{ "summary": { "pubmed_europepmc": { "n": 582, "kept_1": 53, "kept_2": 49, "agree": 578, "kappa": 0.957, "third_reader": 9, "kept": 53, "reviews": 16 }, "openalex": { "n": 736, "kept_1": 101, "kept_2": 107, "agree": 720, "kappa": 0.91, "third_reader": 26, "kept": 99, "reviews": 10 }, "registrations": { "n": 441, "kept_1": 67, "kept_2": 67, "agree": 439, "kappa": 0.982, "third_reader": 2, "eligible": 68 } }, "registrations": [ { "id": "NCT01838005", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05248100", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03021070", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT07463131", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT06831552", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT07569172", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05622903", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT01304888", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06295250", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05373095", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03455257", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT07432971", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT01763502", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05855551", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04166370", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT01678183", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04101487", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04225845", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04013516", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03810300", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT07502365", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT06323967", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": "eligible", "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT07261254", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT04125251", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06733844", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT00966849", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05709457", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03051789", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05778578", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT07115901", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03870061", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05807750", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT04077086", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05531812", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04432571", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT02903641", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT07016646", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT01835574", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT02526147", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT01571128", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05665049", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03236948", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04359264", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT05857553", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT07265375", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT06771739", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT02858011", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04081441", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT07500142", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03144076", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05219552", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT01333826", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03593356", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT05782660", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT05838027", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT05930327", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT07226492", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06505811", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT05225064", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03049917", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05176743", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT01957917", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT02561949", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03490045", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03597243", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT07200648", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT01557998", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT02709967", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04572178", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06923371", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT04090762", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT01233531", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT04532008", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT07381049", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT03518593", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05408884", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT02460848", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT02931422", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05598697", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT02870322", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06186128", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT03355989", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03131193", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06642012", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT02237144", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05609188", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT05477901", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03966833", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06971952", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03540927", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05372978", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT05598970", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT01866124", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03142256", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05559892", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06611982", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT04201353", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03281980", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT06025786", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT03090802", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05201586", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT03498755", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "NCT05698498", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "NCT05192434", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000049", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000082", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000099", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000247", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000340", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000368", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000419", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000454", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000456", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000459", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000521", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000563", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000598", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000656", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000684", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000696", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000815", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000821", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000844", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000947", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0000957", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001035", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001172", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001215", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001299", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001326", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001357", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001395", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001416", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001433", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001458", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001476", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001572", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001601", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001630", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001655", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001674", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001751", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001767", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001778", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001794", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001921", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001942", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001943", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001952", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001953", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0001975", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002041", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002042", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002055", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002058", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002095", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002181", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002187", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002210", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