[
 {
  "trial": "T05",
  "groups": [
   {
    "comparison": "T05-1",
    "wave": "12 months (August 2022, end of payments)",
    "class": "employed_any",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T05-1",
      "wave": "12 months (August 2022, end of payments)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Employed (the sentence does not say which employment categories count)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Compared to the control group, fathers in the treatment group were significantly more likely to be employed as the payments were ending and 6 months after the program ended.",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Findings, '3. Employment and Pathways to Earning', 'Obstacles to employment' paragraph, p. 30: sentence only, no numbers ('as the payments were ending' is the 12-month survey); Table 2 (p. 30) prints only mutually exclusive employment categories with no test, so no any-employment share is printed; Methods (pp. 16-17) say effects are regression-adjusted mean differences 'adjusting for potential confounding variables'",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Columbia-SC"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders found only the p. 30 sentence; one sentence-only entry is kept with the sentence copied whole and kind adjusted_difference, since the methods describe regression-adjusted mean differences."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T05-1",
    "wave": "18 months (February 2023, 6 months after payments ended)",
    "class": "employed_any",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T05-1",
      "wave": "18 months (February 2023, 6 months after payments ended)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Employed (the sentence does not say which employment categories count)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Compared to the control group, fathers in the treatment group were significantly more likely to be employed as the payments were ending and 6 months after the program ended.",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Findings, '3. Employment and Pathways to Earning', 'Obstacles to employment' paragraph, p. 30: sentence only, no numbers ('6 months after the program ended' is the 18-month survey); Table 2 (p. 30) prints only mutually exclusive employment categories with no test, so no any-employment share is printed; Methods (pp. 16-17) say effects are regression-adjusted mean differences 'adjusting for potential confounding variables'",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Columbia-SC"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders found only the p. 30 sentence; one sentence-only entry is kept with the sentence copied whole and kind adjusted_difference, since the methods describe regression-adjusted mean differences."
   }
  ],
  "attrition": []
 },
 {
  "trial": "T11",
  "groups": [
   {
    "comparison": "T11-1",
    "wave": "12 months (August 2023, when payments ended)",
    "class": "employed_full_time",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T11-1",
      "wave": "12 months (August 2023, when payments ended)",
      "class": "employed_full_time",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Employed FT",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": null,
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 37
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 33
      },
      "proportion_unit": "percent",
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 8 'Employment Trends over Time, Treatment vs. Control (in %)', row 'Employed FT', 12 MONTHS columns (p. 45): arms' shares only, no effect or test printed; the text (pp. 4 and 44) says the treatment group's higher full-time shares after baseline were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Madison-WI"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Table 8 prints only the arms' shares (37% vs 33%), so the codebook's form is estimate null with the shares filled (coder 1); the text's 'not statistically significant' is noted in where."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T11-1",
    "wave": "18 months (February 2024, 6 months after payments ended)",
    "class": "employed_full_time",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T11-1",
      "wave": "18 months (February 2024, 6 months after payments ended)",
      "class": "employed_full_time",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Employed FT",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": null,
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 40
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 37
      },
      "proportion_unit": "percent",
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 8 'Employment Trends over Time, Treatment vs. Control (in %)', row 'Employed FT', 18 MONTHS columns (p. 45): arms' shares only, no effect or test printed; the text (pp. 4 and 44) says the treatment group's higher full-time shares after baseline were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Madison-WI"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Table 8 prints only the arms' shares (40% vs 37%), so the codebook's form is estimate null with the shares filled (coder 1); the text's 'not statistically significant' is noted in where."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T11-1",
    "wave": "6 months (February 2023)",
    "class": "employed_full_time",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T11-1",
      "wave": "6 months (February 2023)",
      "class": "employed_full_time",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Employed FT",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": null,
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 34
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 33
      },
      "proportion_unit": "percent",
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 8 'Employment Trends over Time, Treatment vs. Control (in %)', row 'Employed FT', 6 MONTHS columns (p. 45): arms' shares only, no effect or test printed; the text (pp. 4 and 44) says the treatment group's higher full-time shares after baseline were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Madison-WI"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Table 8 prints only the arms' shares (34% vs 33%), so the codebook's form is estimate null with the shares filled (coder 1); the text's 'not statistically significant' is noted in where."
   }
  ],
  "attrition": [
   {
    "comparison": "T11-1",
    "wave": "12 months (August 2023, when payments ended)",
    "row": {
     "comparison": "T11-1",
     "wave": "12 months (August 2023, when payments ended)",
     "randomized_treated": 146,
     "randomized_control": 171,
     "responded_treated": 120,
     "responded_control": 94,
     "where": "Randomized: Quantitative Methodology, p. 14 ('The final allocation randomly designated 146 individuals to receive the monthly GI ... with 171 individuals serving as the control group'; two control members later withdrew, leaving 169, the Baseline row of Table 9). Responded: Appendix A Table 9 'Sample Attrition', 12 months row (p. 72), whose attrition rates are computed on 146 and 169. The program description (p. 13) gives 155 and 200 randomly assigned from the applicants before the research sample was formed.",
     "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Madison-WI"
    },
    "why": "Table 9 counts respondents within the research sample randomized as 146 and 171 (169 after two withdrawals), the base of its own attrition rates, so those are the randomized counts (coder 1), not the 155 and 200 first selected."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T11-1",
    "wave": "18 months (February 2024, 6 months after payments ended)",
    "row": {
     "comparison": "T11-1",
     "wave": "18 months (February 2024, 6 months after payments ended)",
     "randomized_treated": 146,
     "randomized_control": 171,
     "responded_treated": 118,
     "responded_control": 100,
     "where": "Randomized: Quantitative Methodology, p. 14 ('The final allocation randomly designated 146 individuals to receive the monthly GI ... with 171 individuals serving as the control group'; two control members later withdrew, leaving 169, the Baseline row of Table 9). Responded: Appendix A Table 9 'Sample Attrition', 18 months row (p. 72), whose attrition rates are computed on 146 and 169. The program description (p. 13) gives 155 and 200 randomly assigned from the applicants before the research sample was formed.",
     "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Madison-WI"
    },
    "why": "Table 9 counts respondents within the research sample randomized as 146 and 171 (169 after two withdrawals), the base of its own attrition rates, so those are the randomized counts (coder 1), not the 155 and 200 first selected."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T11-1",
    "wave": "6 months (February 2023)",
    "row": {
     "comparison": "T11-1",
     "wave": "6 months (February 2023)",
     "randomized_treated": 146,
     "randomized_control": 171,
     "responded_treated": 109,
     "responded_control": 91,
     "where": "Randomized: Quantitative Methodology, p. 14 ('The final allocation randomly designated 146 individuals to receive the monthly GI ... with 171 individuals serving as the control group'; two control members later withdrew, leaving 169, the Baseline row of Table 9). Responded: Appendix A Table 9 'Sample Attrition', 6 months row (p. 72), whose attrition rates are computed on 146 and 169. The program description (p. 13) gives 155 and 200 randomly assigned from the applicants before the research sample was formed.",
     "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Madison-WI"
    },
    "why": "Table 9 counts respondents within the research sample randomized as 146 and 171 (169 after two withdrawals), the base of its own attrition rates, so those are the randomized counts (coder 1), not the 155 and 200 first selected."
