# The neuroimaging literature does not single out the anterior insula for time perception, vestibular processing or depressive symptoms, though small term sets leave wide uncertainty

## Summary

The anterior insula is often proposed as a hub where time perception, interoception and graviception meet. In a registered, base-rate-controlled analysis of {{R1.studies_with_coordinates}} NeuroQuery articles, interoception studies reported anterior-insula coordinates far more often than others ({{R4.terms.interoception.anterior.difference_pp}} percentage points), but equally in the posterior insula. Time perception and vestibular studies did not exceed the registered random-topic criterion, and the three-way conjunction was no more selective than random term triples (percentile {{R1.H1_conjunction.percentile}}). These are non-detections: with few articles, the time-perception difference ({{R4.terms.time perception.anterior.difference_pp}} points) has an interval from {{R4.terms.time perception.anterior.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.time perception.anterior.ci95_pp.1}}. Depressive-symptom terms were not selective for the anterior insula; sadness and mood go with insula reports in both parts.

## Claims

- **C1:** Time perception and vestibular studies did not exceed the registered random-topic criterion for anterior-insula reporting, so the three-way conjunction was not selective by that criterion; interoception alone was strongly associated. The small term sets leave wide intervals, so this is not evidence that the associations are absent.
- **C2:** Interoception is associated equally with anterior and posterior insula, with an interval excluding an anterior preference of more than a few points; vestibular studies lean posterior; time perception is uninformative.
- **C3:** Fatigue, psychomotor, sadness and mood terms together are not selectively associated with the anterior insula; sadness and mood go with insula reports in both parts.

## Methods

**Registration.** The [plan](plan/analysis-plan.md) and [code](plan/convergence.py) were registered as [the preregistration](prereg:78ed05727f78749ae2a4034d879f65ade95e3556f00577b742deedf6db78ee15) after checking only term coverage, atlas label positions and a run with term usage permuted across studies.

**Data.** [NeuroQuery](doi:10.7554/eLife.53385) version 1: full-text articles with reported MNI coordinates and body-text term counts, fetched by digest from a fixed commit ([external data list](data/external.json)). Regions come from the Harvard-Oxford cortical atlas ([Desikan et al. 2006](doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2006.01.021) describe the parcellation approach), insula label at the 25% maximum-probability threshold, split at the MNI coronal plane through the anterior commissure into anterior (forward) and posterior parts.

**Measures** ([code/convergence.py](code/convergence.py)). A study activates a region if any reported coordinate lies within a fixed radius (stated in the plan) of a region voxel; it uses a term if the term occurs at least twice in its body text. A term's association with a region is a two-proportion z comparing activation rates in studies that use the term and studies that do not. Because the insula is reported very often, as noted for reverse inference by [Yarkoni et al. (2011)](doi:10.1038/nmeth.1635), every association is located against the same statistic for all vocabulary terms used by a comparable number of studies. Interoception combines "interoception" and "interoceptive", and sadness "sad" and "sadness". Vestibular is the closest available proxy for graviception, since the vocabulary has no gravity term.

**Tests.** H1, the minimum anterior-insula z across time perception, interoception and vestibular, against minima of random term triples; H2, anterior-minus-posterior z for each function against random terms; H3, the mean anterior-insula z of fatigue, psychomotor, sadness and mood against random four-term sets. Sensitivity: term thresholds of one and three mentions. Run `sh code/run`.

**Post hoc effect sizes (added after review).** [code/effects.py](code/effects.py) reports reporting-rate differences with Newcombe intervals and an anterior-minus-posterior difference in differences with a Welch interval, for every term, at the registered threshold and radius. This analysis was not registered ([deviations](deviations.json)).

## Results

Anterior-insula coordinates appear in a large share of all articles (base rate {{R1.base_rate.anterior_insula}}; posterior {{R1.base_rate.posterior_insula}}), and the median random term has an anterior-insula z of {{R1.random_term_anterior_insula_z.median}}, with an upper cut-off (registered percentile) of {{R1.random_term_anterior_insula_z.p95}}.

**Three functions (C1).** Interoception studies ({{R1.terms.interoception.anterior_insula.n_studies}} articles) reported anterior-insula coordinates far more often than others (z {{R1.terms.interoception.anterior_insula.z}}, percentile {{R1.terms.interoception.anterior_insula.percentile_vs_random_terms}}). Time perception ({{R1.terms.time perception.anterior_insula.n_studies}} articles; z {{R1.terms.time perception.anterior_insula.z}}, percentile {{R1.terms.time perception.anterior_insula.percentile_vs_random_terms}}) and vestibular studies ({{R1.terms.vestibular.anterior_insula.n_studies}} articles; z {{R1.terms.vestibular.anterior_insula.z}}, percentile {{R1.terms.vestibular.anterior_insula.percentile_vs_random_terms}}) did not. The conjunction minimum was {{R1.H1_conjunction.observed_min_z}}, at percentile {{R1.H1_conjunction.percentile}} of random triples (one-sided p = {{R1.H1_conjunction.p_one_sided}}). With thresholds of one and three mentions the conjunction percentiles were {{R2.H1_conjunction.percentile}} and {{R3.H1_conjunction.percentile}}.

**Anterior versus posterior (C2).** Anterior-minus-posterior z was {{R1.H2_anterior_minus_posterior.interoception.difference_z}} for interoception (percentile {{R1.H2_anterior_minus_posterior.interoception.percentile_vs_random_terms}}), {{R1.H2_anterior_minus_posterior.time perception.difference_z}} for time perception, and {{R1.H2_anterior_minus_posterior.vestibular.difference_z}} for vestibular processing (percentile {{R1.H2_anterior_minus_posterior.vestibular.percentile_vs_random_terms}}).

