1597815980764428,
   "se": 0.11310798240210145,
   "se_binomial": 0.11310798240210145,
   "se_clustered": 0.060671009492904854,
   "trials": 11,
   "trials_with_events": 9,
   "vaccine_affected": 154,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 2410
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 12,
   "comparisons_with_events": 5,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 42,
    "higher": 2.5234217881324654,
    "lower": 0.3962872971545832
   },
   "hi": 2.462745017468892,
   "lo": 0.7686530941645604,
   "log_rr": 0.319080532207815,
   "p": 0.28273970818843486,
   "placebo_affected": 17,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1146,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9460171096013681,
    "hi": 2.2888492699765908,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.7349414893310844,
    "p": 0.36955768220505214,
    "rr": 1.29698507752825,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 42.5644429879709,
   "rd_hi": 118.2485317440795,
   "rd_lo": -33.119645768137694,
   "rr": 1.3758621216589322,
   "se": 0.2970442601937077,
   "se_binomial": 0.2970442601937077,
   "se_clustered": 0.17053392947660834,
   "trials": 11,
   "trials_with_events": 5,
   "vaccine_affected": 25,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 2419
  },
  "id": "target_cmv",
  "name": "Vaccines against cmv"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 25,
   "comparisons_with_events": 24,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5202,
    "higher": 1.0872632300486933,
    "lower": 0.9197404753172925
   },
   "hi": 0.986139535664622,
   "lo": 0.8411151703324194,
   "log_rr": -0.09349205068332496,
   "p": 0.021227401962811625,
   "placebo_affected": 1790,
   "placebo_at_risk": 18978,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.17764780151612078,
    "hi": 0.9825356331444124,
    "i2": 0.20909858107288895,
    "lo": 0.7934907352183131,
    "p": 0.02242132481310934,
    "rr": 0.8829682451379272,
    "tau2": 0.00752054405277276
   },
   "rd": -84.00527869341454,
   "rd_hi": -22.555513157192266,
   "rd_lo": -145.45504422963683,
   "rr": 0.9107452571998833,
   "se": 0.040579639826287955,
   "se_binomial": 0.0275059999451331,
   "se_clustered": 0.040579639826287955,
   "trials": 25,
   "trials_with_events": 24,
   "vaccine_affected": 3412,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 41381
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 21,
   "comparisons_with_events": 9,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 121,
    "higher": 1.7306330738400015,
    "lower": 0.5778232342348328
   },
   "hi": 1.3047995035267164,
   "lo": 0.6187021141999975,
   "log_rr": -0.10704098372951493,
   "p": 0.5738974761860494,
   "placebo_affected": 42,
   "placebo_at_risk": 18740,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.44063072153203475,
    "hi": 1.23481956968337,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.5854003585356928,
    "p": 0.39409772580088653,
    "rr": 0.850213984135485,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -2.2884534457909314,
   "rd_hi": 5.876754272868954,
   "rd_lo": -10.453661164450818,
   "rr": 0.8984888488117627,
   "se": 0.19035572875649656,
   "se_binomial": 0.19035572875649656,
   "se_clustered": 0.16016290956087834,
   "trials": 21,
   "trials_with_events": 9,
   "vaccine_affected": 79,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 40830
  },
  "id": "target_dengue",
  "name": "Vaccines against dengue"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 13,
   "comparisons_with_events": 10,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 251,
    "higher": 1.5242262262329624,
    "lower": 0.6560705903030172
   },
   "hi": 1.3532107171363923,
   "lo": 0.7330034070090106,
   "log_rr": -0.004062425666266097,
   "p": 0.9792778863074971,
   "placebo_affected": 54,
   "placebo_at_risk": 2616,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8965252902480357,
    "hi": 1.2912768156070937,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.6988155093408326,
    "p": 0.742950067333092,
    "rr": 0.9499285581550223,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -0.8468265517364568,
   "rd_hi": 62.77816317628255,
   "rd_lo": -64.47181627975546,
   "rr": 0.9959458148223135,
   "se": 0.15640210912338226,
   "se_binomial": 0.15640210912338226,
   "se_clustered": 0.08795999703413641,
   "trials": 13,
   "trials_with_events": 10,
   "vaccine_affected": 197,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 8857
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 12,
   "comparisons_with_events": 6,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 23,
    "higher": 4.0143889869739455,
    "lower": 0.24910391176461502
   },
   "hi": 2.4374129884112605,
   "lo": 0.33804144330165076,
   "log_rr": -0.09682477575318031,
   "p": 0.8476448474892516,
   "placebo_affected": 6,
   "placebo_at_risk": 2603,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9075629482107906,