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "trial": "T13",
  "groups": [
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
    "class": "depression",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
      "class": "depression",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "K-10 distress component: feeling depressed (part of the 10-item Kessler scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.69,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.04,
       "p_text": "p=0.04",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 132,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 231,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (recurring payments), text p. 35: 'Looking at distress components measured by the K-10 scale, recurring recipients reported feeling less depressed at 6 months (B=-0.68, p=0.04) and 12 months (B=-0.69, p=0.04), and less anxious at 6 months (B=-0.42, p=0.03) and 18 months (B=-0.54, p=0.02)'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates); n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The text prints this K-10 component's B, a depressive-symptom result the codebook asks for, so coder 2's entry is kept as an unadjusted difference."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.11,
       "se": 0.53,
       "lower": -2.12,
       "upper": 0.17,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 132,
       "mean": 20.16,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 231,
       "mean": 21.27,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 12 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the estimate is printed in brackets, [-1.11], without an asterisk (the table does not say what brackets mean)",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.99,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.06,
       "p_text": "p=0.06",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 132,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 231,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (recurring payments), text p. 35: 'Six months after payments started, the recurring recipients showed significant improvement (B=-1.10, p=0.03), with their average scores dropping below 20 (M=19.55) ... while the control group remained higher (M=20.77). Although the recurring payment group maintained lower distress levels at 12 months (B=-0.99, p=0.06) and 18 months (B=-1.08, p=0.04) compared to the control group'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates), which differs from Table 10's -1.11; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Table 10's difference and the text's B are printed with different numbers, so both stay; the model has only treatment, time and their interaction with random intercepts, so both are unadjusted differences (coder 2's kind), with the Table 10 CI and SE as printed."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.05,
       "se": 0.23,
       "lower": -0.24,
       "upper": 0.64,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 132,
       "mean": 6.99,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 231,
       "mean": 7.04,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 12 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 35) says stress differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
    "class": "anxiety",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
      "class": "anxiety",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "K-10 distress component: feeling anxious (part of the 10-item Kessler scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.54,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.02,
       "p_text": "p=0.02",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 157,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 241,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (recurring payments), text p. 35: 'Looking at distress components measured by the K-10 scale, recurring recipients reported feeling less depressed at 6 months (B=-0.68, p=0.04) and 12 months (B=-0.69, p=0.04), and less anxious at 6 months (B=-0.42, p=0.03) and 18 months (B=-0.54, p=0.02)'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates); n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The text prints this K-10 component's B, an anxiety-symptom result the codebook asks for, so coder 2's entry is kept as an unadjusted difference."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.2,
       "se": 0.53,
       "lower": -2.12,
       "upper": -0.02,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "p<0.05",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 157,
       "mean": 20.32,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 241,
       "mean": 21.52,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 18 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; printed [-1.20]* (* p<0.05)",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.08,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.04,
       "p_text": "p=0.04",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 157,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 241,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (recurring payments), text p. 35: 'Six months after payments started, the recurring recipients showed significant improvement (B=-1.10, p=0.03), with their average scores dropping below 20 (M=19.55) ... while the control group remained higher (M=20.77). Although the recurring payment group maintained lower distress levels at 12 months (B=-0.99, p=0.06) and 18 months (B=-1.08, p=0.04) compared to the control group'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates), which differs from Table 10's -1.20; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Table 10's difference and the text's B are printed with different numbers, so both stay; the model has only treatment, time and their interaction with random intercepts, so both are unadjusted differences (coder 2's kind), with the Table 10 CI and SE as printed."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.17,
       "se": 0.2,
       "lower": -0.32,
       "upper": 0.47,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 157,
       "mean": 6.94,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 241,
       "mean": 7.11,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 18 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 35) says stress differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.92,
       "se": 0.56,
       "lower": -1.92,
       "upper": 0.34,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 20.15,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 261,
       "mean": 21.07,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 24 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 35) says that by 24 months the differences between groups were no longer significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.41,
       "se": 0.22,
       "lower": -0.59,
       "upper": 0.26,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 6.81,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 261,
       "mean": 7.22,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 24 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 35) says stress differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.36,
       "se": 0.63,
       "lower": -1.47,
       "upper": 1.11,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 20.71,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 281,
       "mean": 21.07,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 30 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.02,
       "se": 0.23,
       "lower": -0.24,
       "upper": 0.66,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 7.15,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 281,
       "mean": 7.17,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 30 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
    "class": "anxiety",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
      "class": "anxiety",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "K-10 distress component: feeling anxious (part of the 10-item Kessler scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.42,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.03,
       "p_text": "p=0.03",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 142,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 230,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (recurring payments), text p. 35: 'Looking at distress components measured by the K-10 scale, recurring recipients reported feeling less depressed at 6 months (B=-0.68, p=0.04) and 12 months (B=-0.69, p=0.04), and less anxious at 6 months (B=-0.42, p=0.03) and 18 months (B=-0.54, p=0.02)'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates); n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The text prints this K-10 component's B, an anxiety-symptom result the codebook asks for, so coder 2's entry is kept as an unadjusted difference."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
    "class": "depression",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
      "class": "depression",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "K-10 distress component: feeling depressed (part of the 10-item Kessler scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.68,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.04,
       "p_text": "p=0.04",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 142,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 230,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (recurring payments), text p. 35: 'Looking at distress components measured by the K-10 scale, recurring recipients reported feeling less depressed at 6 months (B=-0.68, p=0.04) and 12 months (B=-0.69, p=0.04), and less anxious at 6 months (B=-0.42, p=0.03) and 18 months (B=-0.54, p=0.02)'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates); n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The text prints this K-10 component's B, a depressive-symptom result the codebook asks for, so coder 2's entry is kept as an unadjusted difference."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.22,
       "se": 0.52,
       "lower": -2.13,
       "upper": -0.16,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "p<0.05",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 142,
       "mean": 19.55,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 230,
       "mean": 20.77,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 6 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; printed [-1.22]* (* p<0.05)",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.1,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.03,
       "p_text": "p=0.03",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 142,
       "mean": 19.55,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 230,
       "mean": 20.77,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (recurring payments), text p. 35: 'Six months after payments started, the recurring recipients showed significant improvement (B=-1.10, p=0.03), with their average scores dropping below 20 (M=19.55) ... while the control group remained higher (M=20.77). Although the recurring payment group maintained lower distress levels at 12 months (B=-0.99, p=0.06) and 18 months (B=-1.08, p=0.04) compared to the control group'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates), which differs from Table 10's -1.22; the text also prints the arms' means M=19.55 and M=20.77; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Table 10's difference and the text's B are printed with different numbers, so both stay; the model has only treatment, time and their interaction with random intercepts, so both are unadjusted differences (coder 2's kind), with the Table 10 CI and SE as printed."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-1",
    "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-1",
      "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.31,
       "se": 0.21,
       "lower": -0.48,
       "upper": 0.35,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 142,
       "mean": 6.89,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 230,
       "mean": 7.2,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 6 months row, Recurring Monthly Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 35) says stress differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.58,
       "se": 0.6,
       "lower": -1.61,
       "upper": 0.77,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 147,
       "mean": 21.85,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 231,
       "mean": 21.27,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 12 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 50) says that at all time points the lump-sum group's distress was slightly higher but the differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Participants Likely Mentally Well (share in the K-10 'likely to be well' range, which the text on p. 35 places below 20)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": null,
      "treated": {
       "n": 147,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 48