002388", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002433", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002440", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002537", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002543", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002544", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002665", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002672", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002679", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002737", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002768", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002786", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002788", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002864", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002897", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002915", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002918", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002949", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0002977", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003004", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003011", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003015", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003050", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003082", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003106", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003191", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003200", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003222", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003247", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003248", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003257", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003262", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003290", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003398", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003434", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003498", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003506", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003516", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003592", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003618", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003634", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003655", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003679", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003737", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003782", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003802", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003821", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003834", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003874", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003944", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003958", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003972", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0003986", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004002", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004048", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004101", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004109", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004131", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004148", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004170", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004229", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004388", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004456", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004490", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004527", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004530", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004869", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004974", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0004978", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005031", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005032", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005164", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005168", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005303", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005453", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005580", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005734", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005805", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005852", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0005861", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006104", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006129", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006149", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006150", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006168", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006294", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006398", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006528", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006574", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006590", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006736", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006750", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006793", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006794", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006795", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0006851", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007010", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007164", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007225", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007548", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007579", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007582", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007621", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007725", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007731", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007734", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007755", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007756", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007944", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007957", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0007990", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008051", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008063", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008256", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008261", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008341", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008372", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008427", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008456", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008507", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008509", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008649", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008738", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008833", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008860", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008915", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0008988", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009034", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009051", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009115", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009144", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009158", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009198", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009502", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009652", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009656", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009662", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009773", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009775", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0009791", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010032", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010209", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010326", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010372", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010426", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010468", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010472", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010481", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010546", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010629", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010641", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010745", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010746", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010786", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0010962", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011056", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011126", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011145", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011178", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011362", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011369", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011485", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011612", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011620", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011622", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011791", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011794", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011801", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011832", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011919", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0011995", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