    "hi": 1.5622602699461428,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.28605908715628253,
    "p": 0.352447848686789,
    "rr": 0.6685048591605905,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -2.031338436592076,
   "rd_hi": 18.256280781572563,
   "rd_lo": -22.318957654756712,
   "rr": 0.9077150458842974,
   "se": 0.5039694616553382,
   "se_binomial": 0.5039694616553382,
   "se_clustered": 0.24338816870032698,
   "trials": 12,
   "trials_with_events": 6,
   "vaccine_affected": 17,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 8755
  },
  "id": "target_ebola",
  "name": "Vaccines against ebola"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 11,
   "comparisons_with_events": 11,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 482,
    "higher": 1.3528722323294726,
    "lower": 0.7391681018377679
   },
   "hi": 1.0782953705986318,
   "lo": 0.7573277669817984,
   "log_rr": -0.10128885205808746,
   "p": 0.26114487177599144,
   "placebo_affected": 129,
   "placebo_at_risk": 694,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8969273308215109,
    "hi": 1.0556718636680276,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.7447431917108249,
    "p": 0.17661106755733724,
    "rr": 0.8866816977627551,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -185.68526647481718,
   "rd_hi": 146.36994992721097,
   "rd_lo": -517.7404828768454,
   "rr": 0.9036719676753686,
   "se": 0.09013955649906524,
   "se_binomial": 0.09013955649906524,
   "se_clustered": 0.07813161696448116,
   "trials": 10,
   "trials_with_events": 10,
   "vaccine_affected": 353,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 2295
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 7,
   "comparisons_with_events": 2,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 2,
    "higher": 81.93070860643289,
    "lower": 0.012205435751857806
   },
   "hi": 12.558070228984974,
   "lo": 0.004358920363400582,
   "log_rr": -1.4525836851558147,
   "p": 0.47473246786238077,
   "placebo_affected": 1,
   "placebo_at_risk": 519,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.7057339922334571,
    "hi": 3.1462986550254075,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.034460278345681765,
    "p": 0.33473179897575633,
    "rr": 0.3292754582577021,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -13.817493286638681,
   "rd_hi": 22.41848966501157,
   "rd_lo": -50.05347623828893,
   "rr": 0.23396501457725946,
   "se": 2.032153238632085,
   "se_binomial": 2.032153238632085,
   "se_clustered": 2.0,
   "trials": 7,
   "trials_with_events": 2,
   "vaccine_affected": 1,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 1326
  },
  "id": "target_group_b_strep",
  "name": "Vaccines against group b strep"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 24,
   "comparisons_with_events": 19,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 755,
    "higher": 1.2271159864378371,
    "lower": 0.8149188919809234
   },
   "hi": 1.214932432810414,
   "lo": 0.9058252079618975,
   "log_rr": 0.047889772822084016,
   "p": 0.5225665267289674,
   "placebo_affected": 333,
   "placebo_at_risk": 9226,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9363450798540006,
    "hi": 1.1749355393430054,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8793392623904016,
    "p": 0.8253451293047062,
    "rr": 1.0164482035608833,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 17.667056703363876,
   "rd_hi": 70.88443704101441,
   "rd_lo": -35.550323634286656,
   "rr": 1.0490550145774755,
   "se": 0.07489866730636917,
   "se_binomial": 0.07434831363894889,
   "se_clustered": 0.07489866730636917,
   "trials": 24,
   "trials_with_events": 19,
   "vaccine_affected": 422,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 10946
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 20,
   "comparisons_with_events": 6,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 52,
    "higher": 2.181735095861512,
    "lower": 0.4583507878187775
   },
   "hi": 1.2885039188789127,
   "lo": 0.2883853629855135,
   "log_rr": -0.4949879174019389,
   "p": 0.19491024318516126,
   "placebo_affected": 31,
   "placebo_at_risk": 7497,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.44303583493155185,
    "hi": 1.2579762865329107,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.38258469288982494,
    "p": 0.22852763010208876,
    "rr": 0.6937452495303129,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -15.750794879131009,
   "rd_hi": 7.793146171005537,
   "rd_lo": -39.29473592926755,
   "rr": 0.6095782725410674,
   "se": 0.3818793150969966,
   "se_binomial": 0.29322138968003936,
   "se_clustered": 0.3818793150969966,
   "trials": 20,
   "trials_with_events": 6,
   "vaccine_affected": 21,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 8962
  },
  "id": "target_hiv",
  "name": "Vaccines against hiv"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 20,
   "comparisons_with_events": 18,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 692,
    "higher": 1.2375425800529136,