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 231,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 48
      },
      "proportion_unit": "percent",
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Figure 10 'Participants Likely Mentally Well, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control' (p. 51), 12 MONTHS pair of data labels: lump-sum 48%, control 48%; within each pair the left bar is Control and the right Lump-sum, the legend's order and the order of the report's other paired-bar figures where the text names the values (Figure 8 and the text after it: lump-sum 30% vs control 23% at 12 months); no asterisk marks any wave; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Figure 10 prints both arms' shares likely mentally well at this wave, and the report's other paired-bar figures, checked against its text, put Control left and Lump-sum right, so coder 2's entry is kept."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.38,
       "se": 0.21,
       "lower": 0.1,
       "upper": 0.91,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "p<0.05",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 147,
       "mean": 7.42,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 231,
       "mean": 7.04,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 12 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; printed [0.38]* (* p<0.05)",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "12 months (October 2022)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.49,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.02,
       "p_text": "p=0.02",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 147,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 231,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (lump-sum payments), text p. 50: 'the lump-sum group reported significantly higher stress compared to the control group at both the end of the first year (B=0.49, p=0.02) and 6 months after payments ended (B=0.54, p=0.01)'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates) ('the end of the first year' is the 12-month survey), which differs from Table 10's 0.38; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Table 10's difference and the text's B for lump-sum stress are printed with different numbers, so both stay, as unadjusted differences since the mixed-effects model names no covariates."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.73,
       "se": 0.53,
       "lower": -1.01,
       "upper": 1.04,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 22.25,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 241,
       "mean": 21.52,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 18 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 50) says that at all time points the lump-sum group's distress was slightly higher but the differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Participants Likely Mentally Well (share in the K-10 'likely to be well' range, which the text on p. 35 places below 20)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": null,
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 48
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 241,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 49
      },
      "proportion_unit": "percent",
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Figure 10 'Participants Likely Mentally Well, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control' (p. 51), 18 MONTHS pair of data labels: lump-sum 48%, control 49%; within each pair the left bar is Control and the right Lump-sum, the legend's order and the order of the report's other paired-bar figures where the text names the values (Figure 8 and the text after it: lump-sum 30% vs control 23% at 12 months); no asterisk marks any wave; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Figure 10 prints both arms' shares likely mentally well at this wave, and the report's other paired-bar figures, checked against its text, put Control left and Lump-sum right, so coder 2's entry is kept."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "18 months (April 2023)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.22,
       "se": 0.22,
       "lower": -0.08,
       "upper": 0.75,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 7.33,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 241,
       "mean": 7.11,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 18 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.71,
       "se": 0.53,
       "lower": -1.04,
       "upper": 0.93,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 166,
       "mean": 21.78,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 261,
       "mean": 21.07,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 24 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 50) says that at all time points the lump-sum group's distress was slightly higher but the differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Participants Likely Mentally Well (share in the K-10 'likely to be well' range, which the text on p. 35 places below 20)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": null,
      "treated": {
       "n": 166,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 48
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 261,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 49
      },
      "proportion_unit": "percent",
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Figure 10 'Participants Likely Mentally Well, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control' (p. 51), 24 MONTHS pair of data labels: lump-sum 48%, control 49%; within each pair the left bar is Control and the right Lump-sum, the legend's order and the order of the report's other paired-bar figures where the text names the values (Figure 8 and the text after it: lump-sum 30% vs control 23% at 12 months); no asterisk marks any wave; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Figure 10 prints both arms' shares likely mentally well at this wave, and the report's other paired-bar figures, checked against its text, put Control left and Lump-sum right, so coder 2's entry is kept."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "24 months (October 2023, time of the last payment)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.19,
       "se": 0.21,
       "lower": -0.12,
       "upper": 0.72,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 166,
       "mean": 7.41,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 261,
       "mean": 7.22,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 24 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 1.2,
       "se": 0.67,
       "lower": -0.71,
       "upper": 1.83,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 163,
       "mean": 22.27,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 281,
       "mean": 21.07,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 30 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 50) says that at all time points the lump-sum group's distress was slightly higher but the differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Participants Likely Mentally Well (share in the K-10 'likely to be well' range, which the text on p. 35 places below 20)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": null,
      "treated": {
       "n": 163,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 52
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 281,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 49
      },
      "proportion_unit": "percent",
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Figure 10 'Participants Likely Mentally Well, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control' (p. 51), 30 MONTHS pair of data labels: lump-sum 52%, control 49%; within each pair the left bar is Control and the right Lump-sum, the legend's order and the order of the report's other paired-bar figures where the text names the values (Figure 8 and the text after it: lump-sum 30% vs control 23% at 12 months); no asterisk marks any wave; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Figure 10 prints both arms' shares likely mentally well at this wave, and the report's other paired-bar figures, checked against its text, put Control left and Lump-sum right, so coder 2's entry is kept."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.42,
       "se": 0.22,
       "lower": 0.14,
       "upper": 0.96,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "p<0.05",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 163,
       "mean": 7.59,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 281,
       "mean": 7.17,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 30 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; printed [0.42]* (* p<0.05)",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "30 months (April 2024, 6 months after the last payment)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.54,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": 0.01,
       "p_text": "p=0.01",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 163,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 281,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Findings, 'Impacts on Mental Well-Being, Stress, and the Household Environment' (lump-sum payments), text p. 50: 'the lump-sum group reported significantly higher stress compared to the control group at both the end of the first year (B=0.49, p=0.02) and 6 months after payments ended (B=0.54, p=0.01)'; a B coefficient from the same mixed-effects model (no covariates) ('6 months after payments ended' is the 30-month survey), which differs from Table 10's 0.42; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Table 10's difference and the text's B for lump-sum stress are printed with different numbers, so both stay, as unadjusted differences since the mixed-effects model names no covariates."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress (10-item Kessler scale, K-10)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.63,
       "se": 0.51,
       "lower": -1.1,
       "upper": 0.84,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 151,
       "mean": 21.4,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 230,
       "mean": 20.77,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Kessler Psychological Distress, 6 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9; the text (p. 50) says that at all time points the lump-sum group's distress was slightly higher but the differences were not statistically significant",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Participants Likely Mentally Well (share in the K-10 'likely to be well' range, which the text on p. 35 places below 20)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": null,
      "treated": {
       "n": 151,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 49
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 230,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": 49
      },
      "proportion_unit": "percent",
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Figure 10 'Participants Likely Mentally Well, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control' (p. 51), 6 MONTHS pair of data labels: lump-sum 49%, control 49%; within each pair the left bar is Control and the right Lump-sum, the legend's order and the order of the report's other paired-bar figures where the text names the values (Figure 8 and the text after it: lump-sum 30% vs control 23% at 12 months); no asterisk marks any wave; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Figure 10 prints both arms' shares likely mentally well at this wave, and the report's other paired-bar figures, checked against its text, put Control left and Lump-sum right, so coder 2's entry is kept."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T13-2",
    "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T13-2",
      "wave": "6 months (April 2022)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "PSS-4",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress (four-item Perceived Stress Scale)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.02,
       "se": 0.21,
       "lower": -0.3,
       "upper": 0.56,
       "level": 95,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 151,
       "mean": 7.22,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 230,
       "mean": 7.2,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Appendix Table 10 'Comparative Analysis', Perceived Stress, 6 months row, Lump-Sum Payment vs. Control columns: arm means (footnote: 'Adjusted average score'), mean difference, bootstrapped standard error and 95% CI as printed; the methods (p. 22) name a linear mixed-effects model with fixed effects for treatment, time and their interaction and random intercepts, no covariates, fitted after multiple imputation, with bootstrapped SEs; n = respondents at this wave in Appendix Table 9",
      "source": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 10 numbers; the model names no covariates, so the estimate is an unadjusted difference (coder 2) despite the footnote's 'adjusted average score', and p_text holds only the table's own significance mark."