012144", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012147", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012251", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012321", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012342", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012358", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012385", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012412", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012481", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012505", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012545", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012550", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012647", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012719", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012793", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012808", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012837", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0012845", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013052", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013065", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013157", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013183", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013195", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013210", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013250", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013252", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013550", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013762", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013779", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013807", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013863", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013871", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0013943", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014078", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014150", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014241", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014394", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014418", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014466", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014521", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014629", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014714", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014796", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014812", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0014893", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015020", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015027", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015048", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015065", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015098", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015221", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015253", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015321", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015335", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015357", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015420", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015437", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015474", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015726", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015745", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015873", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0015911", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016052", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016159", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016238", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016260", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016384", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016422", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016479", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016792", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016810", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016876", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016927", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0016974", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0017079", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0017177", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0017198", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0017238", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0017488", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0017492", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0017551", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018086", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018214", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018229", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018353", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018565", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018591", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018597", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018645", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018706", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": "eligible", "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018825", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018883", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018933", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0018984", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019018", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019112", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019197", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019213", "coder_1": "eligible", "coder_2": "eligible", "third": null, "decided": "eligible" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019248", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019291", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019305", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019371", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019426", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019427", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019476", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019594", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019705", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019710", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019711", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019712", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" }, { "id": "AEARCTR-0019857", "coder_1": "exclude", "coder_2": "exclude", "third": null, "decided": "exclude" } ], "grey": { "cgir": [ { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Cambridge-MA", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Cambridge-MA", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Cambridge MA-February 2024.pdf", "chars": 236821 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Columbia-SC", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Columbia-SC", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Columbia SC-February 2024.pdf", "chars": 160665 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Durham-NC", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Durham-NC", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Durham NC-February 2025.pdf", "chars": 242500 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Gainesville-FL", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Gainesville-FL", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Gainesville FL-February 2025.pdf", "chars": 214299 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Iowa-Affordability", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Iowa-Affordability", "file_name": "Castro et al 2026-Iowa-Affordability.pdf", "chars": 72555 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Iowa-HealthAndHope", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Iowa-HealthAndHope", "file_name": "Castro et al 2026-Iowa-HealthAndHope.pdf", "chars": 64292 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Iowa-Parenting", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Iowa-Parenting", "file_name": "Castro et al 2026-Iowa-Parenting.pdf", "chars": 58178 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Ithaca-NY", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Ithaca-NY", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Ithaca NY-July 2025.pdf", "chars": 236373 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-LA-CA-BIGLEAP", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-LA-CA-BIGLEAP", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Los Angeles CA-July 2024.pdf", "chars": 243993 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Madison-WI", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Madison-WI", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Madison WI-October 2025.pdf", "chars": 235450 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-NewOrleans-LA", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-NewOrleans-LA", "file_name": "CGIR Report-New Orleans LA-August 2024.pdf", "chars": 168697 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Newark NJ-June 2025.pdf", "chars": 253368 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ-2", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Newark-NJ-2", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Newark NJ-Reconstructing Home-June 2025.pdf", "chars": 79491 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Oakland-CA", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Oakland-CA", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Oakland CA-April 2025.pdf", "chars": 222194 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Paterson-NJ", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Paterson-NJ", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Paterson NJ-December 2023.pdf", "chars": 194180 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Providence-RI", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Providence-RI", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Providence