    "lower": 0.8080530044931812
   },
   "hi": 0.9849036549663942,
   "lo": 0.6989271530066336,
   "log_rr": -0.18671010650171319,
   "p": 0.032858552241989934,
   "placebo_affected": 371,
   "placebo_at_risk": 20341,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.4770398859642798,
    "hi": 0.9473956122292158,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.7042530574009315,
    "p": 0.007490798892243785,
    "rr": 0.8168269440222038,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -30.720121048883694,
   "rd_hi": 6.3930474534201664,
   "rd_lo": -67.83328955118756,
   "rr": 0.8296842215876409,
   "se": 0.08750091924692467,
   "se_binomial": 0.0749171183389127,
   "se_clustered": 0.08750091924692467,
   "trials": 20,
   "trials_with_events": 18,
   "vaccine_affected": 321,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 21789
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 5,
   "comparisons_with_events": 4,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 37,
    "higher": 2.512203876843331,
    "lower": 0.39805686521610417
   },
   "hi": 1.3350938729220048,
   "lo": 0.21982888517773833,
   "log_rr": -0.6129521118700005,
   "p": 0.18287413503766348,
   "placebo_affected": 24,
   "placebo_at_risk": 11946,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.2450138005593154,
    "hi": 1.322136838977663,
    "i2": 0.27830629546078645,
    "lo": 0.23451054416832182,
    "p": 0.18449399050001203,
    "rr": 0.5568258521060572,
    "tau2": 0.21677017757077247
   },
   "rd": -9.203611323951854,
   "rd_hi": 8.344882193503224,
   "rd_lo": -26.752104841406936,
   "rr": 0.5417492018379662,
   "se": 0.46018892084018514,
   "se_binomial": 0.34368744842508797,
   "se_clustered": 0.46018892084018514,
   "trials": 5,
   "trials_with_events": 4,
   "vaccine_affected": 13,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 11945
  },
  "id": "target_hpv",
  "name": "Vaccines against hpv"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 70,
   "comparisons_with_events": 54,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1591,
    "higher": 1.155949472124731,
    "lower": 0.8650897155235661
   },
   "hi": 1.0610982434345666,
   "lo": 0.8571422225657478,
   "log_rr": -0.04742348484538468,
   "p": 0.38381405647936606,
   "placebo_affected": 587,
   "placebo_at_risk": 36251,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8545916915976178,
    "hi": 1.0302608571263525,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8378673148367006,
    "p": 0.1631306543875275,
    "rr": 0.9290973565465649,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -7.749978774130703,
   "rd_hi": 10.865595300695507,
   "rd_lo": -26.365552848956913,
   "rr": 0.9536834415769812,
   "se": 0.05445402840159749,
   "se_binomial": 0.052455924428628786,
   "se_clustered": 0.05445402840159749,
   "trials": 69,
   "trials_with_events": 53,
   "vaccine_affected": 1004,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 59881
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 41,
   "comparisons_with_events": 10,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 81,
    "higher": 1.8693867039311696,
    "lower": 0.5349347986144763
   },
   "hi": 1.6085881806528648,
   "lo": 0.6517847685146372,
   "log_rr": 0.02365800333421431,
   "p": 0.9182373416736588,
   "placebo_affected": 36,
   "placebo_at_risk": 22944,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.4775815489933801,
    "hi": 1.4737213554759208,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.588420601882372,
    "p": 0.7609325359198662,
    "rr": 0.9312185602725315,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 0.37384505912640775,
   "rd_hi": 7.404701959307779,
   "rd_lo": -6.657011841054963,
   "rr": 1.0239400739116566,
   "se": 0.23046284754618276,
   "se_binomial": 0.23046284754618276,
   "se_clustered": 0.18448359520323515,
   "trials": 40,
   "trials_with_events": 10,
   "vaccine_affected": 45,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 27949
  },
  "id": "target_influenza",
  "name": "Vaccines against influenza"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 5,
   "comparisons_with_events": 5,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 134,
    "higher": 1.7567922377647367,
    "lower": 0.5692192727765891
   },
   "hi": 1.1899374065397377,
   "lo": 0.42096088066452586,
   "log_rr": -0.3456573317301255,
   "p": 0.19225179701067963,
   "placebo_affected": 40,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1367,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.2646658860753569,
    "hi": 1.1351687965064656,
    "i2": 0.23493043306690362,
    "lo": 0.429734752730598,
    "p": 0.14752151867973,
    "rr": 0.6984421823416714,
    "tau2": 0.0728144084283668
   },
   "rd": -82.04640487183633,
   "rd_hi": 80.76872178664436,
   "rd_lo": -244.86153153031702,
   "rr": 0.7077549707297222,
   "se": 0.265085500511091,
   "se_binomial": 0.1993486505572477,
   "se_clustered": 0.265085500511091,
   "trials": 5,
   "trials_with_events": 5,