   }
  ],
  "attrition": []
 },
 {
  "trial": "T29",
  "groups": [
   {
    "comparison": "T29-1",
    "wave": "12-month survey",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: within-stratum unadjusted mean difference",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -3.96,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 155,
       "mean": 20.96,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 126,
       "mean": 24.64,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 12, column 'Within-stratum mean difference' (no SE printed); control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 1 (X): controls for baseline income, education, and age, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -3.94,
       "se": 1.24,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.02]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 155,
       "mean": 20.96,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 126,
       "mean": 24.64,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 12, column 'Model 1 (X)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 2 (LDV): controls for the baseline outcome, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -3.78,
       "se": 0.88,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 155,
       "mean": 20.96,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 126,
       "mean": 24.64,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 12, column 'Model 2 (LDV)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 3 (DiD): within-stratum difference in change from baseline",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -3.76,
       "se": 1.13,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 155,
       "mean": 20.96,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 126,
       "mean": 24.64,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 12, column 'Model 3 (DiD)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The four Table 6 estimates match in both coders and stay; coder 1's Figure 3 arm means are dropped because Figure 3 shows only respondents to the 24-month survey while Table 6 prints the whole sample at this wave (at 24 months the figure repeats Table 6's means to more digits)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T29-1",
    "wave": "12-month survey",
    "class": "life_satisfaction",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: within-stratum unadjusted mean difference",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.3,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 155,
       "mean": 0.28,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 126,
       "mean": 0.01,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 12, column 'Within-stratum mean difference' (no SE printed); control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 1 (X): controls for baseline income, education, and age, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.33,
       "se": 0.11,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.02]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 155,
       "mean": 0.28,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 126,
       "mean": 0.01,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 12, column 'Model 1 (X)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 2 (LDV): controls for the baseline outcome, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.3,
       "se": 0.07,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 155,
       "mean": 0.28,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 126,
       "mean": 0.01,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 12, column 'Model 2 (LDV)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 3 (DiD): within-stratum difference in change from baseline",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.31,
       "se": 0.07,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 155,
       "mean": 0.28,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 126,
       "mean": 0.01,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 12, column 'Model 3 (DiD)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The four Table 6 estimates match in both coders and stay; coder 1's Figure 3 arm means are dropped because Figure 3 shows only respondents to the 24-month survey while Table 6 prints the whole sample at this wave (at 24 months the figure repeats Table 6's means to more digits)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T29-1",
    "wave": "18-month survey",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "18-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: within-stratum unadjusted mean difference",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -4,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 20.58,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 125,
       "mean": 24.4,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 18, column 'Within-stratum mean difference' (no SE printed); control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "18-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 1 (X): controls for baseline income, education, and age, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -4.9,
       "se": 1.2,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 20.58,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 125,
       "mean": 24.4,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 18, column 'Model 1 (X)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "18-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 2 (LDV): controls for the baseline outcome, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -3.28,
       "se": 0.89,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 20.58,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 125,
       "mean": 24.4,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 18, column 'Model 2 (LDV)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "18-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 3 (DiD): within-stratum difference in change from baseline",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -3.22,
       "se": 1.13,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.02]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 20.58,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 125,
       "mean": 24.4,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 18, column 'Model 3 (DiD)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The four Table 6 estimates match in both coders and stay; coder 1's Figure 3 arm means are dropped because Figure 3 shows only respondents to the 24-month survey while Table 6 prints the whole sample at this wave (at 24 months the figure repeats Table 6's means to more digits)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T29-1",
    "wave": "18-month survey",
    "class": "life_satisfaction",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "18-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: within-stratum unadjusted mean difference",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.34,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 0.28,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 125,
       "mean": -0.03,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 18, column 'Within-stratum mean difference' (no SE printed); control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "18-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 1 (X): controls for baseline income, education, and age, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.42,
       "se": 0.11,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 0.28,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 125,
       "mean": -0.03,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 18, column 'Model 1 (X)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "18-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 2 (LDV): controls for the baseline outcome, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.34,
       "se": 0.08,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 0.28,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 125,
       "mean": -0.03,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 18, column 'Model 2 (LDV)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "18-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 3 (DiD): within-stratum difference in change from baseline",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.32,
       "se": 0.09,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [<0.01]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 0.28,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 125,
       "mean": -0.03,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 18, column 'Model 3 (DiD)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The four Table 6 estimates match in both coders and stay; coder 1's Figure 3 arm means are dropped because Figure 3 shows only respondents to the 24-month survey while Table 6 prints the whole sample at this wave (at 24 months the figure repeats Table 6's means to more digits)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T29-1",
    "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: within-stratum unadjusted mean difference",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -2.54,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 21.22,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 120,
       "mean": 23.51,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 24, column 'Within-stratum mean difference' (no SE printed); control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 1 (X): controls for baseline income, education, and age, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -3.15,