RI-January 2025.pdf", "chars": 237229 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Richmond-VA", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Richmond-VA", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Richmond VA-May 2024.pdf", "chars": 140479 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-SanDiego-CA", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-SanDiego-CA", "file_name": "CGIR Report-San Diego CA-August 2025.pdf", "chars": 281369 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-SantaFe-NM", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-SantaFe-NM", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Santa Fe NM-February 2025.pdf", "chars": 153141 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-StPaul-MN", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-StPaul-MN", "file_name": "CGIR Report-St Paul MN-November 2023.pdf", "chars": 186607 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-Tacoma-WA", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Tacoma-WA", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Tacoma WA-August 2024.pdf", "chars": 182538 }, { "id": "cgir:CGIR-Report-UlsterCounty-NY", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-UlsterCounty-NY", "file_name": "CGIR Report-Ulster Cty NY-September 2023.pdf", "chars": 136352 } ], "cited_and_dashboard": [ { "id": "aei:arlington", "url": "https://issuu.com/arlcf/docs/arlingtons_guarantee_final_report_-_jan_2024", "fetched": null, "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 3810, "error": "issuu viewer only; no document file" }, { "id": "aei:compton", "url": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w33209/w33209.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w33209/w33209.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 256604 }, { "id": "aei:openresearch-consumption", "url": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w32784/w32784.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w32784/w32784.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, references", "chars": 480382 }, { "id": "aei:montgomery", "url": "https://mocoboost.org/wp-content/uploads/Evaluation-of-Montgomery-Countys-Two-Year-Guaranteed-Income-Pilot-June-2025.pdf", "fetched": "https://web.archive.org/web/2025id_/https://mocoboost.org/wp-content/uploads/Evaluation-of-Montgomery-Countys-Two-Year-Guaranteed-Income-Pilot-June-2025.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "note": "the original link no longer serves the report; the Internet Archive's copy" }, { "id": "aei:denver", "url": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64f507a995b636019ef8853a/t/6671a15eec7a812dee108e7c/1718722914185/FINAL_DBIP+Year+One+Quantitative+Research+Report.pdf", "fetched": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64f507a995b636019ef8853a/t/6671a15eec7a812dee108e7c/1718722914185/FINAL_DBIP+Year+One+Quantitative+Research+Report.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 115090 }, { "id": "aei:in-her-hands", "url": "https://equitablegrowth.org/working-papers/in-her-hands-a-guaranteed-income-initiative/", "fetched": "https://equitablegrowth.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/090425-WP-In-Her-Hands-Brugger-Davis-Elliott-et-al.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 101931 }, { "id": "aei:rise-up-alameda", "url": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64f8b31cbb263222a1487bd6/t/68b211679124b34f3957ebc7/1756500327354/Rise_Up_Alameda_Interim_Report_Final.pdf", "fetched": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64f8b31cbb263222a1487bd6/t/68b211679124b34f3957ebc7/1756500327354/Rise_Up_Alameda_Interim_Report_Final.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 59417 }, { "id": "aei:minneapolis-overview", "url": "https://www.minneapolisfed.org/-/media/assets/topics/labor-market-policies/24-month-results-overview.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.minneapolisfed.org/-/media/assets/topics/labor-market-policies/24-month-results-overview.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 27668 }, { "id": "aei:minneapolis-paper", "url": "https://doi.org/10.21034/iwp.108", "fetched": "https://www.minneapolisfed.org/institute/working-papers-institute/iwp108.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1" }, { "id": "aei:birmingham", "url": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64f8b31cbb263222a1487bd6/t/66b259743f93ea0c56cd88fe/1722964353521/Birmingham_MGI+Report+Final.pdf", "fetched": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64f8b31cbb263222a1487bd6/t/66b259743f93ea0c56cd88fe/1722964353521/Birmingham_MGI+Report+Final.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1; Pilots Dashboard", "chars": 174130 }, { "id": "aei:alexandria", "url": "https://www.alexandriava.gov/sites/default/files/2024-11/arise_one_year_brief_final.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.alexandriava.gov/sites/default/files/2024-11/arise_one_year_brief_final.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 48884 }, { "id": "aei:rochester", "url": "https://www.cityofrochester.gov/sites/default/files/2025-12/GBI_technical_report_FINAL_v2_12.5.2025.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.cityofrochester.gov/sites/default/files/2025-12/GBI_technical_report_FINAL_v2_12.5.2025.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 314125 }, { "id": "aei:shreveport", "url": "https://www.abtglobal.com/sites/default/files/files/insights/reports/2024/shreveport-mgi-report_10-30-24.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.abtglobal.com/sites/default/files/files/insights/reports/2024/shreveport-mgi-report_10-30-24.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1; Pilots Dashboard", "chars": 199105 }, { "id": "aei:louisville", "url": "https://www.abtglobal.com/sites/default/files/files/insights/reports/2024/louisville-mgi-report-v10.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.abtglobal.com/sites/default/files/files/insights/reports/2024/louisville-mgi-report-v10.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 174392 }, { "id": "aei:chelsea-eats", "url": "https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/Taubman/RIGB/Chelsea%20Eats%20Experimental%20Impacts%20120622.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/Taubman/RIGB/Chelsea%20Eats%20Experimental%20Impacts%20120622.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 150728 }, { "id": "aei:openresearch-health", "url": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w32711/w32711.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w32711/w32711.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, references", "chars": 661776 }, { "id": "aei:openresearch-employment", "url": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w32719/w32719.pdf", "fetched": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w32719/w32719.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 582946 }, { "id": "aei:baltimore", "url": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64f8b31cbb263222a1487bd6/t/68f28379c14e4a200abef61d/1760723833276/Baltimore_MGI+report+FINAL.pdf", "fetched": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64f8b31cbb263222a1487bd6/t/68f28379c14e4a200abef61d/1760723833276/Baltimore_MGI+report+FINAL.pdf", "found_in": "Corinth and Mayhew 2026, Table A1", "chars": 205572 }, { "id": "dashboard:child-outcomes", "url": "https://guaranteedincome.us/images/childoutcomesreport.pdf", "fetched": "https://guaranteedincome.us/images/childoutcomesreport.pdf", "found_in": "Pilots Dashboard (Atlanta, Birmingham, Louisville, Shreveport)", "chars": 114700 } ], "babys_first_years_site": [ { "id": "bfy:employment-ssr", "url": "https://www.babysfirstyears.com/_files/ugd/88a466_ba7101ba238442de96cdfc0a89dfef6c.pdf", "found_in": "Baby's First Years publications page", "chars": 99063 }, { "id": "bfy:health-jamaped", "url": "https://www.babysfirstyears.com/_files/ugd/88a466_5cf24b6779a14e0abaac5aca5e5536e5.pdf", "found_in": "Baby's First Years publications page", "chars": 133915 }, { "id": "bfy:wellbeing-ssrn", "url": "https://www.babysfirstyears.com/_files/ugd/88a466_2d2b839677364313935bbc50050b8ccc.pdf", "found_in": "Baby's First Years publications page", "chars": 279353 }, { "id": "bfy:mh-covid-imhj", "url": "https://www.babysfirstyears.com/_files/ugd/88a466_1dfe71b8b81345aa81ae16414cb62efd.pdf", "found_in": "Baby's First Years publications page", "chars": 102932 }, { "id": "bfy:nber-w30379", "url": "https://www.babysfirstyears.com/_files/ugd/88a466_9a9451f0c3f1490aab1a91139b6385bf.pdf", "found_in": "Baby's First Years publications page", "chars": 168229 }, { "id": "bfy:brief-age4", "url": "https://childandfamilypolicy.duke.edu/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/BFY-Monthly-Cash-Gift-at-Age-4.pdf", "found_in": "Baby's First Years publications page", "chars": 15459 } ], "stanford_pilots_searched": [ { "eid": "fiep", "name": "Family Income for Empowerment Program", "queries": [ "\"Family Income for Empowerment Program\" San Diego guaranteed income evaluation results", "FIEP San Diego County Child and Family Well-Being guaranteed income foster care prevention evaluation interim findings OEPA" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The County of San Diego's Office of Evaluation, Performance, and Analytics runs a lottery-based impact evaluation of FIEP whose report it expects in 2027, and JFS's August 2024 programs report gives only FIEP participants' baseline characteristics and spending." }, { "eid": "hipr", "name": "HIP (Humboldt Income Program)", "queries": [ "\"Humboldt Income Program\" guaranteed income pregnant McKinleyville results evaluation", "Urban Institute evaluation California guaranteed income pilot program CDSS pregnant former foster youth findings report", "Humboldt Income Program guaranteed income 2025 2026 participants outcomes report North Coast" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The McKinleyville pilot (150 pregnant people paid, about 100 controls given $20 a month) is a CDSS Guaranteed Income Pilot site in the Urban Institute and UC Berkeley evaluation, whose findings CDSS expects by summer 2028; no site results were found." }, { "eid": "brea", "name": "Breathe: LA County's Guaranteed Income Program", "queries": [ "Breathe LA County guaranteed income program evaluation results report", "\"Breathe\" guaranteed