Study
Opening the study…
Study
Opening the study…
The studies most like this one, by the words that set it apart, then the fields they share and the work they cite.
A gravitational analogy for depression (Kent 2023) distinguishes slowed time within the moment, local dilation, from desynchronisation against the shared day, a clock whose phase wanders or drifts relative to a distant reference. An earlier registered analysis of the same participants found flatter, less stable and more persistent daily activity with more depressive symptoms. Here we registered a test of the timing itself in 5855 US adults with at least four complete days of wrist accelerometry in NHANES 2011-2014. With more depressive symptoms, the clock hour of peak activity varied more from day to day (standardised coefficient 0.059) and drifted more steadily across days (0.0274), beyond amplitude and total activity. Both effects held on weekdays alone, and peak activity was later. Desynchronisation of the daily rhythm accompanies depressive symptoms, though the effects are small.
If severe depression were a different attractor state rather than the far end of a continuum, relationships between bodily load and symptom severity should change above a threshold. We tested this in a registered analysis of 14722 adults in the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) with PHQ-9 scores. Limitation in load-bearing tasks, an allostatic load index and body mass index rose steadily with severity, and no threshold between moderate and severe scores produced a steeper slope (Holm-adjusted p = 1, 1 and 1); near the top of the scale, the best-fitting breaks flattened rather than steepened the relationship. Height, a negative control, showed no break. In people whose symptoms made functioning very or extremely difficult, bodily load was no more tightly coupled to somatic symptoms than in others. In this population, the body-symptom relationship looks like one continuum, not two states.
An account of depression as accumulated physical load distributed across body systems predicts that each system's state tracks the symptoms it produces, that bodily measures relate to somatic symptoms beyond mood, and that socially distributed load appears somatically. We tested these predictions in a registered analysis of 14722 adults in the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), relating limitation in load-bearing tasks, slow bowel transit, body mass index (BMI), an allostatic load index and income to PHQ-9 depressive symptom items. Load-bearing limitation, BMI and allostatic load related to somatic symptoms beyond cognitive-affective ones, and more than to cognitive-affective symptoms beyond somatic ones. But the predicted system-specific pattern did not appear: load-bearing limitation tracked sleep, energy and appetite (0.2946) far more than slow transit did (0.0404). Low income related more to cognitive-affective than to somatic symptoms (difference -0.0996). Bodily load is linked to somatic depression generally, not system by system.
Ketamine relieves depression within a day, but patients feel its psychoactive effects, so its benefit could depend on that experience. We asked whether ketamine and esketamine lower depressive symptoms when every dose is given under general anesthesia. Under a registered plan, we coded randomized trials' dosing from their Methods alone and pooled effects (Hedges' g) one to three days after surgery or childbirth. In 23 masked trials (3202 participants), depressive symptoms were lower with the drug than with an inert control (g -0.61, confidence interval -0.81 to -0.4; Holm-adjusted p < 0.001), though trials varied widely. Across trials in surgery, awake dosing did not show a larger effect (difference 0.12, -0.24 to 0.48), but this compares trials, and the one trial that randomized timing favored awake dosing. Masked doses also lowered pain. Ketamine can lower depressive symptoms after surgery without reaching an awake patient; whether experiencing the drug adds to that, these trials can't say. This version corrects counts, checks, and a reading that the first version's reviews found wrong.
If depression deepens an attractor, the body should return to equilibrium more slowly after a perturbation, with lingering elevation and more autocorrelated fluctuations during recovery ("critical slowing down"). We tested this in a registered analysis of an open laboratory dataset in which community adults completed a Stroop stressor while ECG and continuous blood pressure were recorded, and reported depressive symptoms on the CES-D. In 170 participants, higher depressive symptoms predicted neither higher late-recovery heart rate (standardised coefficient -0.0094) or systolic pressure (-0.058), given baseline and stress levels, nor a larger rise in beat-to-beat autocorrelation from baseline to recovery. If anything, participants screening positive had lower late-recovery systolic pressure, and higher symptoms went with a blunted heart-rate response. In this sample, depressive symptoms did not slow physiological recovery.