       "se": 1.38,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.13]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 21.22,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 120,
       "mean": 23.51,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 24, column 'Model 1 (X)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 2 (LDV): controls for the baseline outcome, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.75,
       "se": 1.06,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.33]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 21.22,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 120,
       "mean": 23.51,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 24, column 'Model 2 (LDV)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 3 (DiD): within-stratum difference in change from baseline",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.06,
       "se": 1.18,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.52]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 21.22,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 120,
       "mean": 23.51,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 24, column 'Model 3 (DiD)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The four Table 6 estimates match in both coders and stay; coder 1's Figure 3 arm means are dropped because Figure 3 shows only respondents to the 24-month survey while Table 6 prints the whole sample at this wave (at 24 months the figure repeats Table 6's means to more digits)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T29-1",
    "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
    "class": "life_satisfaction",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: within-stratum unadjusted mean difference",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.24,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 0.26,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 120,
       "mean": 0.05,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 24, column 'Within-stratum mean difference' (no SE printed); control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 1 (X): controls for baseline income, education, and age, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.23,
       "se": 0.11,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.15]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 0.26,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 120,
       "mean": 0.05,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 24, column 'Model 1 (X)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 2 (LDV): controls for the baseline outcome, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.19,
       "se": 0.08,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.1]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 0.26,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 120,
       "mean": 0.05,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 24, column 'Model 2 (LDV)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "24-month survey (one to two months after the final payment)",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 3 (DiD): within-stratum difference in change from baseline",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.2,
       "se": 0.08,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.1]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 165,
       "mean": 0.26,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 120,
       "mean": 0.05,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 24, column 'Model 3 (DiD)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The four Table 6 estimates match in both coders and stay; coder 1's Figure 3 arm means are dropped because Figure 3 shows only respondents to the 24-month survey while Table 6 prints the whole sample at this wave (at 24 months the figure repeats Table 6's means to more digits)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T29-1",
    "wave": "6-month survey",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "6-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: within-stratum unadjusted mean difference",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.84,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 22.07,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 128,
       "mean": 23.87,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 6, column 'Within-stratum mean difference' (no SE printed); control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "6-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 1 (X): controls for baseline income, education, and age, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -2.37,
       "se": 1.13,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.16]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 22.07,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 128,
       "mean": 23.87,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 6, column 'Model 1 (X)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "6-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 2 (LDV): controls for the baseline outcome, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.13,
       "se": 0.86,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.35]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 22.07,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 128,
       "mean": 23.87,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 6, column 'Model 2 (LDV)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "6-month survey",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "K10",
      "measure": "Psychological distress (Kessler 10 scale; ten items scored 1 to 5, summed); estimator: Model 3 (DiD): within-stratum difference in change from baseline",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -1.14,
       "se": 0.99,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.44]",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 168,
       "mean": 22.07,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 128,
       "mean": 23.87,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel A. Kessler 10 Scale, Month 6, column 'Model 3 (DiD)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The four Table 6 estimates match in both coders and stay; coder 1's Figure 3 arm means are dropped because Figure 3 shows only respondents to the 24-month survey while Table 6 prints the whole sample at this wave (at 24 months the figure repeats Table 6's means to more digits)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T29-1",
    "wave": "6-month survey",
    "class": "life_satisfaction",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "6-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: within-stratum unadjusted mean difference",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.15,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": null,
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 0.19,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 128,
       "mean": 0.04,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 6, column 'Within-stratum mean difference' (no SE printed); control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "6-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 1 (X): controls for baseline income, education, and age, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.21,
       "se": 0.11,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.16]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 0.19,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 128,
       "mean": 0.04,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 6, column 'Model 1 (X)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "6-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 2 (LDV): controls for the baseline outcome, by stratum",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.14,
       "se": 0.08,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.19]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 0.19,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 128,
       "mean": 0.04,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 6, column 'Model 2 (LDV)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T29-1",
      "wave": "6-month survey",
      "class": "life_satisfaction",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Subjective well-being index (3 items: self-reported health status, happiness, and life satisfaction; inverse covariance weighted index of components standardized by their baseline mean and SD); estimator: Model 3 (DiD): within-stratum difference in change from baseline",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": 0.16,
       "se": 0.08,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "family-wise-error-rate-adjusted p-value [0.14]",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": 167,
       "mean": 0.19,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": 128,
       "mean": 0.04,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 6 (p. 42), panel B. Well-Being Index, Month 6, column 'Model 3 (DiD)', robust SE in parentheses, FWER-adjusted p in brackets; control and treatment Mean (N) columns",
      "source": "aei:minneapolis-paper"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The four Table 6 estimates match in both coders and stay; coder 1's Figure 3 arm means are dropped because Figure 3 shows only respondents to the 24-month survey while Table 6 prints the whole sample at this wave (at 24 months the figure repeats Table 6's means to more digits)."