income Los Angeles County preliminary findings University of Pennsylvania 2025" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "Penn's Center for Guaranteed Income Research evaluates Breathe against a control group, and LA County says the full findings come out in early 2027; so far there is only a county statement that the money went mostly to food and household goods and MGI's dashboard of participant demographics and card spending, with no outcome report." }, { "eid": "breax1", "name": "LA County Breathe - Former Foster Youth Expansion 1 ", "queries": [ "Breathe guaranteed income former foster youth LA County evaluation findings Center for Guaranteed Income Research", "LA County former foster youth guaranteed income $1,000 two years study results randomized 2025 report" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The 200 randomly selected former foster youth are part of the Center for Guaranteed Income Research's Breathe evaluation, whose full findings LA County expects in early 2027; no results for this cohort were found, only news stories with individual accounts." }, { "eid": "taypo", "name": "TAYportunity Guaranteed Income Program", "queries": [ "TAYportunity guaranteed income transition age youth Los Angeles results Jain Family Institute", "\"LA Wellbeing Study\" guaranteed income youth results", "\"The Effects of Cash-Plus Programs on Young Adults\" randomized experiment Los Angeles County", "Cartledge job market paper cash transfers job training young adults Los Angeles randomized $1,000 per month" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/taypo_1.pdf", "url": "https://economics.virginia.edu/sites/uva-as-d10-economics/files/2025-10/Marcella%20Cartledge%20Abstract.pdf", "title": "Abstract of a job market paper on the TAYportunity randomized trial with the LA County Department of Public Social Services", "date": "2025-10", "evaluator": "University of Virginia, Department of Economics", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "food security", "housing", "financial wellbeing", "mental health", "fertility", "arrests", "employment", "income", "job satisfaction", "savings", "wealth" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "Only a one-page abstract (300 treated, 650 controls, six survey rounds plus administrative data) is public; the full paper, which the LA Wellbeing Study site lists as 'The Effects of Cash-Plus Programs on Young Adults: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment in Los Angeles County', was not found, and the study's preregistration is AEARCTR-0011791." }, { "eid": "boost", "name": "BOOST: Building Outstanding Opportunities for Students to Thrive", "queries": [ "BOOST guaranteed income Los Angeles community college students evaluation results Foundation for the Los Angeles Community Colleges", "BOOST guaranteed income LACCD interim report 2026 Center for Guaranteed Income Research students $1,000 findings" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The Center for Guaranteed Income Research runs a randomized evaluation; LACCD said to expect an interim report in May 2026 and a final one in spring 2027, but none is posted on the Center's publications page, and an AERA 2026 paper by district staff covers implementation only." }, { "eid": "paid", "name": "Pregnancy Assistance Income with Dignity (P.A.I.D.)", "queries": [ "Pregnancy Assistance Income with Dignity P.A.I.D. guaranteed income NCJW Los Angeles evaluation results", "Urban Institute evaluation California guaranteed income pilot program CDSS pregnant former foster youth findings report", "NCJW LA \"P.A.I.D.\" guaranteed income pregnant people Los Angeles findings 2025" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "P.A.I.D. is one of the seven CDSS Guaranteed Income Pilot sites that the Urban Institute and UC Berkeley evaluate as a randomized trial (AEARCTR-0014714; 1,928 recipients and 1,436 controls across sites); CDSS expects findings by summer 2028 and Urban's project page lists no publications yet." }, { "eid": "capb", "name": "California Abundant Birth Project", "queries": [ "\"California Abundant Birth Project\" Expecting Justice guaranteed income pregnant evaluation results", "Urban Institute evaluation California guaranteed income pilot program CDSS pregnant former foster youth findings report", "Abundant Birth Project California expansion randomized trial results 2026 birth outcomes mental health" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The California Abundant Birth Project's randomized evaluation by UC Berkeley, UC Davis and UCSF reported only baseline balance in its January 2025 update, and as a CDSS pilot site it is also in the Urban Institute evaluation expected by summer 2028; the published findings are from the earlier San Francisco pilot, not this one." }, { "eid": "uwic", "name": "Inland SoCal United Way (ISCUW) Guaranteed Income Pilot Program", "queries": [ "Inland Southern California United Way guaranteed income pilot pregnant former foster youth Riverside results Claremont McKenna", "Urban Institute evaluation California guaranteed income pilot program CDSS pregnant former foster youth findings report", "\"Inland SoCal United Way\" guaranteed income pilot findings report 2026" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "Inland SoCal United Way's pilot has a randomized control group and is a CDSS Guaranteed Income Pilot site in the Urban Institute and UC Berkeley evaluation (findings expected by summer 2028); no local evaluation results, from Claremont McKenna or anyone else, were found." }, { "eid": "uwco", "name": "United Way California Capital Region (UWCCR) Guaranteed Income Program Cohort 1", "queries": [ "United Way California Capital Region guaranteed income program Sacramento State evaluation report", "United Way California Capital Region guaranteed income 100 families $300 MacKenzie Scott results evaluation 2023", "United Way Sacramento first guaranteed income program 2021-2023 $300 100 families outcomes report" ], "documents": [], "status": "not found", "note": "No evaluation of the first cohort ($300 a month, 2021 to 2023) was found: United Way's and Sacramento State's pages list evaluation reports only for the 2023-24 City cohort and the 2024 County cohort, and an extended search found nothing more." }, { "eid": "uwct", "name": "United Way California Capital Region (UWCCR) Guaranteed Income Program Cohort 2", "queries": [ "United Way California Capital Region guaranteed income program Sacramento State evaluation report", "Sacramento State \"guaranteed income\" United Way white paper six months after payments ended" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/uwct_1.pdf", "url": "https://www.csus.edu/college/health-human-services/center-health-practice-policy-research/_internal/1_sacramento-state-report-for-united-way_final_web.pdf", "title": "Guaranteed Income Program 2.0, City of Sacramento: 1-Year Evaluation Report", "date": "2025-11", "evaluator": "California State University, Sacramento (School of Social Work)", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "financial wellbeing", "housing", "food security", "employment", "income volatility", "savings", "agency", "mental health", "physical health", "civic engagement" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/uwct_2.pdf", "url": "https://www.yourlocalunitedway.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Sac-State-GI-Cohort-2-Whitepaper.pdf", "title": "Reviewing gains 6-month out: Evaluation Report, Guaranteed Income Program 2.0 (white paper)", "date": "2025-10", "evaluator": "California State University, Sacramento (School of Social Work)", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "unclear", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "financial wellbeing", "housing", "food security", "debt", "employment", "agency", "mental health", "civic engagement" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "Sacramento State's 1-year evaluation (randomly selected recipients against a control group of applicants) and its six-month follow-up white paper; United Way also hosts an October 2025 copy of the same 1-year report." }, { "eid": "uwcr", "name": "United Way California Capital Region (UWCCR) Guaranteed Income Program Cohort 3", "queries": [ "United Way California Capital Region guaranteed income program Sacramento State evaluation report", "Sacramento County guaranteed income 130 residents Districts 1 and 2 $500 United Way 2024 evaluation results" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/uwcr_1.pdf", "url": "https://www.yourlocalunitedway.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Sacramento-State-Report-for-United-Way-2026_Final_WEB.pdf", "title": "Guaranteed Income Program, County of Sacramento: Sacramento County Evaluation Report", "date": "2026-06", "evaluator": "California State University, Sacramento (School of Social Work)", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "financial wellbeing", "housing", "food security", "employment", "income volatility", "agency", "mental health", "physical health" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "Sacramento State's evaluation of the County of Sacramento cohort (130 recipients chosen at random from applicants, compared with applicants not chosen at baseline, endline, and 18 months) was posted in June 2026; United Way's April 2024 cohort 3 data brief holds only baseline demographics." }, { "eid": "sand", "name": "San Diego for Every Child ", "queries": [ "\"San Diego for Every Child\" guaranteed income evaluation report results", "\"American Guaranteed Income Studies\" \"San Diego and National City\" guaranteed income findings" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/sand_1.pdf", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-SanDiego-CA", "title": "The American Guaranteed Income Studies: San Diego and National City, CA", "date": "2025-08", "evaluator": "Center for Guaranteed Income Research, University of Pennsylvania", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "income", "income volatility", "financial wellbeing", "food security", "savings", "housing", "employment", "physical health", "stress", "mental health", "parenting", "mattering", "hope" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "CGIR's August 2025 report on the SDEC randomized trial (150 treatment, 150 control, follow-up six months after payments) is the