   "vaccine_affected": 94,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 4235
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 5,
   "comparisons_with_events": 2,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5,
    "higher": 18.47774875021825,
    "lower": 0.05411914695442476
   },
   "hi": 1.6856212087129456,
   "lo": 0.032377220189477036,
   "log_rr": -1.4540830091555,
   "p": 0.14926737652457903,
   "placebo_affected": 2,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1368,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.49606516187880667,
    "hi": 1.7457532095974593,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.04381409274132911,
    "p": 0.17154582616355585,
    "rr": 0.2765657119542768,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -12.431783872871033,
   "rd_hi": 10.44952560914624,
   "rd_lo": -35.31309335488831,
   "rr": 0.2336144880578931,
   "se": 1.008292588474638,
   "se_binomial": 1.008292588474638,
   "se_clustered": 0.92354108443912,
   "trials": 5,
   "trials_with_events": 2,
   "vaccine_affected": 3,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 4235
  },
  "id": "target_lyme",
  "name": "Vaccines against lyme"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 11,
   "comparisons_with_events": 6,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 34,
    "higher": 2.7493123898805494,
    "lower": 0.3637273100287623
   },
   "hi": 1.6849508371850026,
   "lo": 0.4181700543825675,
   "log_rr": -0.1750653569447127,
   "p": 0.6224197424278918,
   "placebo_affected": 12,
   "placebo_at_risk": 564,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9971501902280655,
    "hi": 1.5258918659671241,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.3993327856487056,
    "p": 0.46889231826134026,
    "rr": 0.7806014664573421,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -35.990320496574505,
   "rd_hi": 108.42059774291741,
   "rd_lo": -180.40123873606643,
   "rr": 0.8394021582159562,
   "se": 0.3555176235780773,
   "se_binomial": 0.3555176235780773,
   "se_clustered": 0.11385831903382776,
   "trials": 9,
   "trials_with_events": 5,
   "vaccine_affected": 22,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 1075
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 11,
   "comparisons_with_events": 3,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 3,
    "higher": 30.105692362574835,
    "lower": 0.033216309658539056
   },
   "hi": 20.27592239710203,
   "lo": 0.05648117564977501,
   "log_rr": 0.06779311129504739,
   "p": 0.9639723118630121,
   "placebo_affected": 1,
   "placebo_at_risk": 564,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.5217365250639374,
    "hi": 4.893966607246763,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.12335750818262389,
    "p": 0.7881334578041622,
    "rr": 0.776986181214911,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 1.3037521775652778,
   "rd_hi": 49.68995033628806,
   "rd_lo": -47.082445981157505,
   "rr": 1.0701438848920863,
   "se": 1.500864802608597,
   "se_binomial": 1.2046488653635614,
   "se_clustered": 1.500864802608597,
   "trials": 9,
   "trials_with_events": 3,
   "vaccine_affected": 2,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 1075
  },
  "id": "target_malaria",
  "name": "Vaccines against malaria"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 12,
   "comparisons_with_events": 9,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 189,
    "higher": 1.5263429522973868,
    "lower": 0.6551607543343011
   },
   "hi": 1.546951191003554,
   "lo": 0.8443376638935776,
   "log_rr": 0.13354161583014143,
   "p": 0.3872874860730139,
   "placebo_affected": 62,
   "placebo_at_risk": 4171,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9707633861971983,
    "hi": 1.5421420758024287,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.838467052352885,
    "p": 0.4084589883054207,
    "rr": 1.1371171094515384,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 21.924974690827426,
   "rd_hi": 71.30455634161021,
   "rd_lo": -27.45460695995536,
   "rr": 1.1428688265804297,
   "se": 0.15446426797735857,
   "se_binomial": 0.15446426797735857,
   "se_clustered": 0.09258901450793729,
   "trials": 12,
   "trials_with_events": 9,
   "vaccine_affected": 127,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 7203
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 3,
   "comparisons_with_events": 0,
   "detectable": null,
   "hi": null,
   "lo": null,
   "log_rr": null,
   "p": null,
   "placebo_affected": 0,
   "placebo_at_risk": 504,
   "random_effects": {
    "hi": null,
    "i2": null,
    "lo": null,
    "p": null,
    "rr": null,
    "tau2": null
   },
   "rd": 0.0,
   "rd_hi": 0.0,
   "rd_lo": 0.0,
   "rr": null,
   "se": null,
   "trials": 3,
   "trials_with_events": 0,
   "vaccine_affected": 0,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 901
  },
  "id": "target_meningococcal",
  "name": "Vaccines against meningococcal"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 9,