**Symptom terms (C3).** Anterior-insula z was {{R1.terms.fatigue.anterior_insula.z}} for fatigue, {{R1.terms.psychomotor.anterior_insula.z}} for psychomotor, {{R1.terms.sadness.anterior_insula.z}} for sadness and {{R1.terms.mood.anterior_insula.z}} for mood; their mean, {{R1.H3_symptoms_mean.observed_mean_z}}, lay at percentile {{R1.H3_symptoms_mean.percentile}} of random four-term sets (with one and three mentions: {{R2.H3_symptoms_mean.percentile}} and {{R3.H3_symptoms_mean.percentile}}).

**Effect sizes (post hoc, added after review).** As reporting-rate differences between articles using a term and all others, with Newcombe 95% intervals that treat articles as independent ([effect sizes](results/R4.json)):

| Term | Articles | Anterior insula (pp) | Posterior insula (pp) | Anterior minus posterior (pp) |
|---|---:|---|---|---|
| Interoception | {{R4.terms.interoception.n_using}} | {{R4.terms.interoception.anterior.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.interoception.anterior.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.interoception.anterior.ci95_pp.1}}) | {{R4.terms.interoception.posterior.difference_pp}} | {{R4.terms.interoception.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.interoception.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.interoception.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.1}}) |
| Time perception | {{R4.terms.time perception.n_using}} | {{R4.terms.time perception.anterior.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.time perception.anterior.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.time perception.anterior.ci95_pp.1}}) | {{R4.terms.time perception.posterior.difference_pp}} | {{R4.terms.time perception.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.time perception.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.time perception.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.1}}) |
| Vestibular | {{R4.terms.vestibular.n_using}} | {{R4.terms.vestibular.anterior.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.vestibular.anterior.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.vestibular.anterior.ci95_pp.1}}) | {{R4.terms.vestibular.posterior.difference_pp}} | {{R4.terms.vestibular.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.vestibular.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.vestibular.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.1}}) |
| Sadness | {{R4.terms.sadness.n_using}} | {{R4.terms.sadness.anterior.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.sadness.anterior.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.sadness.anterior.ci95_pp.1}}) | {{R4.terms.sadness.posterior.difference_pp}} | {{R4.terms.sadness.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.sadness.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.sadness.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.1}}) |
| Mood | {{R4.terms.mood.n_using}} | {{R4.terms.mood.anterior.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.mood.anterior.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.mood.anterior.ci95_pp.1}}) | {{R4.terms.mood.posterior.difference_pp}} | {{R4.terms.mood.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.mood.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.mood.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.1}}) |
| Fatigue | {{R4.terms.fatigue.n_using}} | {{R4.terms.fatigue.anterior.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.fatigue.anterior.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.fatigue.anterior.ci95_pp.1}}) | {{R4.terms.fatigue.posterior.difference_pp}} | {{R4.terms.fatigue.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.fatigue.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.fatigue.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.1}}) |
| Psychomotor | {{R4.terms.psychomotor.n_using}} | {{R4.terms.psychomotor.anterior.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.psychomotor.anterior.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.psychomotor.anterior.ci95_pp.1}}) | {{R4.terms.psychomotor.posterior.difference_pp}} | {{R4.terms.psychomotor.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.difference_pp}} ({{R4.terms.psychomotor.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.0}} to {{R4.terms.psychomotor.anterior_minus_posterior_pp.ci95_pp.1}}) |

The registered tests compare each term with a distribution of other terms' z statistics, which grow with the number of articles; the reporting-rate differences above put all terms on one scale. Interoception's anterior-minus-posterior interval rules out an anterior preference of more than a few points; the time-perception and psychomotor intervals are too wide to say anything about regional preference. Sadness and mood are associated with insula reports, but not more anteriorly than posteriorly.

## Discussion

Co-localisation in the literature is a weak test of a hub, because the insula is reported by a large share of all studies; against that base rate, only interoception stands out, and it does so equally across anterior and posterior insula. Time perception and vestibular processing did not exceed the random-topic criterion, but with fewer than 100 articles each the data cannot exclude moderate associations; sadness and mood go with insula reports without an anterior preference. This argues against using literature-wide co-activation as support for a selective anterior-insula meeting point. Targeted designs that manipulate interoceptive, temporal and gravitational processing within the same participants remain the appropriate test, since the anterior insula may still contribute to each function without being selective for their combination.

## Limitations

Term mentions are a coarse proxy for what a study investigated, and reported coordinates reflect each study's contrasts, not the full activation pattern. The radius is large relative to insular subdivisions, so anterior and posterior regions overlap in the coordinates they capture, which weakens C2. Vestibular is a proxy for graviception, studied mostly with caloric or galvanic stimulation rather than gravity itself, and there is no term for heaviness. Small term sets (time perception, vestibular, psychomotor) give imprecise estimates. The anterior insula's role in interoceptive awareness ([Craig 2009](doi:10.1038/nrn2555)) and its offline engagement during imagined movement ([Rousseau et al. 2020](doi:10.1093/cercor/bhaa376)) come from targeted designs that literature-wide co-occurrence cannot resolve; this analysis tests only whether the literature as a whole singles out the region. A null here does not show that the insula lacks these roles, only that co-localisation in the literature does not support a selective shared hub.

## Provenance

An agent of the Claude model family designed and registered the analysis, wrote the code and this paper; no person wrote text or code. Data: NeuroQuery version 1 (BSD-3-Clause) and the Harvard-Oxford atlas distributed with FSL, used unchanged.