evaluation; the other hits were JFS summaries and news coverage." }, { "eid": "beem", "name": "BEEM: The Black Economic Equity Movement Project", "queries": [ "BEEM Black Economic Equity Movement guaranteed income randomized trial results UCSF", "\"Black Economic Equity Movement\" guaranteed income findings Black emerging adults 2025 OR 2026", "BEEM trial guaranteed income $500 Black emerging adults San Francisco Oakland results financial wellbeing mental health" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "Only the 2023 protocol of the randomized crossover trial (Frontiers in Public Health) and a 2024 paper on baseline housing instability and mental health are published; no outcome results were found, including by an extended search." }, { "eid": "wfub", "name": "Compass Family Service Basic Income Pilot", "queries": [ "Compass Family Services basic income pilot San Francisco Wells Fargo results", "\"Compass Family Services\" \"basic income\" pilot 13 families $350 report findings", "Compass Family Services Wells Fargo universal basic income pilot outcomes families Compass Children's Center" ], "documents": [], "status": "not found", "note": "Only Compass's launch announcement (which planned pre/post assessments with a non-participating comparison group) and a news story following one family were found, with no published results, including by an extended search." }, { "eid": "smcbb", "name": "San Mateo County Baby Bonus Pilot Program", "queries": [ "San Mateo County Baby Bonus pilot guaranteed income Stanford evaluation results", "\"Baby Bonus\" San Mateo County First 5 guaranteed income randomized results 2026" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The Baby Bonus randomized trial ($300 a month for three years to Medi-Cal parents of newborns, enrolling from 2025) is still running and has published no results." }, { "eid": "cschs", "name": "GBI for Unhoused High School Students", "queries": [ "Santa Clara County guaranteed basic income unhoused high school students evaluation results", "Santa Clara County Office of Supportive Housing guaranteed basic income baseline report young parents justice-involved unhoused students 2026" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The County's pilot randomly assigned students (75 paid, about 100 controls given services only, per San José Spotlight in February 2026) and was still paying in early 2026; only a baseline report has been presented (Board committee, August 2026), and no outcome results were found." }, { "eid": "cscyp", "name": "GBI for Young Parents", "queries": [ "Santa Clara County guaranteed basic income young parents pilot evaluation findings", "Santa Clara County Office of Supportive Housing guaranteed basic income baseline report young parents justice-involved unhoused students 2026" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The County's randomized young-parents pilot (almost 100 paid, 130 controls, per San José Spotlight in February 2026) was still paying in early 2026; only a baseline report has been presented (Board committee, August 2026), and no outcome results were found." }, { "eid": "dhrty", "name": "Re-Entry Guaranteed Income", "queries": [ "Destination Home re-entry guaranteed income Santa Clara County evaluation results", "Santa Clara County justice-involved guaranteed basic income pilot $1,200 recidivism results report", "Santa Clara County Office of Supportive Housing guaranteed basic income baseline report young parents justice-involved unhoused students 2026" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "This is the County's justice-involved (re-entry) pilot, randomized (110 paid, 190 controls, per San José Spotlight in February 2026) and still paying in early 2026; only a baseline report has been presented (Board committee, August 2026), and no outcome results were found." }, { "eid": "svgip", "name": "Silicon Valley Guaranteed Income Project", "queries": [ "Silicon Valley Guaranteed Income Project UCSF Benioff Homelessness and Housing Initiative findings", "\"Silicon Valley Guaranteed Income Project\" results report 2025 OR 2026" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "UCSF BHHI's mixed-methods RCT (NCT05698498; 150 families paid, about 150 controls) has no published findings in the searches or on Destination: Home's project page, which still describes the study and links only recruitment and consent materials." }, { "eid": "yobi", "name": "Yolo County Basic Income (YOBI)", "queries": [ "Yolo County Basic Income YOBI UC Davis Center for Regional Change evaluation report" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/yobi_1.pdf", "url": "https://regionalchange.ucdavis.edu/sites/g/files/dgvnsk986/files/inline-files/0031493_Booklet-YoloCounty_FINAL%20%28revised%29.pdf", "title": "Yolo Basic Income Evaluation Final Report, 2022-2024", "date": "2025-05", "evaluator": "UC Davis Center for Regional Change", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "no", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "housing", "mental health", "stress", "child outcomes", "financial wellbeing", "material hardship", "social cohesion" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/yobi_2.pdf", "url": "https://public.destinyhosted.com/yolocdocs/2025/BOS/20250225_3836/15070_BOS_YOBI_Participant_Integrated_Results.pdf", "title": "Yolo Basic Income Project (YOBI) Evaluation: participant integrated results (Board of Supervisors presentation)", "date": "2025-02-25", "evaluator": "UC Davis Center for Regional Change", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "unclear", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "housing", "financial wellbeing", "child outcomes", "stress" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/yobi_3.pdf", "url": "https://regionalchange.ucdavis.edu/sites/g/files/dgvnsk986/files/inline-files/Yolo%20County%20Basic%20Income%20Program%20Preliminary%20Data%20Report%20II_Kagawa.pdf", "title": "Yolo County Basic Income Program: Preliminary Data Report II", "date": "2023-07-10", "evaluator": "University of California, Davis", "kind": "interim report", "randomized_as_described": "no", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "housing", "material hardship", "neighborhood safety", "parenting" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/yobi_4.pdf", "url": "https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/23/4/417/pdf", "title": "\"I'd Probably Be Homeless\": Basic Income Participants' Lived Experiences Related to Housing Stability, Health, and Wellbeing (Int J Environ Res Public Health 23(4):417)", "date": "2026-03-26", "evaluator": "UC Davis Center for Regional Change", "kind": "article", "randomized_as_described": "unclear", "has_quantitative_outcomes": false, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "housing", "physical health", "mental health", "stress", "child outcomes" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "UC Davis's final report, interim data report, and county presentation compare YoBI families with a comparison group of CalWORKs families recruited for similar demographics (no random assignment described), and the 2026 article reports participant interviews only; the article PDF came from the Internet Archive's copy." }, { "eid": "stra", "name": "Smooth Transitions", "queries": [ "iFoster \"Smooth Transitions\" guaranteed income former foster youth California results", "Urban Institute evaluation California guaranteed income pilot program CDSS pregnant former foster youth findings report", "iFoster guaranteed income pilot former foster youth $750 18 months evaluation findings 2026" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "iFoster's statewide pilot for former foster youth is a CDSS Guaranteed Income Pilot site in the Urban Institute and UC Berkeley randomized evaluation, whose findings CDSS expects by summer 2028; nothing specific to this pilot is published." }, { "eid": "bwf1", "name": "Build With Families", "queries": [ "Gary Community Ventures \"Build With Families\" Denver $199 evaluation results", "\"Build With Families\" guaranteed income Colorado pilot", "\"Build With Families\" Gary Community Ventures Impact Charitable cash pilot Denver 2022" ], "documents": [], "status": "not found", "note": "Neither standard nor extended searches found any page, report, or news item about this program; the Basic Income Lab's row ($199 a month for 9 months to 110 Denver-area households) is the only description found." }, { "eid": "impa", "name": "I.M.P.A.C.T. (Income Mobility Program for Atlanta Community Transformation)", "queries": [ "IMPACT Atlanta guaranteed income Urban League of Greater Atlanta evaluation report results", "Abt Associates Atlanta I.M.P.A.C.T. guaranteed income pilot final evaluation report control group findings", "Atlanta guaranteed income pilot evaluation report Abt Global IMPACT" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/impa_1.pdf", "url": "https://guaranteedincome.us/images/childoutcomesreport.pdf", "title": "\"My kids deserve the world\": How children in the Southeast benefit from guaranteed income (MGI research brief)", "date": "2023-11", "evaluator": "Abt Associates", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": false, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "basic needs", "child outcomes", "education", "time use", "parenting", "mental health" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "The only Atlanta results found are in Abt's qualitative four-city brief (14 Atlanta interviewees; it says the impact study randomly assigned applicants), which MGI's Atlanta page offers as the pilot's evaluation report; no quantitative Atlanta impact report from Abt was found." }, { "eid": "crcp", "name": "Chicago Resilient Communities Pilot", "queries": [ "Chicago Resilient Communities Pilot evaluation results Inclusive Economy Lab guaranteed income", "\"Resilient Communities Pilot\" Chicago impact findings guaranteed income $500 study 2025", "Chicago guaranteed income pilot impact evaluation results Inclusive Economy Lab lottery recipients versus non-recipients employment mental health", "Chicago Resilient Communities Pilot guaranteed income impact study results released" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The Inclusive Economy Lab's lottery RCT has released only a baseline 'First Look' report (February 2023, applicants' characteristics before payments, so not