   "comparisons_with_events": 6,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 415,
    "higher": 1.3166645946283628,
    "lower": 0.7594948661031297
   },
   "hi": 1.1709972374374435,
   "lo": 0.8106006714330469,
   "log_rr": -0.026062005503783243,
   "p": 0.7812149497834602,
   "placebo_affected": 209,
   "placebo_at_risk": 4285,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6631101769873383,
    "hi": 1.175584181677902,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8136807652323405,
    "p": 0.8129503954114456,
    "rr": 0.9780338626769065,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -12.45765023205588,
   "rd_hi": 75.28634304787852,
   "rd_lo": -100.20164351199028,
   "rr": 0.9742746773436303,
   "se": 0.09383730056693317,
   "se_binomial": 0.09383730056693317,
   "se_clustered": 0.05467636099008313,
   "trials": 9,
   "trials_with_events": 6,
   "vaccine_affected": 206,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 4454
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 7,
   "comparisons_with_events": 1,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 3,
    "higher": 25.41726859790808,
    "lower": 0.0393433305450572
   },
   "hi": 21.961978677981698,
   "lo": 0.18095295503748032,
   "log_rr": 0.6898972589474471,
   "p": 0.5730651863742757,
   "placebo_affected": 1,
   "placebo_at_risk": 4184,
   "random_effects": {
    "hi": null,
    "i2": null,
    "lo": null,
    "p": null,
    "rr": null,
    "tau2": null
   },
   "rd": 2.3603861768610783,
   "rd_hi": 10.403873314051165,
   "rd_lo": -5.683100960329009,
   "rr": 1.9935107073329008,
   "se": 1.2242140454457395,
   "se_binomial": 1.2242140454457395,
   "se_clustered": null,
   "trials": 7,
   "trials_with_events": 1,
   "vaccine_affected": 2,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 4321
  },
  "id": "target_norovirus",
  "name": "Vaccines against norovirus"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 12,
   "comparisons_with_events": 11,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1194,
    "higher": 1.1760444653346385,
    "lower": 0.8503079853493926
   },
   "hi": 1.1465459772236213,
   "lo": 0.9247116527659335,
   "log_rr": 0.02924030397519456,
   "p": 0.5940002080806868,
   "placebo_affected": 579,
   "placebo_at_risk": 45236,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.48758054338699197,
    "hi": 1.130944294631729,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9134183206343633,
    "p": 0.7656125599220507,
    "rr": 1.0163784916720386,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 3.8292016682890826,
   "rd_hi": 17.88956630752046,
   "rd_lo": -10.231162970942295,
   "rr": 1.0296719990223038,
   "se": 0.054854895692633826,
   "se_binomial": 0.054854895692633826,
   "se_clustered": 0.024236196850016035,
   "trials": 11,
   "trials_with_events": 10,
   "vaccine_affected": 615,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 45413
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 7,
   "comparisons_with_events": 3,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 3,
    "higher": 25.56280841267594,
    "lower": 0.03911933242452836
   },
   "hi": 24.089757839906856,
   "lo": 0.06481793191967851,
   "log_rr": 0.22280688875912788,
   "p": 0.8826723112521689,
   "placebo_affected": 1,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1397,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.4286978819269974,
    "hi": 5.757999662846769,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.1447345728495769,
    "p": 0.9227401791755983,
    "rr": 0.9128973774034708,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 2.275982296924379,
   "rd_hi": 28.740508677609174,
   "rd_lo": -24.188544083760412,
   "rr": 1.2495792426367462,
   "se": 1.5097113393457229,
   "se_binomial": 1.1219730759219226,
   "se_clustered": 1.5097113393457229,
   "trials": 6,
   "trials_with_events": 3,
   "vaccine_affected": 2,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 1580
  },
  "id": "target_pneumococcal",
  "name": "Vaccines against pneumococcal"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 27,
   "comparisons_with_events": 26,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 4354,
    "higher": 1.0887095452579747,
    "lower": 0.9185186300199522
   },
   "hi": 0.9388853717556479,
   "lo": 0.8333751335059443,
   "log_rr": -0.12266663993901464,
   "p": 5.4927036224683854e-05,
   "placebo_affected": 2134,
   "placebo_at_risk": 51708,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.4809964366887438,
    "hi": 0.9365590253668805,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8349244027994399,
    "p": 2.7097929906149846e-05,
    "rr": 0.8842827516925048,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -49.14773548503416,
   "rd_hi": -8.793309151934377,
   "rd_lo": -89.50216181813394,
   "rr": 0.8845584898883969,
   "se": 0.03041114934038994,
   "se_binomial": 0.029329560247822007,
   "se_clustered": 0.03041114934038994,
   "trials": 26,
   "trials_with_events": 25,