   }
  ],
  "attrition": []
 },
 {
  "trial": "T31",
  "groups": [
   {
    "comparison": "T31-1",
    "wave": "12-month survey",
    "class": "employed_full_time",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T31-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "employed_full_time",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Rate of full-time employment",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "At that time there were no significant differences between the two groups in rates of full-time employment, part-time employment, caregiving, or any other category of employment.",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Key Findings, 'ARISE might have enabled participants to work fewer hours and focus on other responsibilities', p. 10: sentence only, no numbers ('At that time' is the 12-month survey); Exhibit 11 ('Employment and earnings') is a chart with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 5)",
      "source": "aei:alexandria"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 10 sentence; it is kept whole, with kind adjusted_difference because the brief's impacts carry statistical adjustments for sample loss."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T31-1",
    "wave": "12-month survey",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T31-1",
      "wave": "12-month survey",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Perceived Stress Scale (Cohen et al., 1983; number of items not stated)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "They also reported marginally significantly lower scores than the control group on the Perceived Stress Scale, which measures levels of stress.",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Key Findings, 'ARISE participants reported improved mental well-being', p. 6: sentence only, after one year (the 12-month survey); Exhibit 1's legend (p. 1) marks * p < .10 and ** p < .05, but its values and Exhibits 8-9 are charts with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 5)",
      "source": "aei:alexandria"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 6 sentence; it is kept whole, with kind adjusted_difference because the brief's impacts carry statistical adjustments for sample loss."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T31-1",
    "wave": "6-month two-question tracking survey",
    "class": "employed_full_time",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T31-1",
      "wave": "6-month two-question tracking survey",
      "class": "employed_full_time",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Full-time work (six-month two-question tracking survey)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "On the brief, six-month tracking survey, ARISE participants reported a small but significant reduction in part-time employment, which was mostly offset by small increases in other types of work (e.g., full-time work, seasonal work, and caregiving).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Text box, p. 11: sentence only; it gives only the direction for full-time work (a small increase), with no number or test of its own; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 5)",
      "source": "aei:alexandria"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 11 text box; it is kept whole as the only statement on full-time work at six months, with kind adjusted_difference as for the brief's other impacts."
   }
  ],
  "attrition": []
 },
 {
  "trial": "T33",
  "groups": [
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K6 or K10 not stated)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Survey results are generally consistent with these positive findings, but we found no statistically significant differences between the SGIP parents and the control group over the course of the pilot (Exhibit 9).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 3, 'Psychological Distress', p. 18: sentence only, covering the Kessler scale and the perceived stress scale (footnote 21); Exhibit 9 ('SGIP Parents and Control Parents Experienced Similar Levels of Stress', p. 18) is a bar chart of the three survey points (p. 13 says every bar chart shows mid-pilot, end-of-pilot and post-pilot) with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 18 sentence; it is kept whole, with kind adjusted_difference because the report's impacts carry statistical adjustments for sample loss."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
    "class": "employed_any",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Holding one or more jobs (proportion of parents with at least one job)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "When we examine the likelihood of holding one or more jobs, there are no significant differences between SGIP participants and the control group.",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 6, 'Household Income', p. 35: sentence only; Exhibit 22 ('SGIP Did Not Significantly Change the Proportion of Parents with At Least One Job', p. 36) is a bar chart of the three survey points with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Participation in paid work (percentage of parents in paid work)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "We do not find significant effects on participation in paid or unpaid work (Exhibit 23)",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 6, p. 38: sentence only; Exhibit 23 ('SGIP did not Significantly Change the Percentage of Parents in Paid or Unpaid Work', p. 39) is a bar chart of the three survey points with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The report states two any-employment results without numbers, holding one or more jobs (p. 35, Exhibit 22) and the percentage in paid work (p. 38, Exhibit 23), both covering every survey point, so both entries stay (coder 1)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
    "class": "employed_full_time",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
      "class": "employed_full_time",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Employment status: full-time",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "We do not find significant effects on employment status (full-time, part-time, etc.) at mid-pilot or the end of the pilot (Appendix Table C1).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 6, p. 38: sentence only; Appendix Table C1 is not in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 38 sentence, which names mid-pilot and the end of the pilot; it is kept whole with kind adjusted_difference."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "End-of-pilot (12 months, February 2023, last payment)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Perceived stress scale (questions about parents' recent levels of stress; version not stated)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Survey results are generally consistent with these positive findings, but we found no statistically significant differences between the SGIP parents and the control group over the course of the pilot (Exhibit 9).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 3, 'Psychological Distress', p. 18: sentence only (footnote 21 names the Kessler scale and a perceived stress scale); Exhibit 9 ('SGIP Parents and Control Parents Experienced Similar Levels of Stress', p. 18) is a bar chart of the three survey points (p. 13 says every bar chart shows mid-pilot, end-of-pilot and post-pilot) with no numbers in the file; the summary (p. v) adds that during the pilot 'differences between SGIP participants and the control group were not statistically significant'; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 18 sentence; it is kept whole, with kind adjusted_difference because the report's impacts carry statistical adjustments for sample loss."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K6 or K10 not stated)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Survey results are generally consistent with these positive findings, but we found no statistically significant differences between the SGIP parents and the control group over the course of the pilot (Exhibit 9).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 3, 'Psychological Distress', p. 18: sentence only, covering the Kessler scale and the perceived stress scale (footnote 21); Exhibit 9 ('SGIP Parents and Control Parents Experienced Similar Levels of Stress', p. 18) is a bar chart of the three survey points (p. 13 says every bar chart shows mid-pilot, end-of-pilot and post-pilot) with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 18 sentence; it is kept whole, with kind adjusted_difference because the report's impacts carry statistical adjustments for sample loss."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