listed), a process evaluation (October 2024), and a photovoice book; the Lab's October 2025 policymakers' report says its impact findings are still forthcoming." }, { "eid": "gipp", "name": "Guaranteed Income Pilot Program", "queries": [ "Evanston guaranteed income pilot program Northwestern evaluation results report", "Evanston guaranteed income pilot findings 2024 Guryan $500 monthly impact study", "Evanston Guaranteed Income Pilot Program evaluation findings Northwestern final report results" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "Northwestern researchers studied the pilot (150 recipients chosen by lottery, 503 applicants as a benchmark group), but an April 2026 Evanston RoundTable article reports that their report had still not been delivered to the city." }, { "eid": "give", "name": "Guaranteed Income Validation Effort (GIVE Gary)", "queries": [ "GIVE Gary guaranteed income validation effort evaluation report results", "\"Gary\" guaranteed income pilot GIVE final report Center for Guaranteed Income Research findings", "Gary Indiana G.I.V.E. guaranteed income pilot evaluation report findings participants" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/give_1.txt", "url": "https://www.nwitimes.com/news/local/lake/gary/watch-now-gary-completes-guaranteed-income-pilot-program-announces-wealth-series/article_52447681-9e6e-5615-9417-b2ed60e199f7.html", "title": "WATCH NOW: Gary completes guaranteed income pilot program; announces wealth series", "date": "2022-07-29", "evaluator": "The Times of Northwest Indiana (news report of figures given by the City of Gary and the GIVE program)", "kind": "web page", "randomized_as_described": "unclear", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "employment", "banking" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "No evaluation report was found (2021 coverage mentions a 156-person survey control group); the only outcome figures are program-reported recipient-only numbers in a news story (about 40% returned to work, a quarter opened a first bank account), saved from the Internet Archive copy because the site redirects to a paywall gate." }, { "eid": "root", "name": "The Rooted School: The 50 Dollar Study", "queries": [ "Rooted School \"$50\" study guaranteed income students Indianapolis results report", "\"$50 Study\" final report Rooted School Foundation randomized attendance savings" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/root_1.pdf", "url": "https://drive.google.com/file/d/1f9ZP-JPFmYQ9XlRDS1S5LPoxeHHk6V_1/view", "title": "The $50 Study: Outcomes from a dual-year randomized controlled trial", "date": "2026-07", "evaluator": "University of Tennessee, Knoxville and University of Pennsylvania Center for Guaranteed Income Research, with Rooted School Foundation", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "education", "financial wellbeing", "self-perception", "spending", "savings", "agency" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "Final RCT report pooling the Indianapolis and two New Orleans schools (about 380 students, 2022-24); saved the July 2026 update linked from fifty.cash, which fixes typos and one spending share in the version first released on 2025-07-22 (Google Drive file 1jaANdWkVu7GoCkLSKPwiD7mnv3daQZZi), and the earlier 2021-22 micro-pilot report is a different study, so it was not listed." }, { "eid": "chvg", "name": "Camp Harbor View Guaranteed Income Pilot", "queries": [ "Camp Harbor View guaranteed income pilot Boston UpTogether evaluation results", "Camp Harbor View Direct Cash Program evaluation Blakely Consulting control group findings" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/chvg_1.pdf", "url": "https://basicincome.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Direct-Cash-for-a-Better-Boston.pdf", "title": "Direct Cash for a Better Boston: A report on the first two years of Camp Harbor View's Direct Cash Program", "date": "2024-01", "evaluator": "Camp Harbor View (impact measured by Blakely Consulting; lottery administered by UMass Boston)", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "financial wellbeing", "savings", "mental health", "debt", "housing", "education", "employment", "time use" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "Short two-year summary comparing 50 lottery-selected families with an equal-size control group (e.g., emergency savings 45% vs 14%, psychological distress risk down 23% vs up 8%); interim treatment-control figures from 2022 Boston Globe coverage were not saved." }, { "eid": "pgip", "name": "Paterson Guaranteed Income Pilot Program", "queries": [ "Paterson guaranteed income pilot program results evaluation report $400" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/pgip_1.pdf", "url": "https://upenn.box.com/v/CGIR-Report-Paterson-NJ", "title": "The American Guaranteed Income Studies: Paterson, New Jersey", "date": "2023-12", "evaluator": "University of Pennsylvania Center for Guaranteed Income Research", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "food security", "financial wellbeing", "savings", "income volatility", "mental health", "household chaos", "employment", "time use", "parenting", "housing" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "CGIR's RCT report (identical to the copy in work/raw/grey/cgir and to the report on MGI's Paterson dashboard page); no other evaluation documents turned up." }, { "eid": "famp", "name": "Family Prosperity", "queries": [ "Family Prosperity guaranteed income Las Cruces NMSU evaluation results", "\"Family Prosperity\" Las Cruces guaranteed basic income report findings 2025", "Las Cruces Family Prosperity guaranteed income program NMSU evaluation report results" ], "documents": [], "status": "no results published", "note": "The Community Action Agency of Southern New Mexico's FAQ says NMSU's Crimson Research will issue a report at the end of the 18-month project (150 lottery-selected recipient families, 150 comparison families), and no report or results were found." }, { "eid": "nybp", "name": "The Bridge Project", "queries": [ "The Bridge Project Monarch Foundation guaranteed income evaluation report results mothers New York", "\"Bridge Project\" guaranteed income findings report Center for Guaranteed Income Research randomized mothers infants", "The Bridge Project New York guaranteed income evaluation findings report CGIR randomized controlled trial results" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/nybp_1.pdf", "url": "https://drive.google.com/file/d/1fn8epRwy9cewIhElnJJx-R0VJXp4oBgR/view", "title": "The Case for Cash: Early Investment in Moms Improves Prospects for Babies", "date": "2024", "evaluator": "The Bridge Project (cohort 1 RCT by the University of Pennsylvania Center for Guaranteed Income Research; cohort 2 and 3 findings by the Bridge Project)", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "savings", "financial wellbeing", "child care", "household chaos", "housing", "food security", "spending" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/nybp_2.pdf", "url": "https://drive.google.com/file/d/1AdmGlOhjVsNJxzNAEj4sWSINxh8bW457/view", "title": "Cash as a Catalyst: Unleashing the Educational Potential of Low-Income Mothers", "date": "2025", "evaluator": "The Bridge Project", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "no", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "education" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "No full CGIR report was found; the 2024 brief (cited by Penn's Center for High Impact Philanthropy) gives cohort 1 RCT results against a control group plus the program's own cohort 2 and 3 figures, the 2025 snapshot gives descriptive education figures pooling New York, Connecticut and Milwaukee, and a 2025 Impact Report exists only as an Issuu viewer document." }, { "eid": "lugi", "name": "Level Up Guaranteed Income Pilot ", "queries": [ "Level Up guaranteed income pilot Mount Vernon evaluation results report", "Mount Vernon \"Level Up\" guaranteed income findings 2025 participants study food rent savings", "Mount Vernon Level Up guaranteed income pilot evaluation report findings", "Abt Associates \"Level Up\" Mount Vernon guaranteed income evaluation results" ], "documents": [], "status": "not found", "note": "The city's page says Abt Associates evaluates the pilot as a randomized trial (200 recipients, 275 controls), but no report or results were found, and a February 2026 op-ed co-signed by the mayor says the pilot was evaluated without citing any results." }, { "eid": "trus", "name": "Trust Youth Initiative: Direct Cash Transfers to Address Young Adult Homelessness", "queries": [ "Trust Youth Initiative Point Source Youth direct cash transfer Chapin Hall evaluation report", "\"Trust Youth Initiative\" findings report young adults homelessness cash New York 2025" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/trus_1.pdf", "url": "https://www.chapinhall.org/wp-content/uploads/Chapin-Hall_NYC-Pathways-Study-Findings_July-2025.pdf", "title": "Evaluation of the NYC Trust Youth Initiative: Summary of Findings from the NYC Pathways Study", "date": "2025-07", "evaluator": "Chapin Hall at the University of Chicago", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "housing", "homelessness", "food security", "financial wellbeing", "education", "employment" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "Chapin Hall's July 2025 brief reports implementation and impact findings from the NYC Pathways Study, in which 34 of 78 enrolled young adults were invited to the cash-plus program by biased-coin randomization and the rest received services as usual, with the authors noting the sample was too small for adequate power." }, { "eid": "phlh", "name": "PHLHousing+", "queries": [ "PHLHousing+ evaluation report Housing Initiative at Penn findings", "PHLHousing+ research brief pdf housing security cash randomized Philadelphia Housing Development Corporation" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/phlh_1.pdf", "url": "https://www.housinginitiative.org/uploads/1/3/2/9/132946414/hip_phlh_housingoutcomes_brief.pdf", "title": "PHLHousing+ Housing Security Outcomes After Two Years: A Randomized Control Trial of a Cash Rental Assistance Program in Philadelphia, PA", "date": "2025-08", "evaluator": "Housing Initiative at Penn and Risk & Resilience Lab (University of Pennsylvania), with the Philadelphia Housing Development