   "vaccine_affected": 2220,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 56293
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 5,
   "comparisons_with_events": 3,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 20,
    "higher": 3.8542158981728982,
    "lower": 0.25945614527563254
   },
   "hi": 1.82614584515892,
   "lo": 0.32163581271005237,
   "log_rr": -0.26606386978711905,
   "p": 0.5481127822781151,
   "placebo_affected": 10,
   "placebo_at_risk": 368,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8127382889143622,
    "hi": 1.6889183592233556,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.307562811093388,
    "p": 0.45100211699776527,
    "rr": 0.7207277421259485,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -51.527252339928076,
   "rd_hi": 112.87241211425092,
   "rd_lo": -215.9269167941071,
   "rr": 0.7663901767603593,
   "se": 0.443003810356095,
   "se_binomial": 0.443003810356095,
   "se_clustered": 0.21507570437921136,
   "trials": 5,
   "trials_with_events": 3,
   "vaccine_affected": 10,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 802
  },
  "id": "target_rotavirus",
  "name": "Vaccines against rotavirus"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 65,
   "comparisons_with_events": 55,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 16924,
    "higher": 1.0443705194739812,
    "lower": 0.9575145806525357
   },
   "hi": 1.047116663147366,
   "lo": 0.9808984908209342,
   "log_rr": 0.013377025910994187,
   "p": 0.42215456874191604,
   "placebo_affected": 7486,
   "placebo_at_risk": 66864,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.8204574185700794,
    "hi": 1.0415087868295432,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9851891369016993,
    "p": 0.36398189550215365,
    "rr": 1.0129576214097673,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 14.976476388769715,
   "rd_hi": 51.229152801877085,
   "rd_lo": -21.27620002433765,
   "rr": 1.013466898618156,
   "se": 0.01666526828539455,
   "se_binomial": 0.014319996070752987,
   "se_clustered": 0.01666526828539455,
   "trials": 61,
   "trials_with_events": 51,
   "vaccine_affected": 9438,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 86059
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 62,
   "comparisons_with_events": 22,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1461,
    "higher": 1.1592319190053628,
    "lower": 0.8626401530230585
   },
   "hi": 1.042682259632934,
   "lo": 0.8493913731457772,
   "log_rr": -0.06071936438499112,
   "p": 0.24569401750739595,
   "placebo_affected": 718,
   "placebo_at_risk": 66540,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9783696859461426,
    "hi": 1.033439267948609,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8421556356350528,
    "p": 0.1835066884317249,
    "rr": 0.9329076608054435,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -6.047873262755089,
   "rd_hi": 4.182779102017355,
   "rd_lo": -16.278525627527532,
   "rr": 0.9410873053358862,
   "se": 0.052304967427485506,
   "se_binomial": 0.052304967427485506,
   "se_clustered": 0.03552498655309612,
   "trials": 58,
   "trials_with_events": 21,
   "vaccine_affected": 743,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 85612
  },
  "id": "target_rsv",
  "name": "Vaccines against rsv"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 9,
   "comparisons_with_events": 6,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1446,
    "higher": 1.1588546262791262,
    "lower": 0.8629210060720214
   },
   "hi": 1.0913785298311824,
   "lo": 0.9031764596476054,
   "log_rr": -0.007197863161568754,
   "p": 0.8815013378437235,
   "placebo_affected": 710,
   "placebo_at_risk": 5932,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.907967100812567,
    "hi": 1.0854421573244257,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8990278204605681,
    "p": 0.7992174973233312,
    "rr": 0.9878475069237131,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -8.5318565117418,
   "rd_hi": 103.69099057024184,
   "rd_lo": -120.75470359372544,
   "rr": 0.9928279794145287,
   "se": 0.04828632903586113,
   "se_binomial": 0.04828632903586113,
   "se_clustered": 0.04092680444672328,
   "trials": 9,
   "trials_with_events": 6,
   "vaccine_affected": 736,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 6340
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 2,
   "comparisons_with_events": 1,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 23,
    "higher": 3.2167934032378755,
    "lower": 0.31086858080268576
   },
   "hi": 2.9583218458973666,
   "lo": 0.5719389539623664,
   "log_rr": 0.2629495732345669,
   "p": 0.5305132679653832,
   "placebo_affected": 10,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1806,
   "random_effects": {
    "hi": null,
    "i2": null,
    "lo": null,
    "p": null,
    "rr": null,
    "tau2": null
   },
   "rd": 16.534209817195414,
   "rd_hi": 68.04825324470951,
   "rd_lo": -34.97983361031868,
   "rr": 1.30076112412178,
   "se": 0.4192284094882954,