    "class": "employed_any",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Holding one or more jobs (proportion of parents with at least one job)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "When we examine the likelihood of holding one or more jobs, there are no significant differences between SGIP participants and the control group.",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 6, 'Household Income', p. 35: sentence only; Exhibit 22 ('SGIP Did Not Significantly Change the Proportion of Parents with At Least One Job', p. 36) is a bar chart of the three survey points with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Participation in paid work (percentage of parents in paid work)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "We do not find significant effects on participation in paid or unpaid work (Exhibit 23)",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 6, p. 38: sentence only; Exhibit 23 ('SGIP did not Significantly Change the Percentage of Parents in Paid or Unpaid Work', p. 39) is a bar chart of the three survey points with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The report states two any-employment results without numbers, holding one or more jobs (p. 35, Exhibit 22) and the percentage in paid work (p. 38, Exhibit 23), both covering every survey point, so both entries stay (coder 1)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
    "class": "employed_full_time",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
      "class": "employed_full_time",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Employment status: full-time",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "We do not find significant effects on employment status (full-time, part-time, etc.) at mid-pilot or the end of the pilot (Appendix Table C1).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 6, p. 38: sentence only; Appendix Table C1 is not in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 38 sentence, which names mid-pilot and the end of the pilot; it is kept whole with kind adjusted_difference."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Mid-pilot (6 months, September 2022)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Perceived stress scale (questions about parents' recent levels of stress; version not stated)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Survey results are generally consistent with these positive findings, but we found no statistically significant differences between the SGIP parents and the control group over the course of the pilot (Exhibit 9).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 3, 'Psychological Distress', p. 18: sentence only (footnote 21 names the Kessler scale and a perceived stress scale); Exhibit 9 ('SGIP Parents and Control Parents Experienced Similar Levels of Stress', p. 18) is a bar chart of the three survey points (p. 13 says every bar chart shows mid-pilot, end-of-pilot and post-pilot) with no numbers in the file; the summary (p. v) adds that during the pilot 'differences between SGIP participants and the control group were not statistically significant'; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 18 sentence; it is kept whole, with kind adjusted_difference because the report's impacts carry statistical adjustments for sample loss."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "Post-pilot (6 months after GI ended, August 2023)",
    "class": "distress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Post-pilot (6 months after GI ended, August 2023)",
      "class": "distress",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K6 or K10 not stated)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Survey results are generally consistent with these positive findings, but we found no statistically significant differences between the SGIP parents and the control group over the course of the pilot (Exhibit 9).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 3, 'Psychological Distress', p. 18: sentence only, covering the Kessler scale and the perceived stress scale (footnote 21); Exhibit 9 ('SGIP Parents and Control Parents Experienced Similar Levels of Stress', p. 18) is a bar chart of the three survey points (p. 13 says every bar chart shows mid-pilot, end-of-pilot and post-pilot) with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The p. 18 sentence points to Exhibit 9, which like every bar chart in the report shows the post-pilot survey too, and it covers the Kessler and stress scales alike, so a post-pilot distress entry stands as the post-pilot stress entry does (coder 2)."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "Post-pilot (6 months after GI ended, August 2023)",
    "class": "employed_any",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Post-pilot (6 months after GI ended, August 2023)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Holding one or more jobs (proportion of parents with at least one job)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "When we examine the likelihood of holding one or more jobs, there are no significant differences between SGIP participants and the control group.",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 6, 'Household Income', p. 35: sentence only; Exhibit 22 ('SGIP Did Not Significantly Change the Proportion of Parents with At Least One Job', p. 36) is a bar chart of the three survey points with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     },
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Post-pilot (6 months after GI ended, August 2023)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Participation in paid work (percentage of parents in paid work)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "We do not find significant effects on participation in paid or unpaid work (Exhibit 23), although SGIP parents were more likely than control group members to be workers post-pilot (Appendix Table C1).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 6, p. 38: sentence only; Exhibit 23 ('SGIP did not Significantly Change the Percentage of Parents in Paid or Unpaid Work', p. 39) is a bar chart of the three survey points with no numbers in the file; 'workers' is not defined, the next sentence ties it to gig work, and Appendix Table C1 is not in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Holding one or more jobs and the percentage in paid work both stay at post-pilot; the undefined 'workers' clause (which the report ties to gig work) is kept in the paid-work sentence rather than coded as a separate any-employment result."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T33-1",
    "wave": "Post-pilot (6 months after GI ended, August 2023)",
    "class": "stress",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T33-1",
      "wave": "Post-pilot (6 months after GI ended, August 2023)",
      "class": "stress",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Perceived stress scale (questions about parents' recent levels of stress; version not stated)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Survey results are generally consistent with these positive findings, but we found no statistically significant differences between the SGIP parents and the control group over the course of the pilot (Exhibit 9).",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Chapter 3, 'Psychological Distress', p. 18: sentence only (footnote 21 names the Kessler scale and a perceived stress scale); Exhibit 9 ('SGIP Parents and Control Parents Experienced Similar Levels of Stress', p. 18) is a bar chart of the three survey points (p. 13 says every bar chart shows mid-pilot, end-of-pilot and post-pilot) with no numbers in the file; impacts are differences in mean outcomes with statistical adjustments for study members leaving the sample (p. 10)",
      "source": "aei:shreveport"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders gave a post-pilot stress entry from the p. 18 sentence and Exhibit 9, which shows the post-pilot survey; it is kept whole with kind adjusted_difference."
