November 16, 2026
Two corrected trial entries tilt a heart-valve comparison slightly toward the catheter procedure
An audit of a six-trial analysis found that two entries counted any stroke where the analysis called for disabling stroke, and fixing them shifts the result, though on fragile footing.
A recently published analysis that pooled six clinical trials comparing two ways of replacing the heart's aortic valve used the wrong kind of stroke count for two of its trials, a new paper reports. With the intended counts swapped in, the catheter-based procedure looks somewhat better than surgery at one year. The paper is clear that this does not prove it is the better treatment.