   "se_binomial": 0.4192284094882954,
   "se_clustered": null,
   "trials": 2,
   "trials_with_events": 1,
   "vaccine_affected": 13,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 1835
  },
  "id": "target_s_aureus",
  "name": "Vaccines against s aureus"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 19,
   "comparisons_with_events": 8,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 18,
    "higher": 4.100600232680027,
    "lower": 0.24386673736942907
   },
   "hi": 2.1254764758452764,
   "lo": 0.24910519586151994,
   "log_rr": -0.31794199861279254,
   "p": 0.5610148253918958,
   "placebo_affected": 7,
   "placebo_at_risk": 719,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.7155475516388548,
    "hi": 1.6033913297145137,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.23425450889306948,
    "p": 0.31837344030408676,
    "rr": 0.6128634827640483,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -26.69602959305378,
   "rd_hi": 68.8700291338561,
   "rd_lo": -122.26208831996367,
   "rr": 0.7276449916095696,
   "se": 0.5469171881636263,
   "se_binomial": 0.49329057046407776,
   "se_clustered": 0.5469171881636263,
   "trials": 19,
   "trials_with_events": 8,
   "vaccine_affected": 11,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 1501
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 15,
   "comparisons_with_events": 1,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 1,
    "higher": 392.23495084486314,
    "lower": 0.0025494923332202496
   },
   "hi": null,
   "lo": null,
   "log_rr": null,
   "p": null,
   "placebo_affected": 1,
   "placebo_at_risk": 468,
   "random_effects": {
    "hi": null,
    "i2": null,
    "lo": null,
    "p": null,
    "rr": null,
    "tau2": null
   },
   "rd": -24.80634494813666,
   "rd_hi": 28.842760664715602,
   "rd_lo": -78.45545056098892,
   "rr": null,
   "se": null,
   "trials": 15,
   "trials_with_events": 1,
   "vaccine_affected": 0,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 963
  },
  "id": "target_shigella_etec",
  "name": "Vaccines against shigella etec"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 5,
   "comparisons_with_events": 3,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 5,
    "higher": 12.346796070883606,
    "lower": 0.08099267164201525
   },
   "hi": 19.392629577342735,
   "lo": 0.05418197088265888,
   "log_rr": 0.024743004386597923,
   "p": 0.9868401360944117,
   "placebo_affected": 2,
   "placebo_at_risk": 226,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.41809938202006336,
    "hi": 5.940230148749431,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.17476734102619332,
    "p": 0.9833926752285502,
    "rr": 1.0189004996468336,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 2.124138785881781,
   "rd_hi": 233.0298537212318,
   "rd_lo": -228.78157614946824,
   "rr": 1.0250516528925622,
   "se": 1.5001041196683307,
   "se_binomial": 1.0517411506713563,
   "se_clustered": 1.5001041196683307,
   "trials": 5,
   "trials_with_events": 3,
   "vaccine_affected": 3,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 264
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 5,
   "comparisons_with_events": 0,
   "detectable": null,
   "hi": null,
   "lo": null,
   "log_rr": null,
   "p": null,
   "placebo_affected": 0,
   "placebo_at_risk": 226,
   "random_effects": {
    "hi": null,
    "i2": null,
    "lo": null,
    "p": null,
    "rr": null,
    "tau2": null
   },
   "rd": 0.0,
   "rd_hi": 0.0,
   "rd_lo": 0.0,
   "rr": null,
   "se": null,
   "trials": 5,
   "trials_with_events": 0,
   "vaccine_affected": 0,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 264
  },
  "id": "target_tetanus_diphtheria_pertussis",
  "name": "Vaccines against tetanus diphtheria pertussis"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 15,
   "comparisons_with_events": 14,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 398,
    "higher": 1.3249452926993464,
    "lower": 0.7547481435725344
   },
   "hi": 1.279903637590281,
   "lo": 0.864665528431977,
   "log_rr": 0.05068613640238003,
   "p": 0.6124375706642354,
   "placebo_affected": 172,
   "placebo_at_risk": 4741,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6492412667668657,
    "hi": 1.2671499097322598,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.8772877880158585,
    "p": 0.5725970978832463,
    "rr": 1.054350578030623,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": 19.796710577314553,
   "rd_hi": 106.72337019666682,
   "rd_lo": -67.12994904203771,
   "rr": 1.0519926592609903,
   "se": 0.10005217216369057,
   "se_binomial": 0.09424180856485473,
   "se_clustered": 0.10005217216369057,
   "trials": 15,
   "trials_with_events": 14,
   "vaccine_affected": 226,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 5347
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 10,
   "comparisons_with_events": 7,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 61,
    "higher": 2.055256349206166,
    "lower": 0.4865573096933848