Corporation", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "housing", "homelessness", "forced moves", "housing quality", "subsidy use" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/phlh_2.pdf", "url": "https://www.housinginitiative.org/uploads/1/3/2/9/132946414/hip_phlh_cashandvouchers_impactonhousinginsecurity.pdf", "title": "Cash and Vouchers: The Impact of Different Forms of Rental Assistance on Housing Insecurity", "date": "2025-08", "evaluator": "University of Pennsylvania (Housing Initiative at Penn, Department of Psychology) with the Philadelphia Housing Development Corporation", "kind": "working paper", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "housing", "homelessness", "forced moves", "housing quality", "subsidy use" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "Two-year housing results of the trial, which randomly assigned households from the housing authority's waitlist to cash, housing voucher, or control groups, are out as an August 2025 brief and working paper; a 2024 Cityscape article on the program's design reports no outcomes and is not listed." }, { "eid": "agip", "name": "Austin's Guaranteed Income Pilot Program", "queries": [ "Austin Guaranteed Income Pilot evaluation report findings UpTogether Urban Institute", "urban.org Austin Guaranteed Income Pilot final evaluation report pdf" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/agip_1.pdf", "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2024-12/Evaluation_of_the_Austin_Guaranteed_Income_Pilot.pdf", "title": "Evaluation of the Austin Guaranteed Income Pilot", "date": "2024-12", "evaluator": "Urban Institute, with Jain Family Institute", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "no", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "housing", "food security", "employment", "income", "mental health", "spending" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "The Urban Institute's December 2024 final report states the study is not a randomized controlled trial: it follows participants through four surveys and benchmarks them against Household Pulse Survey data for low-income Texans." }, { "eid": "hoef", "name": "Houston Equity Fund", "queries": [ "Houston Equity Fund guaranteed income pilot results The Houston Fund $375", "Houston guaranteed income pilot 110 residents Mayors for a Guaranteed Income findings report Houston Fund for Social Justice and Economic Equity", "Houston guaranteed income pilot $375 per month 110 participants 2022-2023 evaluation results report" ], "documents": [], "status": "not found", "note": "Two standard searches and one extended search found only the May 2022 launch coverage of the Houston Fund for Social Justice and Economic Equity's 110-person, $375-a-month pilot, and no evaluation or results; Mayors for a Guaranteed Income's site has no Houston page." }, { "eid": "argu", "name": "Arlington's Guarantee", "queries": [ "Arlington's Guarantee guaranteed income pilot final report evaluation findings", "\"Arlington's Guarantee\" final report pdf Arlington Community Foundation evaluation comparison group employment income" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/argu_1.pdf", "url": "https://www.arlcf.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Arlingtons-Guarantee-Final-Report-Feb.-2024.pdf", "title": "Arlington's Guarantee Pilot Evaluation", "date": "2024-02", "evaluator": "Arlington Community Foundation and Arlington County Department of Human Services (Urban Institute gave technical support)", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "employment", "income", "basic needs", "food security", "housing", "debt", "stress", "physical health", "mental health", "belonging" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "The February 2024 report, found on the foundation's site (elsewhere only on Issuu), says county staff randomly divided the eligible pool into 200 cash recipients and 100 comparison households, while also saying the foundation chose not to contract a full RCT." }, { "eid": "bifa", "name": "Basic Income for the Arts", "queries": [ "Basic Income for the Arts pilot Ireland impact evaluation report results control group", "gov.ie Basic Income for the Arts impact assessment report year two pdf Department of Culture" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/bifa_1.pdf", "url": "https://assets.gov.ie/static/documents/b5e28681/Basic_Income_for_the_Arts_-_Impact_Assessment_2_years.pdf", "title": "Basic Income for the Arts Impact Assessment (2 years)", "date": "2025-09", "evaluator": "Irish Government Economic and Evaluation Service, Department of Culture, Communications and Sport", "kind": "interim report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "arts work", "employment", "income", "time use", "mental health", "life satisfaction", "deprivation" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/bifa_2.pdf", "url": "https://assets.gov.ie/static/documents/basic-income-for-the-arts-impact-assessment-first-year.pdf", "title": "Basic Income for the Arts Impact Assessment (First year)", "date": "2024-05", "evaluator": "Irish Government Economic and Evaluation Service, Department of Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media", "kind": "interim report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "arts work", "employment", "income", "time use", "mental health", "life satisfaction", "deprivation" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/bifa_3.pdf", "url": "https://assets.gov.ie/static/documents/basic-income-for-the-arts-initial-impact-assessment-6-month.pdf", "title": "Basic Income for the Arts Initial Impact Assessment (6-month)", "date": "2023-12", "evaluator": "Irish Government Economic and Evaluation Service, Department of Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media", "kind": "interim report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "arts work", "employment", "time use", "mental health", "life satisfaction" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/bifa_4.pdf", "url": "https://assets.gov.ie/static/documents/b87d2659/20250929_BIA_CBA_Final_Report.pdf", "title": "Cost-benefit analysis for the Basic Income for the Arts", "date": "2025-09", "evaluator": "not named in the report (prepared for the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport)", "kind": "final report", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "arts work", "employment", "income", "time use", "mental health", "life satisfaction", "deprivation", "cost-benefit" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "The government's trial randomly selected 2,000 recipients and 1,000 controls from eligible applicants in September 2022 and has 6-month, first-year, and two-year impact assessments plus a September 2025 cost-benefit analysis; a qualitative interviews report (2025) on the same reports page is not listed." }, { "eid": "germ", "name": "Pilotprojekt Grundeinkommen ", "queries": [ "Pilotprojekt Grundeinkommen DIW Berlin results randomized basic income study 1200 euros findings", "Bohmann Fiedler Kasy Schupp Schwerter basic income pilot Germany working paper English results" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/germ_1.pdf", "url": "https://www.diw.de/documents/publikationen/73/diw_01.c.945392.de/25-15-1.pdf", "title": "Pilotprojekt Grundeinkommen: kein Rückzug vom Arbeitsmarkt, aber bessere mentale Gesundheit (DIW Wochenbericht 15/2025)", "date": "2025-04-09", "evaluator": "DIW Berlin (German Institute for Economic Research)", "kind": "brief", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "employment", "time use", "savings", "spending", "mental health", "life satisfaction", "agency" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/germ_2.pdf", "url": "https://www.diw.de/documents/publikationen/73/diw_01.c.960424.de/dp2123.pdf", "title": "Basic Income and Labor Supply: Evidence from an RCT in Germany (DIW Discussion Paper 2123)", "date": "2025-06-16", "evaluator": "DIW Berlin (German Institute for Economic Research)", "kind": "working paper", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "employment", "time use", "income", "education" ] }, { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/germ_3.pdf", "url": "https://www.diw.de/documents/publikationen/73/diw_01.c.968161.de/dp2129.pdf", "title": "Cash Transfers, Mental Health, and Agency: Evidence from an RCT in Germany (DIW Discussion Paper 2129)", "date": "2026-03-23", "evaluator": "DIW Berlin (German Institute for Economic Research)", "kind": "working paper", "randomized_as_described": "yes", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "mental health", "stress", "life satisfaction", "agency", "wellbeing" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "DIW Berlin's preregistered RCT (107 recipients of 1,200 euros a month against 1,580 controls) reported core findings in German in April 2025 and in two English discussion papers, on labor supply (June 2025) and on mental health and agency (updated March 2026); all three PDFs came from the Internet Archive because DIW refuses direct downloads." }, { "eid": "cook", "name": "Cook County Promise Guaranteed Income Pilot", "queries": [ "Cook County Promise Guaranteed Income Pilot evaluation results", "Cook County Promise guaranteed income Inclusive Economy Lab impact findings randomized", "\"Promise Pilot\" Cook County Inclusive Economy Lab impact report 2026 guaranteed income randomized results employment health" ], "documents": [ { "file": "work/raw/grey/pilots/cook_1.txt", "url": "https://www.cookcountyil.gov/news/president-preckwinkle-unveils-next-phase-guaranteed-income-cook-county", "title": "President Preckwinkle Unveils Next Phase of Guaranteed Income in Cook County", "date": "2025-04-08", "evaluator": "Cook County (participant survey by GiveDirectly, the program administrator)", "kind": "web page", "randomized_as_described": "no", "has_quantitative_outcomes": true, "outcomes_mentioned": [ "financial security", "stress", "mental health", "debt", "credit score" ] } ], "status": "found", "note": "Only self-reported results from a survey of participants (county release, April 2025) are public; the Inclusive Economy Lab's lottery-based RCT has published a baseline descriptive snapshot and a process evaluation and called its impact findings forthcoming in October 2025, and Econsult's April 2025 study only models local spending effects, so none of those is listed." } ] } }