   }
  ],
  "attrition": []
 },
 {
  "trial": "T41",
  "groups": [
   {
    "comparison": "T41-1",
    "wave": "Month 30 long survey (6 months after the end of the program)",
    "class": "employed_any",
    "binary": true,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T41-1",
      "wave": "Month 30 long survey (6 months after the end of the program)",
      "class": "employed_any",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Employment (not further described)",
      "binary": true,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "TYI did not appear to have had an impact when compared to services as usual on several long-term outcomes, including employment and education.",
       "kind": "difference",
       "scale": "percentage_points"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": false,
      "where": "Impact Evaluation, Key Findings, 'Long-term Outcomes', p. 14: sentence only, no numbers and no wave named (placed at the month-30 survey, the study's last); the report compares groups as enrolled (TYI n = 29, services as usual n = 49) by visual inspection, without statistical tests (pp. 10 and 16)",
      "source": "pilot:trus_1"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the p. 14 sentence; it is kept whole as an unadjusted comparison (the report used no models or tests) with no proportion unit, since no shares are printed."
   }
  ],
  "attrition": [
   {
    "comparison": "T41-1",
    "wave": "Month 30 long survey (6 months after the end of the program)",
    "row": {
     "comparison": "T41-1",
     "wave": "Month 30 long survey (6 months after the end of the program)",
     "randomized_treated": 34,
     "randomized_control": 44,
     "responded_treated": null,
     "responded_control": null,
     "where": "Study Methods, p. 6: of 78 enrolled, 34 were randomly invited to TYI (29 took part; the 4 not reached and the 1 who declined were placed in services as usual) and the other 44 were not invited (the text says '45', which does not fit its total of 78 or the baseline group sizes of 29 and 49). Month-30 respondents are printed only by group as enrolled, not by randomized arm: Figure 6's note gives 30-Month n = 26 TYI (of 29) and n = 36 services as usual (of 49, which includes the 5 invited non-participants).",
     "source": "pilot:trus_1"
    },
    "why": "The randomized counts are as both coders gave them, but the month-30 respondent counts are for groups as enrolled (the 5 invited non-participants sit in services as usual), so respondents by randomized arm are not printed and stay null (coder 1)."
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "trial": "T81",
  "groups": [
   {
    "comparison": "T81-1",
    "wave": "One-month follow-up survey (sent June 18, 2020)",
    "class": "earnings",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T81-1",
      "wave": "One-month follow-up survey (sent June 18, 2020)",
      "class": "earnings",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Monthly earned income (current monthly earnings, asked in the one-month survey)",
      "binary": false,
      "per": "month",
      "currency": "USD",
      "higher_is": "better",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": null,
       "se": null,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "supplemental analyses found no effect of the treatment on monthly earned income",
       "kind": "adjusted_difference",
       "scale": "currency"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Results, 'Treatment Effects Among Low-Income Groups', p. 10: 'Current monthly earnings were obtained in the one-month survey and could, in theory, be affected by the intervention, but supplemental analyses found no effect of the treatment on monthly earned income' (sentence only, no numbers, whole sample); the supplemental specification is not described, and every analysis the paper prints includes the full set of controls",
      "source": "registered:AEARCTR-0005852_1"
     }
    ],
    "why": "The paper states a whole-sample result for monthly earned income at one month in a sentence, which the codebook asks to copy, so coder 1's entry is kept with kind adjusted_difference and scale currency filled."
   },
   {
    "comparison": "T81-1",
    "wave": "Three-month follow-up survey (launched August 21, 2020)",
    "class": "general_mental_health",
    "binary": false,
    "subgroup": false,
    "entries": [
     {
      "comparison": "T81-1",
      "wave": "Three-month follow-up survey (launched August 21, 2020)",
      "class": "general_mental_health",
      "instrument": "other",
      "measure": "Mental health challenges composite index: Anderson (2008) weighted mean of standardized PHQ-2 (depression) and GAD-2 (anxiety) items, standardized on the control group; positive = worse",
      "binary": false,
      "per": null,
      "currency": null,
      "higher_is": "worse",
      "subgroup": null,
      "estimate": {
       "value": -0.002,
       "se": 0.028,
       "lower": null,
       "upper": null,
       "level": null,
       "p": null,
       "p_text": "Bonferroni 1.000; FWER 0.996",
       "kind": "standardized_difference",
       "scale": "sd_units"
      },
      "treated": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": null,
       "sd": null,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "control": {
       "n": null,
       "mean": -0.001,
       "sd": 0.999,
       "proportion": null
      },
      "proportion_unit": null,
      "baseline_sd": null,
      "adjusted": true,
      "where": "Table 2 'Primary Outcome Intent-to-Treat Estimates in Full Sample at One and Three Months Post Cash Transfer', Three-Month panel, 'Mental Health Challenges': Treatment -0.002 (robust SE 0.028), Observations 5244, Control Mean -0.001, Control SD 0.999, multiplicity-adjusted p-values only, no significance mark; arm numbers analysed are not printed (the 5244 observations are fewer than the 3,430 treatment and 2,344 control respondents to the three-month survey, text p. 8)",
      "source": "registered:AEARCTR-0005852_1"
     }
    ],
    "why": "Both coders copied the same Table 2 numbers; arm n stays null (coder 1) because the 3,430 and 2,344 three-month respondents are not the numbers analysed, which Table 2 gives only as 5244 in all."
   }
  ],
  "attrition": []
 }
]