   },
   "hi": 0.9381264689687389,
   "lo": 0.3330891228113059,
   "log_rr": -0.581607849739701,
   "p": 0.02768266400740127,
   "placebo_affected": 38,
   "placebo_at_risk": 4179,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.7920366603467005,
    "hi": 0.9407699520769086,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.34088278853541915,
    "p": 0.028111455417380523,
    "rr": 0.5662969933120864,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -39.14565492912676,
   "rd_hi": -4.3351909076620165,
   "rd_lo": -73.9561189505915,
   "rr": 0.5589988574539889,
   "se": 0.264156555426604,
   "se_binomial": 0.264156555426604,
   "se_clustered": 0.19630234345056935,
   "trials": 10,
   "trials_with_events": 7,
   "vaccine_affected": 23,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 5015
  },
  "id": "target_tuberculosis",
  "name": "Vaccines against tuberculosis"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 8,
   "comparisons_with_events": 8,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 75,
    "higher": 1.9367927518678865,
    "lower": 0.5163175043047726
   },
   "hi": 1.389525843646867,
   "lo": 0.5420236613530973,
   "log_rr": -0.141741526796407,
   "p": 0.5550583774793952,
   "placebo_affected": 29,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1511,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.6020686440008305,
    "hi": 1.335769330539393,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.5166872952566031,
    "p": 0.44417230347778214,
    "rr": 0.8307677428036806,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -27.421052337615386,
   "rd_hi": 66.50614198820924,
   "rd_lo": -121.34824666344,
   "rr": 0.8678455423162732,
   "se": 0.24015956214805084,
   "se_binomial": 0.24015956214805084,
   "se_clustered": 0.160499891362185,
   "trials": 8,
   "trials_with_events": 8,
   "vaccine_affected": 46,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 2290
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 8,
   "comparisons_with_events": 4,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 4,
    "higher": 17.504928892897077,
    "lower": 0.05712676733041556
   },
   "hi": 16.196842295861607,
   "lo": 0.08087975012983983,
   "log_rr": 0.13501225478102824,
   "p": 0.9204525587045111,
   "placebo_affected": 1,
   "placebo_at_risk": 1513,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.28087646257238164,
    "hi": 3.6922032473719457,
    "i2": 0.21589106052187684,
    "lo": 0.10232574076842262,
    "p": 0.5947034768514341,
    "rr": 0.6146604203581925,
    "tau2": 0.7226447440809626
   },
   "rd": 1.5169406035516328,
   "rd_hi": 27.26818735264572,
   "rd_lo": -24.234306145542458,
   "rr": 1.144550810484929,
   "se": 1.3519656730681755,
   "se_binomial": 0.8998593692635976,
   "se_clustered": 1.3519656730681755,
   "trials": 8,
   "trials_with_events": 4,
   "vaccine_affected": 3,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 2294
  },
  "id": "target_zika",
  "name": "Vaccines against zika"
 },
 {
  "any_serious": {
   "comparisons": 24,
   "comparisons_with_events": 23,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 9797,
    "higher": 1.058249762254022,
    "lower": 0.9449565080648327
   },
   "hi": 1.0269248508652942,
   "lo": 0.9600169549773849,
   "log_rr": -0.007117789211920871,
   "p": 0.6787788567573168,
   "placebo_affected": 4831,
   "placebo_at_risk": 41158,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.618651682894684,
    "hi": 1.019331147832854,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9561443579912049,
    "p": 0.43120907823234234,
    "rr": 0.9872323566035921,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -8.352434310464103,
   "rd_hi": 32.56155914473396,
   "rd_lo": -49.26642776566217,
   "rr": 0.9929074822551721,
   "se": 0.017187327945574274,
   "se_binomial": 0.017187327945574274,
   "se_clustered": 0.016708463346397053,
   "trials": 24,
   "trials_with_events": 23,
   "vaccine_affected": 4966,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 42458
  },
  "death": {
   "comparisons": 20,
   "comparisons_with_events": 17,
   "detectable": {
    "events": 2836,
    "higher": 1.1109851708924112,
    "lower": 0.900102023141082
   },
   "hi": 1.0503990329132875,
   "lo": 0.9174496178984917,
   "log_rr": -0.01849374480578461,
   "p": 0.5921706039877469,
   "placebo_affected": 1414,
   "placebo_at_risk": 23914,
   "random_effects": {
    "heterogeneity_p": 0.9262221256318852,
    "hi": 1.0494724861386557,
    "i2": 0.0,
    "lo": 0.9172027802480637,
    "p": 0.5789722865283873,
    "rr": 0.981111146649666,
    "tau2": 0.0
   },
   "rd": -10.79629761902232,
   "rd_hi": 28.637753395160775,
   "rd_lo": -50.23034863320541,
   "rr": 0.9816762151479687,
   "se": 0.03452301579395475,
   "se_binomial": 0.03452301579395475,
   "se_clustered": 0.02415088773506675,
   "trials": 20,
   "trials_with_events": 17,
   "vaccine_affected": 1422,
   "vaccine_at_risk": 25101
  },
  "id": "target_zoster",
  "name": "Vaccines against zoster"
 }
]
