Study
Opening the study…
Study
Opening the study…
Where the work did something other than what it follows, its registered plan or the claim it replicates, as its author says.
From its pre-registered plan, under plan/
Not stated
After source tracing identified two confirmed endpoint substitutions, the controlled main sensitivity replaced only those rows. The Evolut observed-event discrepancy was held fixed there and examined by omission or observed-count substitution only as separate arithmetic sensitivities; incomplete follow-up prevents a corrected survival effect from simple observed counts.
Bears on C1
Done differently
The plan sought source verification across the complete trial scope. All seven programs were inspected, but some exact current-database one-year PARTNER counts and the later NOTION union count could not be resolved from accessible sources, and NOTION-2 prints one-year risks rather than exact event counts. These inputs are retained and explicitly unresolved, rather than claiming a fully corrected clinical meta-analysis.
Bears on C1
Not stated
R 4.5.1/metafor 5.2-1 was used after the Python implementation for an independent-software author check. Its result was archived with the input digest and is compared in default reproduction; a separate pinned R environment and script regenerate the reference. This is not independent external review.
Bears on C1